241
243
1 M O R N I N G S E S S I O N
2
3 (The following takes place in the absence of the
4 jury.)
5 THE COURT: Mr. Trabulus, you wanted to speak to
6 me?
7 MR. TRABULUS: Very briefly, your Honor.
8 THE COURT: Mr. Trabulus, before you give me your
9 brief dissertation, I don't like to keep the jury
10 waiting. Have I gotten that impression across?
11 MR. TRABULUS: Yes.
12 THE COURT: There are 18 citizens who are giving
13 up of their time. I don't like to keep them waiting. If
14 you have anything you want to tell me, do it before 9:30.
15 MR. TRABULUS: Your Honor, at --
16 THE COURT: Excuse me.
17 At any time you want to talk to me, I will be
18 glad to talk to you, 9:00, 8:00, 7:00 in the morning, not
19 at 9:30. Go ahead at this time because I am giving you
20 notice.
21 Mr. Neville, be on time.
22 Where is Mr. Neville? Is he here?
23 MR. DUNN: Yes.
24 THE COURT: I guess I didn't make an impression
25 with the other ten-defendant case I told you about.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
244
1 Go ahead.
2 MR. TRABULUS: Your Honor, the government now
3 furnished to me the document on which I based the
4 objection that your Honor ruled on yesterday. That
5 objection is wi thdrawn.
6 Also, I have not had a chance to make multiple
7 copies of it, I will not have multiple copies for the
8 jury. That's all I wanted to say.
9 THE COURT: From now on I will be glad to talk to
10 you at any time. I don't want to tell you 6:00 o'clock in
11 the morning. I can talk to you at that time also. But
12 7:00 o'clock, 8:00 o'clock, 9:00 o'clock, but not 9:30.
13 Bring in the jury, please.
14 Mr. Neville, be on time from now on.
15 MR. NEVILLE: Yes, your Honor. I am sorry.
16 MR. WHITE: Your Honor, I wanted to tell you that
17 we tabbed the portions in the books with respect to
18 exhibits we expect to use today. With the Court's
19 permission, over the weekend we will take it back and have
20 it completely tabbed.
21 THE COURT: Good.
22 MR. WHITE: We aim to please, your Honor.
23 THE COURT: So do I.
24 Where is this book you tabbed?
25 MR. WHITE: I put them on the top of the boxes
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
245
1 there.
2 THE COURT: This one, you mean?
3 MR. WHITE: Yes, the exhibits we expect to use
4 today are here.
5 THE COURT: Very good.
6 MR. WHITE: These are ones, we just added, and
7 that may be referred to today.
8 THE COURT: It would be helpful if you can give
9 copies of the exhibits to the court reporter who could
10 follow better if he had copies of the exhibits. It would
11 help him. I am sure you want to do that.
12 THE CLERK: Jury entering. Please rise.
13 (Whereupon, the jury at this time entered the
14 courtroom.)
15 THE COURT: Good morning members of the punctual,
16 responsible, dedicated jury. Please be seated.
17 Thank you very much. I appreciate it that you
18 all got here on t ime. I had to take something up with the
19 lawyers, or we would have had you in at 9:30 sharp.
20 Where is the witness?
21 MR. WHITE: Right here, your Honor.
22
23
24
25
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
246
1 F R A N K G A G L I A R D I ,
2 called as a witness, having been previously
3 duly sworn, was examined and testified as
4 follows:
5
6 THE COURT: You are previously sworn and you are
7 still under oath, Mr. Gagliardi.
8 You may proceed.
9 MR. WHITE: Thank you, your Honor.
10
11 DIRECT EXAMINATION (cont'd)
12 BY MR. WHITE:
13 Q Mr. Gagliardi, when we broke yesterday you told us
14 that you were assigned in 1993 to evaluate an offer in
15 compromise that was submitted by Mr. Gordon to the IRS; is
16 that correct?
17 A That's correct.
18 Q Let me show you Government's Exhibit 420, which I
19 believe you identified yesterday as that offer in
20 compromise; is that correct?
21 A That's correct.
22 MR. WHITE: With the Court's permission, I have
23 copies of this multi-page document to hand out to the jury
24 so they can follow along the testimony.
25 THE COURT: Very well.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
247
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 We always start on this side. Let's get the
2 protocol right.
3 MR. WHITE: This side.
4 THE COURT: Since I am old fashioned, start on
5 this side, start with juror number one and his group, and
6 then juror number seven and his group. Then we get to the
7 two gentlemen in the front. That's the way it is going to
8 be done.
9 MR. WHITE: That's fine, your Honor.
10 THE COURT: All uniform, protocol.
11 Go ahead.
12 (Whereupon, the exhibit/exhibits were published
13 to the jury.)
14 Q Mr. Gagliardi, if you can turn to the attachment of
15 this document, which is marked Exhibit 420-C. Do you have
16 that?
17 A Yes, I do.
18 Q Can you tell us what that is?
19 A It is Form 2848, power of attorney form, for
20 Mr. Bruce Gordon.
21 Q Can you tell us what a power of attorney form is?
22 A A power of attorney allows a representative on behalf
23 of the taxpayer to deal with the Internal Revenue Service,
24 an attorney or accountant or enrolled agent.
25 Q For what taxpayer is this Form 420-C?
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
248
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 A Mr. Gordon.
2 Q Can you tell us who it is he is appointing to be his
3 representative in this case?
4 A It says Martin Reffsin.
5 Q And where is that?
6 A Section 2.
7 Q If you can look at page 2 of that document, and the
8 boxes at the bottom, can you tell us what it says there?
9 A It says delegation (sic), insert the letter A to H,
10 and then it says B, certified public accountant, and to
11 show the jurisdiction shown below.
12 Q What is the jurisdiction?
13 A New York.
14 Q Can you read the signature -- is there a signature?
15 A Yes.
16 Q Can you read it?
17 A It appears to be Martin Reffsin, December 17, 1992.
18 Q If you look over to the top page of the document,
19 now.
20 Whose letterhead is it written on, that letter?
21 A M. Reffsin and Company, certified public accountants.
22 Q Could you read the first sentence --
23 A The first sentence?
24 Q Of the body of the letter.
25 A The above referenced taxpayer has been assessed
H ARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
249
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 Section 6672 penalties, income tax plus interest and
2 penalties and also promote penalties under Section 6700
3 and 6701.
4 Q Tell us what Section 6672 penalties are?
5 MR. TRABULUS: Objection.
6 THE COURT: What ground?
7 MR. TRABULUS: May we approach?
8 THE COURT: Relevancy?
9 MR. TRABULUS: Yes, and prejudicial grounds.
10 THE COURT: Sustained.
11 This is all before this case?
12 MR. WHITE: What gives rise to the tax liability.
13 THE COURT: We will not get into it in great
14 detail.
15 Move along.
16 Q Could you read aloud to us the second paragraph of
17 the letter?
18 THE COURT: When you read, slow down,
19 Mr. Gagliardi.
20 THE WITNESS: I am sorry.
21 THE COURT: Everybody has a tendency to read
22 faster than they speak. They speak fast enough, when they
23 read they really speed it up, so slow down.
24 THE WITNESS: Yes, your Honor.
25 Taxpayer is presently trying to clean up his life
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
250
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 and move forward. He is 60 years of age and he will never
2 be able to pay substantial sums of taxes, penalties and
3 interest owed to the government. In addition, he is
4 liable for substantial amounts to other parties which he
5 will not be able to pay. We have prepared a projection of
6 income for the next five years, and even if he increases
7 his earnings substantially over the next five years, he
8 won't come close to earning enough to pay all his
9 obligations.
10 Q If you can skip down to the fourth paragraph and read
11 that allowed to us.
12 A In view of the circumstances d iscussed above, and the
13 fact that the taxpayer is over 60 years of age, he wishes
14 to file the attached offer in compromise. He has talked
15 to various relatives, and because of his age and desire to
16 clean up his situation, they have agreed to lend him some
17 money. The offer is presented -- the offer presented is
18 based on the sum of money which he feels he can borrow.
19 He has no other assets.
20 Q And could you read the top of the next page as well?
21 A I, Bruce Gordon, do hereby declare the above to be
22 true and correct to the best of my knowledge. Bruce
23 Gordon signature.
24 Q Now, if you turn to the next page, which is
25 Exhibit 420A, can you tell us what that form is?
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
251
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 A Form 656, offer in compromise, and it says Bruce
2 Gordon, 10 Bl uff Road, Glen Cove, New York, 11542.
3 Q Tell us in summary what is offered with respect to
4 this document?
5 A In summary he offered $150,000 to compromise the
6 total tax liability.
7 Q And on this form is there a signature line for the
8 taxpayer?
9 A Yes, there is.
10 Q And where is that?
11 A On the bottom right.
12 Q Is it signed and dated?
13 A Yes, it is.
14 Q What is the date?
15 A August 9, 1993.
16 Q Can you read what it says above the taxpayer
17 signature.
18 A It says: Under penalties of perjury, I declare that
19 I have examined this offer, including accompanying
20 schedules and statements, and to the best of my knowledge
21 and belief, it is true, correct and complete.
22 Q If you take a look at 420-D, and it is a few pages
23 beyond that?
24 A D as in David?
25 Q Yes.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
252
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 A Okay.
2 Q Now, what is that, 420-D?
3 A Form 433-A, collection and information statement for
4 individuals.
5 Q What does it say in box one?
6 A Bruce Gordon, 10 Bluff Road, Glen Cove, New York,
7 11768.
8 Q Look at box five, what does it say?
9 A Taxpayers employer, business name and address.
10 Q What is listed?
11 A Who's Who Worldwide Registry, Inc., 1983 Marcus
12 Avenue, Lake Success, New York, 11042.
13 Q In box F, what are the choices the box can check?
14 A As wage earner, sole proprietor or partner.
15 Q And what is checked?
16 A Wage earner.
17 Q And at the bottom of the page in box 12(b), what does
18 that ask for?
19 A Adjusted gross income.
20 Q What is listed by Mr. Gordon?
21 A 51,876 for the year 1991.
22 Q If you turn to the next page, question 14 at the top,
23 what does that ask for?
24 A Bank charge cards, credit unions, savings and loans,
25 I am sorry if I am going too fast, and lines of credit.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
253
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 Q Is there an American Express Gold Card listed there?
2 A No, there is not.
3 Q What is listed there?
4 A The word "none" is written there.
5 Q Look down at question 18. What kind of information
6 is in that box?
7 A Securities, stocks, bonds, mutual funds, money market
8 funds, government securities, etcetera.
9 Q Now, are there any shares of Who's Who Worldwide
10 Registry listed there?
11 A No.
12 Q Any shares of any company listed there?
13 A No.
14 Q What is listed there?
15 A It says none.
16 Q Turn to the next page, page 3, where it says assets
17 and liability analysis, do you see that?
18 A Yes.
19 Q Can you tell us what assets Mr. Gordon lists?
20 A $500 in cash.
21 Q Any other assets?
22 A None.
23 Q Look at box number 28, where it says other
24 liabilities, including judgments, notes and other charge
25 accounts, any liabilities listed?
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
254
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 A Yes, there are.
2 Q Among the ones listed, are any loans to Mr. Gordon
3 from Who's Who Worldwide Registry or any other companies,
4 or loans listed?
5 A No, it doesn't appear to be.
6 Q Turn to the next page, page 4, where it says monthly
7 income and expense analysis, does Mr. Gordon list his
8 monthly expenses?
9 A Yes, he does.
10 Q Tell us what he lists?
11 A He lists rent of $2,000, utilities of $250,
12 transportation, 150, insurance 50 for home. Court ordered
13 payments, it says not able to pay. And $70 in other
14 expenses.
15 Q At the bottom, can you read the box that says
16 certification -- I am sorry, in the middle, the box that
17 says certification.
18 A It says: Under penalties of perjury, I declare that
19 to the best of my knowledge and belief this statement of
20 assets, liabilities and other information is true, correct
21 and complete.
22 Q What is the date of the signature there?
23 A July 8th, '93.
24 Q If you can turn to the next page of the document,
25 420-E.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
255
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 Can you tell us what that is?
2 A It is a five-year projection of income -- actual,
3 actual expenses and income, 1991 through 1996.
4 Q Now, can you tell us what it says Mr. Gordon's annual
5 salary was in '91 and '92?
6 A On the very top left, $50,000 in actual annual salary
7 in 1991 and '92.
8 Q What does it project his annual salary would be in
9 the following years?
10 A 1993, 100,000; 1994, 125 -- 125,000. 1993, 100,000,
11 1994, 125,000, 1995, 150,000, 1976, 175,000.
12 Q If you can look down at the column on the far left
13 side, does it list Mr. Gordon's expenses and debts for
14 those years also?
15 A Yes, it did.
16 Q Can you list what expenses and other debts he has.
17 A It lists rent. Do you want the amounts?
18 Q No, just categories.
19 A Rent, groceries, electric and gas, telephone,
20 insurance, which is broken into home, life,
21 hospitalization and other; travel expense, gas and
22 maintenance; other expenses, cleaning, taxes, in
23 parenthesi s, withholding; payments to wife by court order;
24 outstanding judgments, required payments pursuant to
25 agreement with Justice Department.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
256
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 Q Is there a net cash flow listed for Mr. Gordon?
2 A Yes, there is.
3 Q Can you tell us what is a net cash flow?
4 A A net cash flow for purposes of statement like this
5 indicates how much a taxpayer has after paying all of his
6 expenses.
7 Q Tell us what is listed there for 1991?
8 A It shows that Mr. Gordon had a net deficit of 11,356.
9 Q What does it mean that he had a net deficit?
10 A Paying out more than he earned. I am sorry, 366.
11 Q What is the annual cash flow or deficit projected for
12 1992.
13 A It shows deficit of 15,864.
14 Q And tell us what is projected for the years '93
15 throu gh '96?
16 THE COURT: What is the difference? Why is that
17 important?
18 MR. WHITE: Okay.
19 THE COURT: Let's move along, Mr. White.
20 Q Take a look at the same document, 420-E, does it
21 indicate on the schedule that Mr. Gordon is required to
22 repay loans from Who's Who Worldwide?
23 A No, it is not listed.
24 Q Does it indicate anywhere that any of his expenses
25 are being paid by Who's Who Worldwide?
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
257
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 A No.
2 Q Now, if you could turn to 420-H -- I am sorry, 420-G,
3 like in George.
4 Do you have it now?
5 A Yes, I do.
6 Q Tell us what that is?
7 A It is on a Who's Who Worldwide stationery, and it is
8 compensation agreement between Bruce Gordon and the
9 shareholders of Who's Who Worldwide Registry, Inc.
1 0 Q And at the bottom, can you read what the date of it
11 is?
12 A It says agreed to by the undersigned on this 26th day
13 of January, 1993. But the 3 is either crossed out, or it
14 was written over.
15 Q Now, if you can turn to the page, the next attachment
16 is 420-H; is that correct?
17 A Yes.
18 Q What is that?
19 A An agreement, United States Department of Justice,
20 Tax Division, collateral agreement on future income.
21 Q Can you read the first paragraph for us -- I am
22 sorry, the paragraph that begins, the purpose of.
23 A Okay.
24 The purpose of this collateral agreement,
25 hereinafter referred to as this agreement, is to provide
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
258
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 additional consideration for acceptance of the offer in
2 compromise described above. It is unde rstood and
3 agreed -- you want me to go on?
4 Q Read the paragraph numbered one.
5 A That the taxpayer will pay out of annual income for
6 the years 1991 to 2000 inclusive, nothing on the first
7 $25,000 of annual income; 10 percent of annual income more
8 than 25,000, and not more than 35,000;
9 20 percent of annual income more than 35,000, not
10 more than 50,000.
11 D is 50 percent of annual income more than
12 $50,000.
13 Q Turn the page and look at paragraph three.
14 Without reading it, would you just review it and
15 tell us in substance what that says.
16 (Whereupon, at this time there was a pause in the
17 proceedings.)
18 A In brief, the taxpayer owns a closely held business
19 that the income from that business would be included for
20 the terms of this collateral agreement.
21 Q Okay.
22 Now, after you were assigned to evaluate this
23 offer in compromise, tell us what you did.
24 A Okay.
25 I spoke to the power of attorney, Mr. Reffsin.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
259
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 We discussed the offer in compromise. And I indicated
2 that I would write to request a revised collection
3 statement and then additional information.
4 Q Let me show you Government's Exhibit 421. Do you
5 recognize that?
6 A Yes, I do.
7 Q Can you tell us what that is?
8 A It is a letter I prepared and sent to Mr. Gordon, in
9 care of Mr. Reffsin.
10 MR. WHITE: Your Honor, the government offers
11 421.
12 THE COURT: Any objection?
13 MR. TRABULUS: No, your Honor, there is no
14 objection.
15 My copy is barely readable. I don't know if the
16 other copies are more readable.
17 MR. WHITE: I have an enlargement.
18 THE COURT: All right, Government's Exhibit 421
19 in evidence.
20 (Government's Exhibit 421 received in evidence.)
21 Q Mr. Gagliardi, let me show you 421-A, is that simply
22 an enlargement of 421?
23 A Yes, it is.
24 MR. WHITE: We offer 421-A, your Honor.
25 THE COURT: Any objection?
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
260
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 MR. TRABULUS: No objection.
2 THE COURT: Government's Exhibit 421-A in
3 evidence.
4 (Government's Exhibit 421-A received in
5 evidence.)
6 Q Would you read the first three paragraphs of the
7 letter before us?
8 A I am writing in regard to the offer in compromise
9 which you submitted on August 9, 1993. Your offer has
10 been reviewed by IRS counsel, and they have determined
11 that it is processable, and if it is accessib le it could
12 compromise your entire tax liability. If a recommendation
13 of acceptance is made by myself, the offer is subject to
14 review by Brooklyn district counsel and would require
15 coordination with the Department of Justice regarding your
16 previously accepted offer and settlement. I will,
17 therefore, require additional verification of your income
18 and expenses, assets and liabilities to make a
19 determination regarding the viability of your offer in
20 compromise. I have prepared a list of documents for
21 financial verification required to allow analysis of the
22 offer. The records should be provided by January 3rd,
23 1994. If you have any questions regarding the
24 documentation I can be reached at the number above, Monday
25 to Friday, 9:00 a.m. to 1:00 p.m.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
261
Gagliardi-dire ct/White
1 Q Now, the numbered paragraphs that follow, what are
2 those?
3 A The information requested in addition to verify the
4 offer in compromise.
5 Q The specific categories of information you asked for?
6 A That's correct.
7 Q Now, if you look down in the margin next to each of
8 the numbered paragraphs, there are handwritten notations.
9 Are those yours?
10 A No, they are not.
11 Q Were they on the letter when you sent them?
12 A No, they were not.
13 Q Now, what do you ask for in item number one?
14 A An updated and fully documented form 433-A,
15 collections information statement for individuals.
16 Q What do you ask for in item number three?
17 A Original cancelled checks and bank statements for all
18 accounts which you are a signator for months of April,
19 May, June, July, August, September and October, 1993.
20 Q And what did you ask for in item --
21 THE COURT: Do we have to go through all of this,
22 Mr. White? What is the purpose of that?
23 For example, this case will be shortened
24 considerably if you do not have these witnesses read every
25 item. The first part could have been summarized easily,
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
262
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 we will accept your offer and compromise if you verify
2 certain things. That's all it says. Why do we need to
3 take up all this time?
4 MR. WHITE: Your Honor, on these particular
5 responses and these particular requests, Mr. Gagliardi
6 will also specify about the specific responses to each of
7 these requests.
8 THE COURT: Is that material to any of the issues
9 in the case?
10 MR. WHITE: It is directly material, your Honor.
11 THE COURT: All right.
12 From now on, try to prevent the reading from the
13 documents, unless it is absolutely necessary.
14 MR. WHITE: I will, your Honor.
15 I will finish with the items.
16 Q Number six, what do you ask for in six?
17 A Verification, full monthly payments, if not paid for
18 by your personal check.
19 Q Item nine?
20 A Copies of all motor vehicle registrations, title
21 certificates and leasing agreements for vehicles you own
22 or operate.
23 Q Did you receive any response from Mr. Reffsin for
24 this letter?
25 A Yes, I did.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
263
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 Q And when was that?
2 A Mr. Reffsin called in January, late January, 1994,
3 and we met at my office.
4 Q Let me show you Government's Exhibit 423.
5 (Handed to the witness.)
6 Q Can you tell us wh at that is?
7 A They are copies of the information provided by
8 Mr. Reffsin in January of 1994.
9 Q Does that include 423 and attachments, A through L?
10 A Yes, it does.
11 Q In addition to that information did you receive
12 anything else from Mr. Reffsin?
13 A Yes. I received the cancelled checks and statements,
14 but I copied the pertinent information and returned the
15 originals.
16 Q And are the ones you copied included in 423?
17 A Yes.
18 MR. WHITE: The government offers 423.
19 THE COURT: Any objection?
20 MR. TRABULUS: No objection.
21 THE COURT: Government's Exhibit 423 in
22 evidence.
23 (Government's Exhibit 423 received in evidence.)
24 MR. WHITE: Inclusive of the attachments, 423-A
25 through L.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
264
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 T HE COURT: Any objection?
2 MR. TRABULUS: I wasn't objecting to any of them.
3 THE COURT: 423-A for Abel through L for Lion, in
4 evidence.
5 (Government's Exhibits 423-A through 423-L
6 received in evidence.)
7 MR. WHITE: Your Honor, again I have copies to
8 provide to the jury to follow along.
9 THE COURT: Good thinking, Mr. White.
10 MR. WHITE: I will do it in the proper order.
11 THE COURT: Now you are getting to it.
12 MR. WHITE: I learn quickly, your Honor.
13 THE COURT: You do.
14 (Whereupon, the exhibit/exhibits were published
15 to the jury.)
16 Q Let's review the information you received from
17 Mr. Reffsin.
18 Now, the top document marked 423 what is it?
19 A Revised collection statements from individuals, form
20 433-A.
21 Q Let me ask you about a couple of quick areas about
22 that, if you look at the top of pag e 2, question 14, for
23 bank charge cards, are any listed?
24 A No.
25 Q If you look for 18, securities, anything listed?
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
265
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 A Nothing at all.
2 Q For question 16 above that, real property, anything
3 listed?
4 A No.
5 Q On page 3, what assets are listed by Mr. Gordon?
6 A The only asset is $1,000 in cash.
7 Q In box 28 under other liabilities, are there loans to
8 Mr. Gordon for any corporations listed there?
9 A No.
10 Q On the next page under living expenses. At the
11 bottom under other expenses, what is written there?
12 A Box 51?
13 Q Yes.
14 A Other expenses, specify, nothing.
15 Q Were bank statements among the documents you received
16 from Mr. Reffsin?
17 A Yes.
18 Q Can you tell us what statements you received from
19 Mr. Reffsin?
20 A I will look at the attachments.
21 423-F is National Westminster Bank, statements
22 for the month of May 18th through June 16th, 1993.
23 Q Without reading each one, can you page through it and
24 tell us what you got?
25 A May 18th, through October 16th, through November
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
266
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 16th, 1993.
2 Q Looking at one in particular, 423-H, and that's the
3 statement for July 17th through August 17th, 1993.
4 A Yes.
5 Q Any deposits to Mr. Gordon's account to that
6 statement?
7 A There are two items listed as credit memos.
8 Q And what are the amounts?
9 A August 2nd, listed at $10,000, and the word "loan" is
10 written in. On August 3rd, 1993, credit memo, $5,000.
11 Q Now, if you could turn ahead to the st atement that is
12 marked 423-K. Any deposits to Mr. Gordon's account that
13 month?
14 A Yes, three.
15 Q Tell us what they are?
16 A October 21st, $5,000, credit memo. October 25th,
17 $613.52, deposit. And on November 2nd, $5,000, credit
18 memo.
19 Q Mr. Gagliardi, if you take a look at Exhibit 421,
20 your letter to Mr. Reffsin, and if you could compare that
21 with 423, which are the documents you received from him.
22 A Okay.
23 Q Going through the letter. Item number one, you asked
24 for a 433-A. Did you get that?
25 A Yes, I did.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
267
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 Q Item number two, you asked for tax returns, did you
2 get those?
3 A 1991, 1992 -- yes, we did.
4 Q The checks and bank statements, did you receive
5 those?
6 A Yes.
7 Q Item four, copies of all savings bank statements,
8 passbooks, and certificates of deposits, savings bonds,
9 stock certificates, etcetera. Did you receive any of
10 those?
11 A No. We received none.
12 Q Five is current wage or commission, income
13 statements. Did you receive any of those?
14 A Yes, the W-2 statement for 1993.
15 Q Number six, verification of all monthly payments, if
16 not paid by your personal check. Did you receive any of
17 those?
18 A No.
19 Q Seven, copies of utility bills, did you receive any
20 of those?
21 A No.
22 Q Eight, insurance policy numbers and verifications,
23 did you receive any of those?
24 A Received insurance information for homeowners
25 insurance.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
268
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 Q Number nine, copies of all m otor vehicle
2 registrations, title certificates, and/or leasing
3 agreements for vehicles you own or operate. Did you
4 receive any of those?
5 A No.
6 Q Ten, dental or medical bills, did you receive any of
7 those?
8 A No.
9 Q And 11, any additional documentation which supports
10 the income and expenses claimed on your Form 433. Did you
11 receive any of those?
12 A No.
13 Q Now, Mr. Gagliardi, after you reviewed the materials
14 in Exhibit 423, what did you do?
15 A I prepared a spread sheet for certain information,
16 and I contacted Mr. Reffsin again to request additional
17 verification and information.
18 Q Let me show you Exhibit 424.
19 (Handed to the witness.)
20 Q Do you know what that is?
21 A A letter I wrote to Mr. Reffsin on February 17th,
22 1994.
23 MR. WHITE: Your Honor, the government offers
24 424.
25 THE COURT: Any objection?
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
269
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 MR. TRABULUS: No objection.
2 THE COURT: Government's Exhibit 424 in
3 evidence.
4 (Government's Exhibit 424 received in evidence.)
5 Q Mr. Gagliardi, if you take a look at 424-A and see if
6 it is simply an enlargement of 424?
7 A Yes, it is.
8 MR. WHITE: We offer it in evidence.
9 THE COURT: Any objection?
10 MR. TRABULUS: No.
11 THE COURT: Government's Exhibit 424-A, for Abel,
12 in evidence.
13 (Government's Exhibit 424-A received in
14 evidence.)
15 Q Mr. Gagliardi, without reading it, can you tell us
16 what you asked for in that letter.
17 A Okay.
18 In a nutshell I requested additional information
19 as to the questionable items I found when I reviewed the
20 information that had arrived.
21 Q And what specific questionable items did you find?
22 A Unusual deposits out of his bank account, and the
23 service contract with Who's Who, there was that question
24 with a date that I could not determine when it began.
25 There were questions about the taxpayer's taxes, and the
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
270
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 agreement with the Department of Justice.
2 Q Let me first direct your attention to the bank
3 deposits. Specifically what bank deposits were you asking
4 him about?
5 A The $15,000 in July and $10,613.52 in October.
6 Q What was your question with respect to the
7 compensation agreement?
8 A I wanted to fix the term. I needed to make certain
9 when it began. I wanted to -- I wanted either an
10 explanation for the date or --
11 Q Now , Mr. Gagliardi, did you receive a response from
12 Mr. Reffsin regarding your request?
13 A Yes, I did.
14 Q Let me show you Exhibit 425.
15 (Handed to the witness.)
16 Q Do you recognize that?
17 A Yes, I do.
18 Q What is it?
19 A A letter from Mr. Reffsin whereby he transmitted the
20 information that I requested, and the attachments.
21 MR. WHITE: Your Honor, the government offers
22 425.
23 THE COURT: Any objection?
24 MR. TRABULUS: No.
25 THE COURT: Government's Exhibit 425 in
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
271
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 evidence.
2 (Government's Exhibit 425 received in evidence.)
3 MR. WHITE: With the Court's permission we will
4 hand out copies again to the jury?
5 THE COURT: Very well.
6 (Whereupon, the exhibit/exhibits were published
7 to t he jury.)
8 THE COURT: Is this an undated letter,
9 Mr. Gagliardi?
10 THE WITNESS: Yes.
11 MS. SCOTT: Your Honor, I will place a sticker on
12 the last enlargement, 423-A.
13 THE COURT: Very good.
14 Now, does that include the attachments also to
15 425.
16 MR. WHITE: Yes, your Honor.
17 THE COURT: Any objection to the attachments?
18 MR. TRABULUS: No, your Honor.
19 THE COURT: They are 425-A, for Abel to, is it D
20 for Dog?
21 MR. WHITE: Yes, through D for Dog.
22 THE COURT: Those are in evidence as well.
23 MR. WHITE: Thank you.
24 (Government's Exhibits 425-A through 425-D
25 received in evidence.)
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
272
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 Q Now, Mr. Gagliardi, in substance, can you tell us
2 what Mr. Reffsin told you in this letter regarding those
3 deposits that you requested or questioned?
4 A He indicated that they were loans to the taxpayer.
5 We had spoken about this previously. I don't know if you
6 went to bring that up.
7 Q Okay.
8 Tell us what you discussed with Mr. Reffsin prior
9 to this letter.
10 A Okay.
11 I questioned the items when we spoke on the
12 phone. I raised the issues. He gave an explanation. And
13 I told him I would want the information, and he provided
14 that to me.
15 Q And in this letter what did he tell you about those
16 bank deposits?
17 A That Mr. Gordon received loans from Joyce Grossman
18 for $15,000, and Madeline Middlemark for $10,000.
19 Q Did he explain the purposes of these loans?
20 A Yes.
21 Q Can you explain for each one what the purpose was?
22 A He indicated Mr. Gordon's son had passed away, and he
23 borrowed money to pay for funeral expenses.
24 Q From which one of those people?
25 A In the bottom paragraph, he borrowed money from Joyce
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
273
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 Grossman.
2 Q So, the money for the son's funeral was borrowed from
3 Joyce Grossman?
4 A Yes.
5 Q And does it indicate what the loan from Madeline
6 Middlemark was for?
7 A Yes, it does. It indicates back alimony for payment
8 to Mr. Gordon's ex-spouse.
9 Q Was any documentation of these loans provided to you?
10 A Yes.
11 Q What was provided to you?
12 A Attachments 425-A and 425-B are promissory notes for
13 $15,000 from Joyce Grossman, and $10,000 from Madeline
14 Middlemark.
15 Q Look at 425-A, if you would.
16 That indicates that it is a note from Bruce
17 Gordon to repay Joyce Grossman; is that corre ct?
18 A Yes.
19 Q Can you tell us what the date of the promissory note
20 is?
21 A It says July 25th, 1993.
22 Q And that's the note or the loan that Mr. Reffsin told
23 you what to pay for his son's funeral expenses?
24 A Yes.
25 Q You can take a look at Government's Exhibit 499-1-A.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
274
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 MR. WHITE: Your Honor, I will offer it now. It
2 is a certified copy --
3 THE COURT: What is the number?
4 MR. WHITE: 499-1-A.
5 THE COURT: It is Exhibit 499 --
6 MR. WHITE: 499-1-A.
7 THE COURT: Any objection?
8 MR. TRABULUS: Your Honor, I have to find it.
9 THE COURT: So do I.
10 MR. TRABULUS: Your Honor, I know what it is, I
11 have soon it before, I will not object to it.
12 THE COURT: Very well.
13 Government's Exhibit 499-1-A, which is a
14 certificate of death?
15 MR. WHITE: Correct.
16 THE COURT: In evidence.
17 (Government's Exhibit 499-1-A received in
18 evidence.)
19 Q If you can take a look at that Exhibit, it is a death
20 certificate from the Florida Department of Health and
21 Rehabilitative Services; is that correct?
22 A It appears to be.
23 Q Would you read the decedent's name in the top box,
24 number one?
25 A Todd Gordon.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
275
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 Q If you look down to box 17, where it lists father,
2 what does it say?
3 A Bruce Gordon.
4 Q Look back down on box number three, where it says
5 date of death, what is the date?
6 A It says July 28th, 1993.
7 Q And compare that to the date of the promissory note,
8 please, 425-A?
9 A J uly 25th, 1993.
10 Q So, Mr. Gordon's son died three days after he
11 supposedly borrowed the money for the funeral?
12 MR. JENKS: Objection.
13 THE COURT: What ground?
14 Please rise when you make an objection.
15 MR. JENKS: I am sorry, your Honor. Objection.
16 THE COURT: What ground?
17 MR. JENKS: On the grounds of the phrasing of
18 that objection.
19 THE COURT: Overruled.
20 Did you hear the question?
21 THE WITNESS: Yes, I did, sir.
22 Q What is the answer?
23 A It appears that the promissory note is three days
24 prior to the date of death.
25 Q Now, if you can look at 425-C.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
276
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 Is that the verification you requested with
2 respect to the compensation agreement?
3 A It is what I received, yes, from Mr. Reffsin.
4 MR. JENKS: Objection. Mr. White continually
5 keeps feeding the witness answers instead of asking him
6 questions.
7 I will ask you to instruct him not to lead the
8 witness.
9 THE COURT: Well, I don't know about
10 continuously, because no one has made an objection about
11 it before, including you.
12 Let me hear the last question, Mr. Reporter,
13 please.
14 MR. WHITE: I will rephrase it, if you like.
15 THE COURT: I don't know whether you have to or
16 not. Let's see if it is a leading question.
17 (Whereupon, the court reporter reads the
18 requested material.)
19 THE COURT: What is leading about that?
20 MR. JENKS: He can simply ask him what the
21 document is, your Honor. For ten or fifteen questions he
22 has been summarizing what is in the document and calling
23 for a yes or no answer.
24 THE COURT: Happily so.
25 MR. JENKS: I will object, your Honor.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
277
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 THE COURT: It would be leading if -- read it
2 again to me, I want to make a point so the lawyers know
3 what I think a leading question is. Go ahead,
4 Mr. Reporter.
5 (Whereupon, the court reporter reads the
6 requested material.)
7 THE COURT: That is not technically a leading
8 question. It would be leading if it said: That's the
9 verification you received; isn't that right?
10 Very slightly different.
11 Objection overruled.
12 I have to break this up every once in a while,
13 members of the jury. If we get a whole hour's worth of
14 this stuff, I am not going to let it go. I will even tell
15 some stories or something every once in a while. I can't
16 tell jokes. I was never able to do that, but stories I
17 can tell.
18 Go ahead.
19 Q Now, Mr. Gagliardi, after you received this response
20 from Mr. Reffsin, did you have any additional contact with
21 him regarding this offer?
22 A I kept the chronology of the actions I took on the
23 case. To tell you the truth, as to what action I took
24 next it would be difficult to place. If I can see my
25 notes I could tell you.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
278
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 Q Do you recall the specific dates?
2 A Not after this time, no.
3 Q All right.
4 Let me show you Exhibit 3500-8-A, which I believe
5 are your notes. And you can see if that refreshes your
6 recollection.
7 (Handed to the witness.)
8 A I told Mr. Reffsin that I would have to review the
9 information and make a determination on the offer in
10 compromise.
11 Q Now, did you ever ask him for any additional
12 information?
13 A Yes, I did.
14 Q What did you ask him for?
15 A The taxpayer was required to make a filing with the
16 Department of Justice on an annual basis as part of that
17 agreement, a previous agreement. And he had yet to do
18 so. And I brought that issue up.
19 Q Now, did you ask him for any additional projections
20 of income?
21 A Yes, I -- the offer examination required that we
22 bring it out five years after the recommendation was
23 made. And this thing was dragging on a little longer than
24 expected, and I needed an additional year's projection.
25 Q Take a look at Exhibit 426.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
279
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 (Handed to the witness.)
2 What is that?
3 Q What is that?
4 A A letter from Mr. Reffsin and attachment. To
5 summarize it, it is the extension --
6 THE COURT: No. Just tell us what it is. It is
7 a letter and dated May 13th, 1994.
8 THE WITNESS: Sorry.
9 Q Mr. Gagliardi, did you receive this letter?
10 A Yes, I did.
11 MR. WHITE: Your Honor, the government offers
12 426.
13 THE COURT: Any objection?
14 MR. TRABULUS: No, your Honor.
15 THE COURT: Government's Exhibit 426 in evidence.
16 (Government's Exhibit 426 received in evidence.)
17 Q Mr. Gagliardi, would you look at 426-A, and tell me
18 if it is simply an enlargement of 426?
19 A Yes, it is.
20 MR. WHITE: Your Honor, we offer 426-A.
21 THE COURT: Any objection?
22 MR. TRABULUS: No.
23 THE COURT: 426-A, Government's Exhibit in
24 evidence.
25 (Government's Exhibit 426-A received in
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
280
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 evidence.)
2 Q If you can summarize it for us what is it Mr. Reffsin
3 told you with respect to the additional year's projection
4 of income?
5 A Basically the taxpayer's employer filed for Chapter
6 11 protection, and it was impossible to provide an extra
7 year's projection.
8 Q And why was it impossible?
9 A Because it was not certain as to whether or not his
10 employment would be continued.
11 Q Now, you indicated before in addition to that you
12 asked Mr. Reffsin with respect to information about the
13 collateral agreement.
14 A Yes, I did.
15 Q Did you receive a response from Mr. Reffsin with
16 respect to that issue?
17 A I just want to make sure I properly state it.
18 No, I received the verification, for 1992. I
19 can't find it in my notes right now.
20 Q Okay.
21 Let me show you Exhibit 427.
22 (Handed to the witness.)
23 Q Tell me if you recognize that.
24 A Yes, I do.
25 Q And what is that?
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
281
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 A It is a letter from M. Reffsin & Company signed by
2 Mr. Reffsin explaining the taxpayer's liability for the
3 future income and collateral agreement with the Department
4 of Justice.
5 MR. WHITE: The government, your Honor, would
6 offer Exhibit 427.
7 THE COURT: Any objection?
8 MR. TRABULUS: No.
9 THE COURT: Government's Exhibit 427, in
10 evidence.
11 Q Now, Mr. Gagliardi, again, look at 427-A, and tell me
12 if it is simply an enlargement of 427.
13 MR. WHITE: Your Honor, we offer 427-A.
14 MR. TRABULUS: No objection.
15 THE COURT: Government's Exhibit 427-A in
16 evi dence.
17 Q Now, Mr. Gagliardi, can you explain for us more
18 specifically what information you asked Mr. Reffsin for
19 that this letter responds to?
20 A All right.
21 The taxpayer had previously made that agreement
22 with the Department of Justice, and it was separate and
23 distinct from the offer in compromise. He had to file
24 that with his tax return annually. And it was not
25 provided -- that information was not provided along with
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
282
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 the offer in compromise. But it was -- I am sorry.
2 THE COURT: Mr. Gagliardi, what is this agreement
3 with the Department of Justice? What is that about? Does
4 it have anything to do with your offer in compromise?
5 THE WITNESS: With the offer in compromise -- not
6 particularly with the offer in compromise.
7 THE COURT: Well, did you know what that was, the
8 Department of Justice collateral agreement?
9 THE WITNESS: Only to the extent that the
10 taxpayer had provided copies with the information that was
11 submitted with the offer.
12 THE COURT: So, you didn't know what it was?
13 THE WITNESS: No. I didn't have a copy of the
14 agreement, no.
15 THE COURT: You still don't know what it is?
16 THE WITNESS: I have a basic idea what it is.
17 But I don't have specific knowledge.
18 MR. WHITE: Your Honor, I think I can clarify a
19 question.
20 Q Prior to receiving the offer in compromise, did you
21 have a copy of the collateral agreement?
22 A Prior to receiving the offer in compromise? No.
23 Q With the offer in compromise did you receive a copy
24 of the collateral agreement?
25 A Yes, I did.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COU RT REPORTER
283
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 Q Was the sum -- were the sums owed by Mr. Gordon under
2 the collateral agreement, part of the liability that he
3 was trying to compromise?
4 A It indicated all taxes. I believe if you look at the
5 offer in compromise, I believe --
6 MR. NEVILLE: Objection to what he believes, your
7 Honor.
8 THE COURT: When you say you believe, you mean
9 you understand that to be so with reasonable certainty, or
10 are you just guessing?
11 THE WITNESS: My recollection is that it was
12 included. Without looking at the document, I don't want
13 to make the guess, your Honor.
14 THE COURT: You don't know at this point?
15 THE WITNESS: No. I don't know at this point.
16 Q Look at Government's Exhibit 420-H, that you have in
17 front of you.
18 A If you give me a minute.
19 Q H should be the last attachment to that.
20 A Okay.
21 Q Now, is that the collateral agreement?
22 A Yes, it is.
23 Q Did you receive it as part of the offer in
24 compromise?
25 A Yes, I did.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
284
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 Q That collateral agreement covers how much in
2 penalties?
3 A 254,781, plus interest.
4 THE COURT: I still don't understand.
5 What does the collateral agreement have to do
6 with what you were doing with respect to the offer in
7 compromise? Is it the same tax liability? Is it a
8 previous tax liability or what?
9 A It's -- it's the same tax liability.
10 THE COURT: It is the second agreement covering
11 the second tax liability?
12 THE WITNESS: The offer in compromise?
13 THE COURT: You were involved in an offer in
14 compromise.
15 THE WITNESS: Yes.
16 THE COURT: There was some three and a half
17 million dollars in taxes, penalty and interest due; is
18 that correct?
19 THE WITNESS: Correct.
20 THE COURT: There was an offer in compromise to
21 settle the whole shooting match for 150,000?
22 THE WITNESS: Rate.
23 THE COURT: You were asking for all these
24 documents to verify that the taxpayer couldn't pay more
25 than that, correct?
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
285
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 THE WITNESS: Correct.
2 THE COURT: That's what you were doing?
3 THE WITNESS: Yes.
4 THE COURT: What does the collateral agreement
5 cover, the same three and a half million dollars?
6 THE WITNESS: The taxpayer previously agreed to
7 make these payments with the Department of Justice, the
8 information. If the offer was accepted it had to go back
9 to Justice to be approved.
10 THE COURT: The collateral agreement covered then
11 with the Department of Justice was also involving taxes,
12 past due taxes?
13 THE WITNESS: The penalty portions of those
14 taxes.
15 THE COURT: Just the penalty portions, but the
16 same taxes that you were concerned with?
17 THE WITNESS: Well, the liability was part of the
18 offer, the taxes to be settled, yes.
19 THE COURT: So, he had already made an agreement
20 with the Department of Justice to pay, you say, the
21 penalties part; is that right?
22 THE WITNESS: Right.
23 THE COURT: And this offer in compromise was an
24 additional payment to be made?
25 THE WITNESS: Okay.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
286
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 The offer in compromise offered this amount to
2 pay the -- to wipe out the rest of the -- the entire tax
3 liability.
4 THE COURT: Including the collateral --
5 THE WITNESS: Including -- I am sorry.
6 THE COURT: If the offer in compromise went
7 through, it would wipe out the collateral agreement?
8 THE WITNESS: With the approval of the Department
9 of Justice.
10 THE COURT: Yes.
11 THE WITNESS: Yes.
12 Q The $240,000 in penalties that the collateral
13 covered, was that a portion of the total three and a half
14 million liability that Mr. Gordon wanted to compromise?
15 A Yes.
16 Q So, if the offer were accepted, that debt would be
17 extinguished along with the debt for 150,000?
18 A That's correct.
19 Q Now, to go back to the collateral agreement question,
20 what specifically were you asking Mr. Reffsin about, to
21 which this letter responds?
22 THE COURT: What is this l etter?
23 MR. WHITE: 427.
24 A The question I raised was whether Mr. Gordon met the
25 terms of the collateral agreement with the Department of
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
287
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 Justice. This is the explanation provided by Mr. Reffsin.
2 Q What made you think he had not met the terms of the
3 agreement?
4 MR. TRABULUS: Objection to form, your Honor.
5 THE COURT: Overruled.
6 A No information was provided with the offer package to
7 indicate any payments were made.
8 Q Now, does Mr. Reffsin provide you with any
9 information regarding payments for 1993 by Mr. Gordon
10 under that agreement?
11 A Yes. He did.
12 Q What did he tell you in that letter, 427?
13 A In a nutshell, that the taxpayer had made a partial
14 payment for the amount required for 1993, and that he was
15 unable to pay the balance.
16 THE COURT: He paid $5,500?
17 THE WITNESS: Yes, sir.
18 THE COURT: Of the 14,000 --
19 A Yes, sir.
20 Q And a little over $8,000 is what he was unable to
21 pay; is that correct?
22 A Yes, sir.
23 Q Now, if you could just read for us the two sentences
24 in the third paragraph allowed?
25 A The third paragraph?
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
288
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 Q Yes.
2 A He is going to have to borrow the money he has
3 offered in the offer in compromise submitted. Where shall
4 he borrow this money? Perhaps he should cease eating.
5 THE COURT: E A T I N G, which we will do at
6 12:30 today. And I can't wait already.
7 Q Now, let me show you Exhibit 428. And would you take
8 a look at that.
9 (Handed to the witness.)
10 Q Would you tell us what Exhibit 428 is?
11 A Form 656, offer in compromise, marked at the top,
12 amended offer, October 20th, 1994. And it has an
13 attachment.
14 MR. WHITE: Your Honor, the government offers
15 428.
16 THE COURT: Any objection?
17 MR. TRABULUS: No, your Honor.
18 THE COURT: Government's Exhibit 428, in
19 evidence.
20 (Government's Exhibit 428 received in evidence.)
21 Q Now, what is an amendment to an offer in compromise?
22 A A taxpayer -- an offer in compromise is basically a
23 negotiation. A taxpayer can offer an additional sum,
24 include additional periods, or change the terms of the
25 payment of the offer.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
289
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 Q Okay.
2 In what respects does this amended offer in
3 compromise amend the original one?
4 A The attachment is basically similar to the original
5 offer, except for paragraph C of the attachment, which
6 indicates that there is current -- you want me to read it
7 or no?
8 Q Tell us in substance how it is different.
9 A It is basically to include the unpaid portion of the
10 agreement with the Department of Justice.
11 Q And the unpaid portion relates to that $8,000 that
12 you mentioned before?
13 A Yes.
14 Q Now, aside from reviewing the information submitted
15 to you by Mr. Gordon and Mr. Reffsin, can you tell us what
16 else you did to investigate this offer in compromise?
17 A I researched routine databases that we have, the
18 motor vehicles, real property information, records of the
19 state and the county, currency and banking records which
20 lists disbursements over $10,000 by a taxpayer. And I
21 made a visit to the taxpayer's address to dete rmine what
22 kind of lifestyle he was living.
23 Q Now, let's take it one by one.
24 First of all, you mentioned a database with
25 respect to currency transactions?
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
290
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 A Yes.
2 Q Tell us what that is and why you checked it?
3 A It indicates any cash transaction that is made either
4 in a deposit or withdrawal from a bank over $10,000. I
5 researched that and didn't find any for Mr. Gordon.
6 Q Did you say you reviewed real estate records as well?
7 A Yes, we did.
8 Q Why did you do that?
9 A To determine if there are any real estate holdings
10 not reported on the collection statements, and on Nassau
11 County and Suffolk records, which were researched, and
12 there were none found in Mr. Gordon's name.
13 Q Did you review motor vehicle regis trations?
14 A Yes, we did. And, likewise, there were none found.
15 Q You mentioned also about investigating Mr. Gordon's
16 life style. Tell us what you did.
17 A I visited the address listed on the offer in
18 compromise. I found no one at home. I made note of the
19 area, the type of neighborhood it was, the value of the
20 property. I researched that particular property to see if
21 he was in the chain of title. I didn't find anything for
22 Mr. Gordon.
23 Q Okay.
24 If you can look back to Exhibit 420.
25 A Give me a clue?
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
291
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 Q Which is the offer in compromise, the original one.
2 A Okay.
3 A lot of papers here.
4 Q Look at 420-A, the offer in compromise form.
5 A Yes.
6 Q The address listed is 10 Bluff Road in Glen Cove?
7 A Correct.
8 Q What address did you go and observe?
9 A That address.
10 Q And from looking at your notes, can you tell us when
11 you did that?
12 A December, 1993. And I believe I made another visit
13 later on, but I can't fix the date.
14 Q If I can address your attention to July of '94 in
15 your notes.
16 A Yes, I did, on July 29th, 1994, I also visited.
17 Q Let me address your attention to early April, 1995.
18 Did you learn anything in connection with this offer in
19 compromise at that time?
20 A Yes, I did.
21 Q Can you tell us what you learned?
22 A There was a newspaper published -- report regarding
23 Mr. Gordon and Who's Who Worldwide Registry, indicated
24 that he had an ownership role in the company, and that he
25 had been arrested, I believe.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
292
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 Q And as a result of that, what did you do?
2 A I contacted Mr. Reffsin.
3 Q And what happened?
4 A Mr. Reffsin indicated that it was an error, it would
5 be resolved, and he would get back to me shortly, and all
6 should be fine.
7 MR. TRABULUS: Your Honor, may we have a limiting
8 instruction concerning the significance of the information
9 in the newspaper article that he had, as to it being
10 admissible for his state of mind and only that?
11 THE COURT: Yes.
12 The newspaper article that the witness said that
13 he is not admissible, you are to pay no attention to the
14 fact of whatever was in that newspaper article. The only
15 reason it is allowed in is what effect it had on this
16 witness.
17 As far as whether it was true or not, that is
18 absolutely not admissible. You are to pay no attention to
19 that.
20 Q Now, Mr. Gagliardi, was there a reason why this
21 newspaper article of Mr. Gordon's ownership was
22 significant to you?
23 A Yes.
24 Up to this point in time, and as far as I know,
25 Mr. Gordon had no ownership, stock ownership, or no other
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
293
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 role other than an employee for the corporation. It
2 raised that issue and it had to be cleared up.
3 Q From where did you obtain that impression that he had
4 no ownership interest?
5 A On every collection statement filed, it indicated he
6 was an employee, and had no ownership role.
7 Q Now, did you subsequently have any additional
8 conversation with Mr. Reffsin about this situation?
9 A Yes, we waited at least about six weeks for
10 Mr. Reffsin -- to see if the situation had resolved. I
11 contacted him again, and he indicated he could not -- and
12 I indicated he could not hold this open forever, and if
13 the taxpayer would withdraw the offer -- if the taxpayer
14 would not withdraw the offer, we have to reject it.
15 Q Okay.
16 Let me show you Exhibit 429.
17 (Handed to the witness.)
18 Q Do you recognize that?
19 A Yes, I do.
20 Q What is that?
21 A A letter dated May 10th, 1995, where Mr. Reffsin -- I
22 am sorry, from Mr. Reffsin, withdrawing the offer in
23 compromise.
24 Q To you?
25 A Yes.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
294
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 MR. WHITE: Your Honor, the government offers
2 Exhibit 429.
3 THE COURT: Any objection?
4 MR. TRABULUS: No, your Honor.
5 MR. WALLENSTEIN: No, your Honor.
6 THE COURT: Government's Exhibit 429 in
7 evidence.
8 (Government's Exhibit 429 received in evidence.)
9 THE COURT: What is the date on that?
10 THE WITNESS: May 10, 1995.
11 Q If you can just read the first paragraph for us.
12 A Pursuant to our telephone discussion of the other
13 day, I elect to withdraw Mr. Gordon's request for an offer
14 in compromise in view of his current legal problems -- in
15 view of the current legal problems that Mr. Gordon is
16 involved in.
17 He would prefer to re-submit when the problems
18 are resolved.
19 And it is signed by Mr. Reffsin.
20 MR. WHITE: Your Honor, may I have one moment,
21 please?
22 THE COURT: Surely.
23 (Whereupon, at this time there was a pause in the
24 proceedings.)
25 MR. WHITE: Your Honor, I have no further
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
295
Gagliardi-direct/White
1 questions.
2 THE COURT: Cross-examination -- maybe we ought
3 to take our recess first and then start the
4 cross-examination.
5 All right. Members of the jury, we will take a
6 ten-minute recess. Please do not discuss the case. Keep
7 an open mind.
8 Madam courtroom deputy, would you please recess
9 the jury.
10 (Whereupon, at this time the jury leaves the
11 courtroom.)
12
13 (Whereupon, a recess is taken.)
14
15 THE CLERK: Jury entering.
16 (Whereupon, the jury at this time entered the
17 courtroom.)
18 THE COURT: Please be seated, members of the
19 jury.
20 You may proceed, Mr. Trabulus.
21 MR. TRABULUS: Thank you, your Honor.
22
23 CROSS-EXAMINATION
24 BY MR. TRABULUS:
25 Q Good morning, Mr. Gagliardi.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
296
Gagliardi-cross/Trabulus
1 A Good morning.
2 Q I am Mr. Gordon's attorney.
3 Before you came to court yesterday, had you ever
4 seen Mr. Gordon before?
5 A To the best of my recollection, no.
6 Q And did you ever speak to Mr. Gordon?
7 A No, I don't believe so.
8 Q So, is it fair to say that your entire involvement
9 with Mr. Gordon was through Mr. Reffsin?
10 A Yes, it would be.
11 Q Now, I believe you were shown Exhibit 499-1-A, which
12 showed the date of death of Mr. Gordon's son as being July
13 28th, 1993; is that correct?
14 A I believe so.
15 Q Of course, you were shown a note that had an earlier
16 date; is that correct?
17 A Yes.
18 Q Now, the inquiry that you made which resulted in you
19 being given the note was prompted by some entries on bank
20 statements; is that correct?
21 A Yes.
22 Q And I would ask you now to turn to Exhibit 423-H.
23 A I have it.
24 Q Mr. Gagliardi, some of the entries which prompted
25 your inquiry appear on this 423-H; is that correct?
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
297
Gagliardi-cross/Trabulus
1 A Yes.
2 Q And those are the two additions, one for 10,000 and
3 one for 15,000; is that correct?
4 A Yes.
5 Q And one has the word "loan" written next to it?
6 A Yes.
7 Q They are both shown as credit memos; is that correct?
8 A Yes.
9 Q One is dated August 2nd, and the other is August 3rd;
10 is that correct?
11 A Yes.
12 Q And that's a few days after the July 28th date of the
13 debt; is that right?
14 A Yes, sir.
15 Q Now, it is not unheard of for people who receive
16 money as a loan to give a promissory note for that
17 afterwards; is that correct?
18 A I have no particular knowledge of it.
19 Q Would it seem -- if there was an emergency situation
20 and someone got some money, they might not give a
21 promissory note for it right at that point; is that
22 correct?
23 A If you want to make that supposition. I can't.
24 Q Isn't it correct that they then prepared a promissory
25 note afterward, and in the course of dating it, they might
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
298
Gagliardi-cross/Trabulus
1 not remember the actual date they got the money; is that
2 correct?
3 A I am rather careful in dating documents. I would
4 imagine that Mr. Gordon would be the same.
5 Q Well, when someone is upset because a close relative,
6 such as a child, had died, perhaps they might not be as
7 careful; would you agree?
8 A You can make that supposition. Ho wever, this is
9 information he is providing to the Internal Revenue
10 Service.
11 Q In any event, there is no dispute that the money, the
12 money itself was given to -- put into Mr. Gordon's account
13 after the date that the son had died; is that correct?
14 A That is correct.
15 Q Now, Mr. Gagliardi, when you first got involved with
16 Mr. Gordon's case, information case, that was prompted by
17 the receipt of the offer in compromise; is that correct?
18 A I had previously been assigned a review of
19 Mr. Gordon's account on another matter.
20 Q Now, in connection with your assignment relating to
21 the offer in compromise, you had access to documents
22 relating to Mr. Gordon's tax filings, filings that had
23 been made before the offer in compromise itself was
24 proposed; is that correct?
25 A Do you want to restate that?
HARRY RAPA PORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
299
Gagliardi-cross/Trabulus
1 Q I am sorry. I will restate it.
2 When you got involved -- at the time you received
3 the offer in compromise, did you have the prior collection
4 information statements, the forms 433-A, that had been
5 filed by or on behalf of Mr. Gordon?
6 A When I received the offer in compromise, I received a
7 package of information with that collection statement that
8 was dated, I believe it was July of '93, or September of
9 '93. I don't have it -- without looking at it I can't
10 give you the exact date.
11 Q Did you have any earlier collection information
12 statements that had been filed by Mr. Gordon?
13 A Did I -- no. I did not have any collection
14 information statements prior to receiving the offer in
15 compromise.
16 Q After receiving the offer in compromise, did there
17 come a point in time when you acquired earlier collection
18 information statements that had been filed by Mr. Gordon
19 before the offer in compromise?
20 A I don't recall so. The original -- the file with the
21 offer is dated, I think, July of '93. I don't believe
22 there was another offer -- another collection statement.
23 Q No other collection statement?
24 A I don't have any knowledge of it.
25 Q So, it is your understanding that the very first
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300
Gagliardi-cross/Trabulus
1 collection information statement that was ever filed by
2 Mr. Gordon was the July 8th, 1993, collection information
3 statement?
4 A When I received the offer in compromise, that's the
5 first collection statement that I had.
6 Q In the course of doing your investigation, I think
7 you mentioned that you did some investigation, you went to
8 a condominium, you checked property records, currency and
9 banking records.
10 In the course of that investigation did you seek
11 to ascertain whether or not Mr. Gordon had previously,
12 before July 8th, 1993, filed any collection information
13 statements?
14 A I didn't have access to any other information, and I
15 don't believe I ever requested any prior filings.
16 Q When you say you didn't have any access to other
17 information, could you have access to information, had you
18 requested it?
19 A Do you want to be specific?
20 Q Yes.
21 For example, if you had wanted to see other
22 collection information statements that had been filed by
23 Mr. Gordon earlier than the July 8th, 1993 collection
24 information statement, could you have made a request and
25 gained access to it?
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
301
Gagliardi-cross/Trabulus
1 A It's a possibility. However, it is sometimes
2 difficult to retrieve records on previous cases.
3 Q Did you ever ask Mr. Reffsin whether Mr. Gordon had
4 previously filed any earlier collection information
5 statements?
6 A I don't believe so.
7 Q And you say it would be difficult -- it could
8 sometimes be an effort to retrieve files within the IRS to
9 get earlier collection information statements; is that
10 correct?
11 A That's correct.
12 Q Would that be more difficult than going out and
13 visiting a condominium? Would that take more of your
14 time, to make a request for a prior document?
15 A Well, we could make a request for a prior document.
16 However, this is a current offer in compromise I was
17 reviewing. There was really no reason to see prior
18 records.
19 Q Did you tell Mr. Reffsin that you were unaware of any
20 prior records, and wouldn't be considering them?
21 A It never became an issue.
22 Q So, he -- withdrawn.
23 Now, I would like to direct your attention to
24 Exhibit -- bear with me a moment. It is one of the
25 420's -- I am sorry, it is 423.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
302
Gagliardi-cross/Trabulus
1 Do you have that in front of you?
2 A Yes, I do.
3 Q Now, that's a collection information statement, is it
4 not?
5 A Yes, it is.
6 Q And you testified concerning it.
7 I would like you to turn to page 3.
8 A Page 3.
9 Q Under item 27 that you have been asked some questions
10 about by Mr. White --
11 A Uh-huh.
12 Q -- is it not true that there is a listed liability of
13 $30,000 for charge ac counts?
14 A Yes, there are.
15 Q Did you pursue that with any follow-up inquiry
16 concerning what those charge accounts were?
17 A No, I didn't.
18 Q Okay.
19 Now, let's go to the -- that was a collection
20 information statement that was filed in connection with --
21 following the offer in compromise; is that correct?
22 A This is I believe the amended statement.
23 Q This is the one you asked for?
24 A Yes.
25 Q As part of your desire to get additional information?
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
303
Gagliardi-cross/Trabulus
1 A That's right. Uh-huh.
2 Q Now, let's go back to the collection information you
3 received in connection with the offer in compromise, and I
4 believe that was Exhibit 420-D?
5 A I have it.
6 Q That's the one dated July 8th, 1993; is that right?
7 A Yes, it is.
8 Q And that offer in compromise -- excuse me, that
9 collection information statement on page 3 also indicates
10 a liability for charge accounts, $32,000; is that correct?
11 A Yes, it does.
12 Q Did you pursue that to inquire as to the nature or
13 existence of that charge account?
14 A No, I didn't.
15 Q Is it fair to say that in these collection
16 information statements that were given to you in
17 connection with the offer in compromise, there was
18 disclosure of the fact that there were charge account
19 liabilities relating to Mr. Gordon?
20 A Charge account liabilities, yes.
21 Q Now, I would like to refer you to the collateral
22 agreement. And I think that is 420-H.
23 A I have it.
24 MR. TRABULUS: I will just give the jury a chance
25 to find their copy.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
304
Gagliardi-cross/Trabulus
1 (Whereupon, at this time there was a pause in the
2 proceedings.)
3 Q Now, Mr. Gagliardi, you were asked to read the -- I
4 think the second paragraph.
5 A Uh-huh.
6 Q Take a look at the first paragraph. And without
7 asking you to read it, is it fair to say that it refers to
8 an offer dated August 29th, 1991, as amended on September
9 19th, 1991?
10 A You want my understanding?
11 Q Yes.
12 A My understanding is that it was an offer in
13 settlement with the Department of Judges.
14 Q And the collateral agreement itself was dated was
15 dated October -- excuse me, November 20th, 1991; is that
16 correct?
17 A That's correct.
18 Q And it was prepared well, well -- well, years in
19 advance, years before the offer in compromise that you
20 have been testifying about was submitted to you; is that
21 correct? Or submitted to the IRS?
22 A That's correct.
23 Q So, just for clarification where this document, that
24 is, 420-H refers to an offer in compromise, it is not
25 talking about something that happened years later? It is
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
305
Gagliardi-cross/Trabulus
1 talking about the offer of settlement?
2 A It is talking about the offer in settlement, yes.
3 Q Are you familiar with the offer in settlement? Have
4 you ever seen it, the offer referred to with respect to
5 that?
6 A As to this case?
7 Q This particular case, yes, have you seen the offer
8 dated August 1991, or any document reflecting an amendment
9 on September 19th, 1991?
10 A I have seen the correspondence from the Department of
11 Justice to the taxpayer's attorneys.
12 Q Fair enough.
13 A And vice versa.
14 Q Let me go back and I think you told Mr. White, or you
15 summarized for Mr. White a provision of this collateral
16 agreement, in which you said that it includes for purposes
17 of this agreement in Mr. Gordon's income, not just his own
18 income, but income of corporations that he owned, closely
19 held corporations that he owned; is that correct?
20 A That's correct.
21 Q But does it not also include income of corporations
22 that he controls, as opposed to owned?
23 A Allow me to read it?
24 Q Please do. Look at paragraph 3: I will read the
25 first clause to you.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
306
Gagliardi-cross/Trabulus
1 That in the event closely held corporations are
2 directly or indirectly controlled or owned by the taxpayer
3 during the existence of this agreement, and then it
4 proceeds.
5 A Uh-huh.
6 Q Yes?
7 A Yes.
8 Q And so, for purposes of this collateral agreement, it
9 doesn't make any difference as to whether the corporation
10 is owned or controlled? It operates the same way; is that
11 right?
12 A That appears to be the intent.
13 Q Now, let's turn to the shareholder -- the
14 compensation agreement, which was disclosed to you by
15 Mr. Reffsin; is that correct? It was disclosed to you by
16 him; is that right?
17 A Right.
18 Q And the compensation agreement was -- and you will
19 forgive me, but it is 420-G.
20 (Whereupon, at this time there was a pause in the
21 proceedings.)
22 MR. TRABULUS: I am making sure the jurors all
23 have it.
24 (Whereupon, at this time there was a pause in the
25 proceedings.)
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
307
Gagliardi-cross/Trabulus
1 Q This compensation agreement indicates, does it not,
2 that Mr. Gordon was the president of Who's Who Worldwide,
3 Inc.; is that correct?
4 A President and chief executive officer.
5 Q That's my next question, Mr. Gagliardi.
6 A I am sorry.
7 Q Chief executive officer as well.
8 And it indicates he is responsible for running
9 the day to day operations of Who's Who Worldwide, Inc.; is
10 that right?
11 A Yes, it does.
12 Q And that would certainly indicate to you, did it not,
13 that he controlled Who's Who Worldwide; is that correct?
14 A It indicated he was the managing officer.
15 Q Would being the president and chief executive officer
16 of a company indicate to you that a person was in control
17 of it, directly or indirectly?
18 A You want my understanding?
19 Q Well, what was your understa nding at the time when
20 you read that? Did it occur to you that he might be in
21 control of it?
22 A At the time it appeared to me that he was a contract
23 employee.
24 Q Did you understand that regardless of whether he was
25 a contract employee or not that he might be in control of
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
308
Gagliardi-cross/Trabulus
1 it? Did that even occur to you?
2 A I can't say if I can recollect whether or not.
3 Q Certainly, Mr. Reffsin on Mr. Gordon's behalf did not
4 conceal from you that Mr. Gordon was the president, chief
5 executive officer and responsible for the day to day
6 operations of Who's Who Worldwide, did he? He didn't
7 conceal that at all?
8 A No, he did not.
9 Q Now, it also indicated that he was to be a director
10 of Who's Who Worldwide; is that correct?
11 A Y es.
12 Q And corporations are generally controlled, if by
13 nobody else, by their directors; is that correct? Did you
14 understand that?
15 A I understand that.
16 Q Did you inquire as to whether there were any other
17 directors or anybody else who might be in control?
18 A No, I didn't, because --
19 Q So, as far as -- as far as you knew -- the only
20 director of Who's Who Worldwide that you were aware of,
21 was Mr. Gordon; is that correct?
22 A My understanding of the agreement --
23 Q Please tell me if that's correct?
24 MR. WHITE: Objection. Let the witness finish
25 the answer.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
309
Gagliardi-cross/Trabulus
1 THE COURT: He can't finish the answer. The
2 answer was not responsive. If he did I would strike the
3 answer if a motion was made that it was not respons ive.
4 As I told the first witness produced, as I will
5 tell each one, on cross-examination you will be asked
6 questions that pinpoint certain things. A cross-examiner
7 has a right to do that.
8 So, almost every question calls for a yes or no.
9 If you can't say yes or no, say so.
10 THE WITNESS: I am sorry, your Honor.
11 THE COURT: That shifts the burden back to
12 Mr. Trabulus to decide what to do. You can say I can't
13 answer the question yes or no. No explanation, if you
14 don't remember or don't know, say so. That's the way it
15 is done.
16 THE WITNESS: All right.
17 Can you repeat the question?
18 Q Is it correct that the only director of Who's Who
19 Worldwide of whom you were aware at the time was
20 Mr. Gordon?
21 A That's correct.
22 MR. TRABULUS: Your Honor, I am going to ask,
23 with your Honor's permission, if th e government has any
24 additional copies of the documents he just provided to me
25 this morning, the October 15th, 1991 -- the
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
310
Gagliardi-cross/Trabulus
1 correspondence, I believe, that the witness has testified
2 to.
3 Do you have any additional copies?
4 MR. WHITE: I have three extra copies, will that
5 help?
6 MR. TRABULUS: Perhaps.
7 MR. WHITE: That's the whole set.
8 (Documents handed to Mr. Trabulus.)
9 MR. TRABULUS: Thank you.
10 Your Honor, I would like to show the witness -- I
11 have given Mr. Reffsin a copy, and there are copies for
12 other counsel, if they want them.
13 (Handed to the witness.)
14 Q Mr. Gagliardi, I am showing you what is marked as
15 Gordon A, and I didn't have the right kind of stickers, so
16 I penned it in the upper right -hand corner.
17 Is this one of the correspondence relating to the
18 collateral agreement that you were familiar with?
19 A I never received this agreement. So if you give me
20 an opportunity to review it?
21 Q Sure.
22 (Whereupon, at this time there was a pause in the
23 proceedings.)
24 A It appears to be.
25 MR. TRABULUS: Your Honor, I would offer
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
311
Gagliardi-cross/Trabulus
1 Gordon A.
2 THE COURT: Any objection?
3 MR. WHITE: Your Honor, may I have a brief voir
4 dire of the witness?
5 THE COURT: Surely.
6 You will hear this from time to time, that the
7 lawyer not doing the cross-examination, or the examination
8 is going to ask for voir dire, which are two French words
9 meaning to see or to say. It is like when they voir dired
10 the jury. An d these questions are designed to bring out
11 whether the document is admissible or not. It is not for
12 any other purpose. It is as to whether the document is
13 admissible.
14 Go ahead.
15
16 VOIR DIRE EXAMINATION
17 BY MR. WHITE:
18 Q Mr. Gagliardi, at any time while you were considering
19 Mr. Gordon's offer in compromise, did you see this
20 document?
21 A No, I did not.
22 Q When was the first time you saw this document?
23 A When I was shown it by you.
24 Q And when was that?
25 A This morning.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
312
Gagliardi-cross/Trabulus
1 MR. WHITE: No further questions, your Honor.
2 I object to the offer.
3 THE COURT: Can I see the document?
4 MR. TRABULUS: Certainly, your Honor.
5 THE COURT: No, give it to me. He is the
6 reporter. I am the judge.
7 MR. TRABULUS: I know. I was going --
8 THE COURT: We want to get our in-title work
9 straightened out here.
10 It is all right, because Mr. Gordon follows what
11 they do in the state court. In the state court the
12 lawyers always hand the exhibits to somebody else, not the
13 judge. Why that is, I don't know. But we stopped that
14 here. I am the one who has to look at it.
15 What happens is they give the exhibit to the
16 reporter and then he hands it to me. But we don't do that
17 here.
18 (Handed to the Court.)
19 THE COURT: Sustained.
20 This is hearsay, is it not?
21 MR. TRABULUS: No. If we can approach, I will
22 explain the basis for the offer or the relevance of it.
23 THE COURT: The relevance I am not getting to. I
24 am getting to the fact that it is the letterhead of a law
25 firm.
HARRY RAPAPORT , CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
313
Gagliardi-cross/Trabulus
1 MR. TRABULUS: Your Honor, the collateral
2 agreement refers to this letter. It then refers to a
3 subsequent letter which amends it.
4 THE COURT: Show me where in the collateral
5 agreement it refers to this letter.
6 MR. TRABULUS: Sure.
7 Your Honor, that's 420-H, and it refers in the
8 first paragraph of 420-H, it refers to an offer dated
9 August 29th, 1991. And that's this letter. Indeed it is
10 really almost -- I guess the classic word for it would be
11 res gestae. It is like an offer and acceptance. It is
12 not offered for the truth. It is just for what the
13 history proposals are.
14 THE COURT: Notwithstanding your knowledge of
15 Latin, Mr. Trabulus, we don't use those terms any more.
16 As a matter of fact, the United States Supreme Court has
17 disapproved o f the use of Latin words. We are an English
18 speaking nation, not Latin or any other language.
19 MR. TRABULUS: Mea culpa.
20 THE COURT: Very good, Mr. Trabulus.
21 First of all, we don't know that this is the
22 document. How are you going to show that.
23 MR. TRABULUS: Let me show with a few other
24 questions with your Honor's permission?
25 THE COURT: Go ahead.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
314
Gagliardi-cross/Trabulus
1
2 CROSS-EXAMINATION (cont'd)
3 BY MR. TRABULUS:
4 Q Mr. Gagliardi, do you recognize the received stamp
5 that appears on that?
6 A Received August 30th, 1991, Internal Revenue Service.
7 Q Does that stamp, is it in the ordinary course of the
8 Internal Revenue Service's business, is it placed upon
9 documents as it is received?
10 A Yes, it is. Tax returns, etcetera.
11 Q Is it your understanding that this is the offer dated
12 August 29th, 1991, that is referred to in the collateral
13 agreement?
14 A That's my understanding. But I can't state that
15 fact.
16 Q Well --
17 MR. TRABULUS: Your Honor, this document was
18 originally first given to me by the government.
19 Q Mr. Trabulus, assuming it is the offer dated August
20 29th, 1991, which is set forth in
21 Government's Exhibit 420-H, the collateral agreement, what
22 relevancy does that have? Does this collateral agreement
23 confirm this offer?
24 A This collateral agreement modifies this offer.
25 What happens is that the offer -- the offer of
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
315
Gagliardi-cross/Trabulus
1 August 29th just talks about Mr. Gordon's income, without
2 mentioning picking up any other income of any corporations
3 he is related to.
4 The Justice Department comes back suggesting that
5 he was well aware that he controlled, and had ownership
6 agreements in corporations. They are the ones who
7 insisted on that change.
8 THE COURT: I don't see anything in this
9 document, Defendant's Exhibit Gordon A for Identification,
10 that says anything about an ownership interests.
11 MR. TRABULUS: This is a document from
12 Mr. Gordon's then attorney. It is the proposal by his
13 then attorney. They were in communications and talked
14 about discussions over the --
15 THE COURT: What does it have to do with anything
16 involving this case now? Why is it important?
17 THE COURT: You want me to explain it at this
18 point?
19 MR. TRABULUS: You want me to explain it at this
20 point?
21 THE COURT: Yes, explain it.
22 MR. TRABULUS: It appe ars that the government
23 contends that there was concealment from the IRS that
24 Mr. Gordon had an interest in --
25 THE COURT: This document shows that he revealed
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
316
Gagliardi-cross/Trabulus
1 the interest?
2 MR. TRABULUS: This document --
3 THE COURT: This document is
4 Defendant's Exhibit Gordon A, for Abel, for
5 Identification.
6 MR. TRABULUS: Gordon A read in conjunction with
7 420-H, and also in conjunction with another document given
8 to me today memorializing the September 19th, and they
9 were then negotiations. And Mr. Gordon's then attorney
10 said we will enter into an arrangement --
11 MR. WHITE: I sort of object to Mr. Trabulus
12 portraying all the history admissible in his best light,
13 just talking off the top of his head about this.
14 THE COUR T: It is not evidence. The jury knows
15 that whatever the lawyers say is not evidence. But
16 instead of having 14 sidebars per hour, let's cut them
17 down.
18 MR. WHITE: That's fine with me, your Honor.
19 THE COURT: I see nothing in this agreement that
20 says that. Sustained.
21 Q I would like to show you Gordon B.
22 (Handed to the witness.)
23 Mr. Gagliardi, do you recognize Gordon B?
24 A No, I don't.
25 Q Do you recognize what it is?
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
317
Gagliardi-cross/Trabulus
1 A Yes.
2 Q What is it?
3 A Form 433-A, collection information statement for
4 individuals.
5 Q Does it indicate that it was prepared for Bruce
6 Gordon?
7 A Yes, it does.
8 THE COURT: What is the date on it?
9 MR. TRABULUS: The date on it is 12/21, and on
10 this co py it is a little cut off. I believe it is '91. I
11 think it is actually '91.
12 At the top it indicates as per 8/91, suggesting
13 it is '91. The copy I was given, your Honor, produced by
14 the government is itself somewhat cut off.
15 THE COURT: Okay.
16 Let's move along. It is a cut off 1991; is that
17 right? It is not to say an abbreviated 1991, just a cut
18 off 1991.
19 MR. TRABULUS: Your Honor, I would offer it in
20 evidence.
21 THE COURT: Any objection?
22 MR. WHITE: Voir dire, your Honor?
23 THE COURT: Go ahead.
24
25
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
318
Gagliardi-cross/Trabulus
1 VOIR DIRE EXAMINATION
2 BY MR. WHITE:
3 Q Mr. Gagliardi, you said you recognize this as form
4 433-A?
5 A That's correct.
6 Q Have you ever seen this particular document before ?
7 A No, sir.
8 MR. WHITE: Objection, your Honor.
9 THE COURT: Can I see it, please?
10 (Handed to the Court.)
11 THE COURT: Is this Form 433-A an official form
12 of the United States Government?
13 THE WITNESS: It is, sir.
14 THE COURT: Is it a form made by the United
15 States Government in the regular course of its business?
16 THE WITNESS: Yes, it is.
17 THE COURT: Was it the business of the United
18 States Government to make forms such as this?
19 THE WITNESS: Yes, sir, it is.
20 THE COURT: Without stating to me what it is,
21 point out the relevancy of this. What is it in this
22 document that is relevant?
23 MR. TRABULUS: Your Honor, box 7, and it has two
24 entries. The second one is of particular relevance in
25 terms of the issues we have been talking about.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
319
Gagliardi-cross/Trabulus
1 The last page, it is a little hard to read, but
2 under the heading income, the column gross, what is under
3 that is also relevant.
4 I have to point something out, your Honor. The
5 indictment alleges filing three false collection
6 information statements. This is a fourth one. It doesn't
7 allege that it is false, and it was filed in the midst of
8 the other three, and there are --
9 THE COURT: All I wanted to know is what you said
10 is relevant.
11 You are objecting to this document on what
12 ground, Mr. White?
13 MR. WHITE: Your Honor, I don't believe, or I
14 don't know if this document was ever filed with the
15 Internal Revenue Service. For all I know it may have come
16 from Mr. Gordon's files and it was never filed.
17 THE COURT: Good point.
18 Is there any way to know by looking at Gordo n
19 Exhibit B for Identification, as to whether it was filed
20 or received by anyone in the government?
21 Before we get to that, who drew up this
22 document?
23 THE WITNESS: It is published by the federal
24 government, the Internal Revenue Service.
25 THE COURT: I mean the form is. But someone then
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
320
Gagliardi-cross/Trabulus
1 fills it out?
2 THE WITNESS: Yes, the taxpayer or
3 representative.
4 THE COURT: The taxpayer fills it out, and then
5 delivers it, or sends it to the government?
6 THE WITNESS: Yes, sir.
7 THE COURT: Is there anything on this document
8 that would show that this was received by the government?
9 Do you have a copy in front of you?
10 THE WITNESS: No, you have the copy.
11 THE COURT: Do you want to show it?
12 MR. TRABULUS : Yes, sir.
13 THE COURT: This is the copy he had -- excuse me
14 a minute.
15 MR. TRABULUS: Surely.
16 (Whereupon, at this time there was a pause in the
17 proceedings.)
18 THE COURT: Do you went to show it to him?
19 MR. TRABULUS: Yes.
20 (Handed to the witness.)
21 THE COURT: Is your name Gagliardi, or Galiardi?
22 THE WITNESS: Whatever you wish.
23 THE COURT: There was a prominent Judge, Joseph
24 Galiardi, administrative judge of the Ninth District. We
25 went to meetings together when I was the administrative
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
321
Gagliardi-cross/Trabulus
1 judge. He pronounced it with a silent G. You don't care
2 which way you hear it?
3 THE WITNESS: No, sir.
4 THE COURT: All right.
5 (Whereupon, at this time there was a pause in the
6 proceedings.)
7 TH E WITNESS: There was no way to tell if it was
8 ever received by the Internal Revenue Service.
9
10 CROSS-EXAMINATION (cont'd)
11 BY MR. TRABULUS:
12 Q Mr. Gagliardi, is there a document to indicate what
13 filings, or what dates filings were made by Mr. Gordon of
14 collection information statements? Is there a document
15 like a log or something like that that the IRS maintains?
16 A As an IRS officer, we keep notes of what we receive.
17 I kept such a log. But I never received such a statement.
18 Q Understood. But is there some record within the
19 Internal Revenue Service whereby someone familiar with
20 Internal Revenue Service procedures, would be able to,
21 even if they had not themselves received it, would be able
22 to determine if a collection statement dated 12/21/91 was
23 received?
24 A No, sir. There are not -- on most documents, such as
25 tax returns, etcetera, there are document locator
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
322
Gagliardi-cross/Trabulus
1 numbers. But this information is for the collection of a
2 tax liability, and it is retained only in those case
3 files, and then when the case is closed it is shipped out.
4 Q Shipped out to where?
5 A Storage, and finally the federal records center.
6 Q Do you have any familiarity with how the collection
7 information statements which the government has introduced
8 in evidence in this case with respect to Mr. Gordon, how
9 they were obtained?
10 A How they were obtained?
11 It is my understanding that they were maintained
12 by the offer in compromise. There is an offer in
13 compromise unit in the Internal Revenue Service. I
14 believe that that is where they came from. I don't have
15 specific kn owledge.
16 Q Now, you --
17 THE COURT: Excuse me one moment, Mr. Trabulus.
18 MR. TRABULUS: Sure.
19 THE COURT: When a document like this,
20 Defendant's Exhibit B for Identification, where is it sent
21 to? What part of the government would receive this
22 document?
23 THE WITNESS: It would be received in the
24 collection of an income tax liability verification, by the
25 Internal Revenue Service collections division. And that's
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
323
Gagliardi-cross/Trabulus
1 only an intent. It is not filed as a tax return.
2 THE COURT: But it is received by some agency in
3 the government?
4 THE WITNESS: It is received by the Internal
5 Revenue Service collections division.
6 THE COURT: Is there a custom and usage that a
7 document like that received would be stamped in any way?
8 THE WITNESS: No, sir, it is not the custom.
9 THE COURT: They don't stamp "received"?
10 THE WITNESS: No, sir.
11 MR. TRABULUS: Your Honor, this document was
12 provided by the government.
13 MR. WHITE: The government provided the defense
14 with all the documents, no matter where they got them
15 from.
16 THE COURT: In order for you to introduce this
17 document, because there is a difference in the
18 admissibility standard with respect to the government
19 introducing this, you understand that, Mr. Trabulus, such
20 as 801(d)(2). And you introducing it.
21 MR. TRABULUS: Your Honor, I think 801(d)(2)
22 doesn't come into issue here, because regardless of truth
23 or falsehood of a document, the content of it has to be
24 looked at in connection with other documents. It is to be
25 considered for issues -- other documents have to be read
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
324
Gagliardi-cross/Trabulus
1 in light of it.
2 Your Honor, I think we should approach on this.
3 THE COURT: No reason to approach. There is no
4 proof as of now that the government received it.
5 For example, you are trying to prove that the
6 government knew that he was, whatever it says in that
7 document; is that correct?
8 MR. TRABULUS: That's correct, your Honor.
9 THE COURT: But if they didn't get it, that's not
10 proof of that.
11 MR. TRABULUS: That's true.
12 THE COURT: Okay. That's why I am keeping it
13 out.
14 Q Now, Mr. Gagliardi, with regard to Exhibit 426, that
15 was a letter, was it not, in which Mr. Reffsin disclosed
16 the fact that his employer, Mr. Gordon's employer, had
17 been bankrupt -- excuse me, filed for bankruptcy; is that
18 correct?
19 A That's correct.
20 Q And Mr. Reffsin certainly made no secret of that, did
21 he?
22 A No, he didn't.
23 Q And where he indicated that the bankruptcy could
24 affect future income projections, did you understand that
25 to mean because of the bankruptcy of the employer there
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
325
Gagliardi-cross/Trabulus
1 might be less money available for Mr. Gordon?
2 A My understanding of it?
3 Q Yes.
4 A My understanding --
5 THE COURT: It calls for a yes or no answer. Did
6 you understand by looking at that letter that Mr. Gordon
7 would have less money to pay the government?
8 THE WITNESS: Yes, your Honor.
9 Q Now, in the course of your investigation that you
10 indicated you did, going to different places, did you ever
11 go and take a look at the bankruptcy filings?
12 A No.
13 Q Is those -- withdrawn.
14 Where was your office located?
15 A In Garden City.
16 Q And was it your understanding that the bankruptcy
17 filings -- the bankruptcies files were located in Westbury
18 at the time?
19 A My understanding, yes.
20 Q To do that would simply have been to go from Garden
21 City to Westbury to look at the files in the bankruptcy
22 court; is that correct?
23 A If a need arose.
24 Q Did you ever advise Mr. Reffsin as to whether you
25 would or would not be doing that?
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
326
Gagliardi-cross/Trabulus
1 A No, sir.
2 Q Did you ever, going back to -- going back to the
3 compensation agreement, 420-G, that provided, did it not
4 that Mr. Gordon's compensation would have a component that
5 would be based upon cash flow of Who's Wh o Worldwide; is
6 that correct?
7 A Basically.
8 Q And in the course of your investigation or analysis
9 as to whether to accept the offer in compromise, did you
10 ever check the corporate tax returns of Who's Who
11 Worldwide?
12 A No, sir.
13 Q Did you ever ask for them?
14 A No, sir.
15 Q Did it occur to you that information in them might
16 bear upon were Mr. Gordon's compensation would be or
17 should have been?
18 A The only answer I can give is I had no reason to
19 obtain those tax returns, based on the information
20 provided.
21 Q Did you ever request them of Mr. Reffsin?
22 A No, sir.
23 Q Did you ever tell Mr. Reffsin that you didn't have a
24 set of them yourself?
25 A It never became an issue with Mr. Reffsin.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
327
Gagliardi-cross/Tra bulus
1 Q You never even discussed the corporate tax returns
2 with Mr. Reffsin; is that fair to say?
3 A Never discussed them.
4 Q Mr. Gagliardi, at the time when you were reviewing
5 the collateral agreement, 420-H, the one we talked about
6 control ownership, did you in reviewing it believe --
7 withdrawn.
8 At the time you reviewed it, you understood that
9 it contained a definition of income which was different
10 than Mr. Gordon's taxable income as it would be normally
11 defined? Did you understand that?
12 A I know I made a notation in my chronology of exactly
13 what my understanding was. If you want me to refresh my
14 memory, I will.
15 Q Was that understanding that the difference between
16 what that agreement provided and what might ordinarily be
17 understood to be his taxable income, is that the agreement
18 looked at Mr. Gordon's adjusted gross income?
19 A Yes.
20 Q And you made no note of any understanding that it
21 picked up any income of any corporation that Mr. Gordon
22 might have had a connection with; is that correct?
23 A I don't understand the question.
24 Q You indicate a moment or two ago that you made a note
25 at the time concerning your understanding. And I was
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
328
Gagliardi-cross/Trabulus
1 going to ask you whether in that note, besides referring
2 to the fact that the agreement, as you understood it at
3 the time looked to Mr. Gordon's adjusted gross income, did
4 you note any other differences between that -- between --
5 withdrawn. I am sorry.
6 In your note did you make any note -- you made a
7 note of the fact that it picked up his adjusted gross
8 income; is that right?
9 A If you allow me to look at my notes --
10 Q You can certainly look at your note.
11 I think what you are referring to there is
12 Exhibit 3500-8-A; is that correct?
13 A Yes.
14 Q Now, without telling -- just tell me whether looking
15 at that note, as to whether you have refreshed your
16 recollection as to what you put in at the time; and look
17 at the third page.
18 MR. WHITE: Can I ask Mr. Trabulus what date he
19 is looking at?
20 MR. TRABULUS: The third page, the entry is under
21 10/11/94. And I am just trying to -- the handwriting is a
22 little small.
23 THE WITNESS: Sorry.
24 MR. TRABULUS: You should see mine. Maybe I am
25 on the wrong page.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
329
Gagliardi-cross/Trabulus
1 (Whereupon, at this time there was a pause in the
2 proceedings.)
3 MR. TRA BULUS: I think it is on the third page,
4 entry for 10/11/94.
5 Q Take a look at the ninth line down, maybe the eighth
6 or the ninth line down.
7 (Whereupon, at this time there was a pause in the
8 proceedings.)
9 Q Do you see what I am referring to?
10 A Not particularly, no.
11 Q Are you able to read that portion?
12 A I am able to read it. 10/11/94 --
13 Q Don't read it outloud.
14 The sentence, the collateral required, that
15 sentence, the eighth line down, or seventh line down, the
16 eighth line. Just read that.
17 Does it refresh your recollection that at that
18 time the collateral agreement required payment based upon
19 adjusted gross income, rather than taxable income, and
20 requires 50 percent of income over $50,000 after federal
21 taxes are paid? Was that your understanding in a nutshell
22 of what the collateral agreement r equired at the time?
23 Yes or no, sir.
24 A Yes.
25 Q And you made no notation about it, including income
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
330
Gagliardi-cross/Trabulus
1 of any corporations; is that correct?
2 A I made no notation, no.
3 MR. TRABULUS: Your Honor, I will just be a
4 moment longer.
5 THE COURT: Yes.
6 (Whereupon, at this time there was a pause in the
7 proceedings.)
8 Q Let me ask you, how much period of time elapsed
9 between the time that the collateral agreement was first
10 submitted, and the time that you made a recommendation
11 with respect to it?
12 A It was two separate issues, the collateral
13 agreement --
14 Q I am sorry, I misspoke.
15 How much time went by between the time the offer
16 in compromise was submitted, and the time that you made a
17 recommendation with respect to it?
18 A Almost a year.
19 Q Now, during that time did you make any tentative
20 counter proposals to Mr. Reffsin suggesting a larger
21 amount of money?
22 A No, sir.
23 Q Would it be typical in discussions concerning an
24 offer in compromise for there to be give and take between
25 the two sides, an offer, a counter-offer, and discussions
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
331
Gagliardi-cross/Trabulus
1 to reach some kind of understanding in-between?
2 A If there are assets being evaluated, yes.
3 MR. TRABULUS: No further questions, your Honor.
4 THE COURT: Mr. Wallenstein.
5 MR. WALLENSTEIN: Thank you, your Honor.
6
7 CROSS-EXAMINATION
8 BY MR. WALLENSTEIN:
9 Q Good morning, Mr. Gagliardi. Good afternoon.
10 A Almost.
11 Q Close.
12 My name is John Wallenstein and I represent
13 Martin Reffsin.
14 If I understand this correctly, you first learned
15 of this when the offer in compromise was referred to you;
16 is that correct?
17 A I learned of this meeting, the tax situation?
18 Q Well, this particular tax situation. When you
19 undertook your duties in connection with collecting
20 liabilities from Mr. Gordon, the first time that that
21 occurred was in November of '93; is that correct?
22 A As to the offer in compromise?
23 Q Right.
24 A Yes.
25 Q And between then and sometime in 1995, you were the
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
332
Gagliardi-cross/Wallenstein
1 revenue officer who was in charge of this particular
2 investigation; is that correct?
3 A That's correct.
4 Q And in connection with that, you obtained substantial
5 d ocumentation from Mr. Reffsin on Mr. Gordon's behalf?
6 A That's correct.
7 Q And you also conducted field investigations of your
8 own, you went to DMV, you went to Nassau County, and went
9 out to look at the condo and all those things; is that
10 correct?
11 A Correct.
12 Q At no time did you ask for and obtain corporate tax
13 returns from Who's Who Worldwide; is that correct?
14 A Correct.
15 Q You never asked Mr. Reffsin for them, and you never
16 requisitioned them, or whatever else you have to do to get
17 them from the IRS itself; is that correct?
18 A I would not be permitted to, no.
19 Q You had no authority to obtain those corporate tax
20 returns?
21 A Not for his employer.
22 Q Did you ever ask Mr. Reffsin or Mr. Gordon for
23 authority?
24 A It never became an issue. My understanding is he was
25 an employee.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
333
Gagliardi-cross/Wallenstein
1 Q And you had the collateral agreement from day one?
2 That was part of the offer in compromise submitted in July
3 of 1993?
4 A Correct.
5 Q Correct?
6 A Yes.
7 Q Now, would you take a look, please at the power of
8 attorney, and that is 420-C.
9 A I have it.
10 Q You have it?
11 A Yes.
12 Q That power of attorney is signed by Mr. Gordon and
13 gives Mr. Reffsin authority to act in his behalf; is that
14 correct?
15 A Yes.
16 Q Are there limitations on what Mr. Reffsin can do
17 acting under that power of attorney?
18 A They are specified in the power of attorney.
19 Q He can't get any money if the IRS -- that he could,
20 but he couldn't have if he had?
21 Now, does the fact that Mr. Gordon signed a power
22 of attorney giving Mr. Reffsin power to act on his behalf
23 preclude Mr. Gordon from acting personally?
24 A No, it doesn't.
25 Q Okay.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
334
Gagliardi-cross/Wallenstein
1 Now, in fact, he can revoke the power of attorney
2 at any time; is that correct?
3 A Yes, he could.
4 Q In effect then, would it be fair to say that this
5 power of attorney permits Mr. Reffsin to act as
6 Mr. Gordon's agent?
7 A It would be fair to say.
8 Q Did you at some point receive, either 1991, or 1992
9 1040s for Mr. Gordon?
10 A It is my recollection.
11 Q Were they part of the initial offer in compromise, do
12 you know? Or part of the documents received later?
13 A Part of the documentation. I am not sure of the time
14 frame without looking.
15 Q Do you recall having re ceived schedules and
16 attachments attached to either or both of the '91 or '92
17 personal returns?
18 A I don't believe so, no.
19 Q Would you look, please, at Exhibit 420-F.
20 Would you tell me what that is?
21 A Form 1040 of 1990.
22 Q Are you looking at the same documents I am looking
23 at?
24 A Plaintiff's Exhibit F, clients copy, U.S. individual
25 income tax return, 1990.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
335
Gagliardi-cross/Wallenstein
1 Q Take a look about six pages into that, and there is
2 another document marked 420-F.
3 A F-1, okay.
4 Q I think the 1990 return should be an E, but the
5 bottom line of the E seems to have merged with the black
6 line there.
7 A Okay.
8 Q I made the same mistake. I am looking at the '91
9 return.
10 A I have that.
11 Q T here are attachments with that; is that correct?
12 Schedules, statement of income, and so on.
13 A The only attachment is a statement of income.
14 Q Is there a second page to that that is not here?
15 A Second page to --
16 Q To that statement of income.
17 A I have no knowledge of that. This is the information
18 as received.
19 Q Under paragraph 2, under 2E, there is a reference to
20 a note A; is that correct?
21 A Where is that?
22 Q On that statement of income, the fourth page of
23 420-F?
24 A 420-F, I have one, two, three pages. I don't have a
25 fourth page.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
336
Gagliardi-cross/Wallenstein
1 Q I am looking at a document headed statement of annual
2 income for the year 1991, Bruce Gordon.
3 A I am sorry. Okay, yes.
4 Q You got it?
5 A I though t it was other document.
6 Q Item 2E, it makes reference to a note A. But there
7 is no note A on this page; is that correct?
8 A Not that I see.
9 Q And would that lead you to believe that there was in
10 fact a second page or even a third page?
11 A It would be a fair assumption.
12 Q Do you recall ever seeing a second page that
13 indicated that Mr. Gordon had a 75 percent ownership
14 interest in Who's Who Worldwide?
15 A No, sir.
16 Q Let me direct your attention now to Exhibit 425.
17 An undated letter from you to Mr. Reffsin; is
18 that correct?
19 A You have to give me a moment.
20 Q You should have had a book where they are all
21 marked.
22 A 420 --
23 Q 425.
24 A 425.
25 (Whereupon, at this time there was a pause in the
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
337
Gagliardi-cro ss/Wallenstein
1 proceedings.)
2 THE COURT: Do you want to show him your copy to
3 save time?
4 THE WITNESS: I am sorry, it is turned in.
5 Q Now, you received that from Mr. Reffsin; is that
6 right?
7 A Yes.
8 Q That's the transmittal letter for the copies of the
9 promissory note?
10 A Correct.
11 Q Would it be fair to say when you got those promissory
12 notes, the one for $15,000 from Joyce Grossman, and
13 $10,000 to Madeline Middlemark, you examined those
14 documents and relied upon them in determining the
15 taxpayer's assets?
16 A That's correct.
17 Q And on their face they appear to be general
18 promissory notes of debts totalling $25,000; is that
19 right?
20 A Yes.
21 Q Did you do any investigation with respect to those
22 notes?
23 A No, sir.
24 Q Did you call Joyce Grossman to ask if she really
25 loaned the $15,000?
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
338
Gagliardi-cross/Wallenstein
1 A No, sir.
2 Q Or Ms. Middlemark and ask if she loaned the 10,000?
3 A No, sir.
4 Q And you took them and felt that it looks right to me?
5 A Yes.
6 Q Is that correct?
7 A Correct.
8 Q And the same would apply to the third page of that
9 Exhibit 425C, the letter from Maria Gaspar, G A S P A R;
10 is that correct?
11 A Right.
12 Q And the same it would apply to 425-D, the letter from
13 Who's Who Worldwide; is that correct?
14 A Correct.
15 Q The 433-A collection statements, which are part of
16 Exhibit 420, I believe, specifically, 420-D.
17 You have that?
18 A Yes.
19 Q And that document is signed by Mr. Gordon and not
20 Mr. Reffsin; is that correct?
21 A Yes, sir.
22 Q And if you lack at 420-A, please, the offer in
23 compromise, that document also bears Mr. Gordon's
24 signature and not Mr. Reffsin's; is that correct?
25 A Correct.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
339
Gagliardi-cross/Wallenstein
1 Q In fact, the transmittal letter on Exhibit 420
2 itself, dated July 27th, 1993, on the letterhead of
3 M. Reffsin & Company, that's a two-page document which is
4 also signed by Bruce Gordon and not by Martin Reffsin; is
5 that correct?
6 A Correct.
7 Q In fact, in connection with the offer in compromise
8 other than letters, there are no documents signed by
9 Mr. Reffsin; is that correct?
10 A That's correct.
11 Q And those letters advanced -- those letters referred
12 to Mr. Gordon's position with respect to certain matters
13 that you had requeste d; is that correct?
14 A Correct.
15 Q And the financial letters you had requested and
16 received in connection with this offer in compromise were
17 Mr. Gordon's records and not Mr. Reffsin's; is that
18 correct?
19 A Correct.
20 MR. WALLENSTEIN: No further questions.
21 Thank you.
22 THE COURT: Anything else, Mr. White?
23 MR. WHITE: Yes, your Honor. There is an issue I
24 think I need to discuss with Mr. Wallenstein and
25 Mr. Trabulus, perhaps over lunch with respect to
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
340
Gagliardi-cross/Wallenstein
1 documents.
2 THE COURT: With respect to this witness?
3 MR. WHITE: Yes.
4 THE COURT: Anything else to question him on
5 besides that?
6 MR. WHITE: Yes. Shall I proceed with that?
7 THE COURT: Well, let's go.
8
9 REDIRECT EXAMINATI ON
10 BY MR. WHITE:
11 Q Now, Mr. Gagliardi, do you recall Mr. Trabulus asked
12 you regarding whether or not you attempted to get 433-A
13 forms prepared by Mr. Gordon prior to the submission of
14 the offer in compromise?
15 A Yes, I do.
16 Q Did you try to get them?
17 A No, I didn't try.
18 Q Why not?
19 A It wasn't really pertinent. We were investigating
20 his current assets and income.
21 Q Now, do you have Exhibit 423 in front of you?
22 A Yes, I do.
23 Q Is it 423, if you look on, that's the December 1993
24 collection information statement; is that correct?
25 A That's correct.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
341
Gagliardi-redirect/White
1 Q And look on page 3 of that.
2 Do you see on box 28, there is a liability listed
3 for $30,000, charge accounts?
4 A Yes, I do .
5 Q And Mr. Trabulus asked you if you pursued what those
6 charge accounts were. Do you recall that?
7 A Yes, I recall it.
8 Q What is your understanding of what that term that
9 references charge accounts refer to?
10 MR. TRABULUS: Objection, your Honor.
11 THE COURT: Overruled.
12 A A past debt.
13 Q A past debt?
14 A Yes.
15 Q And why did you assume it was a past debt?
16 A Because there was no information regarding any
17 current charge cards or revolving credit.
18 Q And if you take a look at Government's Exhibit 421-A,
19 which is your letter to Mr. Reffsin from November '93.
20 A Right.
21 Q And Mr. Reffsin responded to that in early '94; is
22 that correct?
23 A Yes, sir.
24 Q And did you ask him for verification of all monthly
25 payments if not paid by your personal check?
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
342
Gagliardi-redirect/White
1 A Yes, I did.
2 Q Did you get any?
3 A No, sir.
4 Q And did you ask for his checks for April through
5 October of '93?
6 A Yes, I did.
7 Q Did you review them?
8 A Yes, I did.
9 Q Were there any credit card payments included there?
10 A No, sir.
11 Q Okay.
12 If you look at 420-D, like in David; that's the
13 July of 1993 collection information statement; is that
14 correct?
15 A Yes.
16 Q And that also has a reference to a $32,000 charge
17 account liability; is that right?
18 A Yes, sir.
19 Q And what did you understand that referred to?
20 A My understanding of all of those items were that they
21 were monies that he owed previously.
22 MR. WHITE: Your Honor, would you bear with us
23 one minute? I need an enlargement.
24 THE COURT: Surely.
25 (Whereupon, at this time there was a pause in the
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
343
Gagliardi-redirect/White
1 proceedings.)
2 MR. WHITE: I am sorry, your Honor, we have so
3 many charts.
4 THE COURT: That's all right.
5 (Whereupon, at this time there was a pause in the
6 proceedings.)
7 Q Now, Mr. Gagliardi, the two collection information
8 statements we just referred to, Exhibits 423 and 423-D,
9 were submitted in 1993 to you; is that correct?
10 A Yes.
11 Q And both of those submitted -- both of those
12 indicated that the liabilities were for, quote, charge
13 account, unquote; is that correct?
14 A Correct.
15 Q Let me show you what is already in evidence as
16 Government's Exhibit 404-A.
17 That's a prior collection information statement
18 fro m September of 1991; is that right?
19 A Yes, sir.
20 Q And if you can step down here, Mr. Gagliardi, and if
21 you could look on box 35, where it says "other
22 liabilities" and could you read what line C says.
23 A It says shopper's charge, $32,000, ex-wife as
24 charges.
25 Q Ex-wife's charges?
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
344
Gagliardi-redirect/White
1 A Yes, sir.
2 Q You can be seated again.
3 Now, if you turn to --
4 THE COURT: Have you concluded your thought on
5 that?
6 MR. WHITE: Yes.
7 THE COURT: All right.
8 We are going to take a recess now.
9 You may step down.
10 Members of the jury, we will recess for lunch.
11 Please do not discuss the case either among yourselves or
12 anyone else. Keep an open mind. Come to no conclusions.
13 We will recess until 1:30.
14 Have a nice lunch.
15 (Whereupon, at this time the jury leaves the
16 courtroom.)
17 (Luncheon Recess.)
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
345
Gagliardi-redirect/White
1 A F T E R N O O N S E S S I O N
2
3 (Whereupon, the following takes place in the
4 absence of the jury.)
5 THE COURT: Which of the defendants are not
6 here?
7 MR. SCHOER: Everybody is in the building. I
8 will go look for them by the telephones.
9 THE COURT: We have been looking for them and
10 they are not around.
11 Bring the jury in.
12 Are the defendants themselves all present?
13 MR. SCHOER: Yes.
14 THE COURT: Which lawyers are not present.
15 THE DEFENDANT RUBIN: Mr. Dunn is with the
16 investigators.
17 THE COURT: Where is the Mr. Neville?
18 (Mr. Neville enters the courtroom.)
19 THE COURT: I guess I have not made an impression
20 at all.
21 (Whereupon, at this time there was a pause in the
22 proceedings.)
23 THE COURT: You say the other attorneys are in
24 the building?
25 MR. SCHOER: Yes.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
346
Gagliardi-redirect/White
1 THE COURT: Where are they?
2 MR. SCHOER: Upstairs using the phones probably.
3 THE CLERK: Jury entering.
4 (Whereupon, the jury at this time entered the
5 courtroom.)
6 THE COURT: Please be seated, members of the
7 jury.
8 (Whereupon Mr. Lee enters the courtroom.)
9 THE COURT: I neglected to tell you to bring your
10 notes in with you during the lunch hour also. Just put
11 them face down wherever you put them, face down on th e
12 table.
13 (Whereupon, at this time there was a pause in the
14 proceedings.)
15 THE COURT: Are we all here?
16 (Whereupon, at this time there was a pause in the
17 proceedings.)
18 THE COURT: So I hear rumors it is going to
19 snow.
20 ALTERNATE JUROR NO. 1: It is snowing.
21 THE COURT: It is snowing now?
22 JUROR NO. 4: Up to the third floor.
23 THE COURT: There is only one comedian here.
24 (Whereupon Mr. Dunn entered the courtroom.)
25 THE COURT: There is no snow.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
347
Gagliardi-redirect/White
1 JUROR NO. 8: Yes, there is.
2 THE COURT: There might have been. But right now
3 it is not snowing.
4 You may proceed.
5 MR. WHITE: Thank you, your Honor.
6
7 REDIRECT EXAMINATION (cont'd)
8 BY MR. WHITE:
9 Q Mr. Gaglia rdi, if you can turn back to the collateral
10 agreement, which is Exhibit 420-H. Do you have it before
11 you?
12 A Yes.
13 Q Look on the second page, the one speaking with
14 respect to closely held corporations that are directly or
15 indirectly controlled or owned by the taxpayer; do you
16 recall that?
17 A Yes.
18 Q In the event there is such a corporation that is
19 owned or controlled by the taxpayer, what does that mean
20 under this paragraph? What are the consequences of that?
21 A My understanding is that the taxpayer should become
22 involved in the company in the future, it would become, a
23 certain portion of the income would be relevant to the
24 collateral agreement.
25 Q A certain portion's of whose income?
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
348
Gagliardi-redirect/White
1 A The corpora tion's income.
2 Q Look at paragraph three and tell us what portion of
3 the corporation's income would be subject to the
4 agreement?
5 A In excess of $10,000.
6 Q So, any corporate income in excess of $10,000?
7 A Right.
8 Q Now, Mr. Trabulus asked you questions regarding
9 Mr. Gordon's position at the company; do you recall that?
10 A Yes.
11 Q And what was your understanding of whether or not
12 someone who was the president of a corporation, but still
13 an employee -- still just an employee, would control the
14 corporation within the meaning of this section?
15 A As to this section, unless there was some other
16 control demonstrated, that it wouldn't apply.
17 Q And why is that?
18 A You can be an officer of the corporation and not have
19 an ownership role.
20 Q And if someone were president but just an employee,
21 would h e have any right to the corporate annual income
22 over $10,000?
23 MR. TRABULUS: Objection, your Honor.
24 THE COURT: Sustained.
25 Q What is your understanding of whether or not an
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
349
Gagliardi-redirect/White
1 employee with no ownership interest would be able to
2 subject his corporation's income to this agreement?
3 MR. TRABULUS: Objection.
4 THE COURT: Sustained.
5 Q Mr. Gagliardi, tell us what you understood regarding
6 whether or not Mr. Gordon's position as president meant
7 that he controlled the corporation?
8 MR. TRABULUS: Objection, your Honor.
9 THE COURT: What do you mean by his
10 understanding, Mr. White? He either said it or he didn't
11 say it. He put it down or didn't put it down. Or he
12 never said anything about it. What do you mean by
13 understa nding?
14 MR. WHITE: What I meant is Mr. Gordon's 433
15 indicated he was the president. I want to find out if
16 Mr. Gagliardi interpreted that that therefore he came
17 under this section or he did not.
18 THE COURT: Sustained.
19 MR. WHITE: Okay.
20 Q Now, do you recall on cross-examination you were
21 asked whether or not you went to the bankruptcy court in
22 Westbury to review the files?
23 A Yes.
24 Q Did you do that?
25 A No, I did not.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
350
Gagliardi-redirect/White
1 Q Why not?
2 A The information as presented in the offer in
3 compromise indicated that Mr. Gordon was a contract
4 employee, and, therefore, I saw no necessity to obtain
5 additional information regarding his employer.
6 Q And if you look back one document on Exhibit 420-G,
7 that 's the compensation agreement, do you recall being
8 asked questions that this agreement makes it clear that
9 part of Mr. Gordon's compensation is based on the
10 performance of the company?
11 A Yes.
12 Q Do you recall being asked questions on whether or not
13 you obtained the corporate returns?
14 A I recall.
15 Q Did you obtain the corporate returns?
16 A I did not.
17 Q And why not?
18 A The specific reason, if this -- if Mr. Gordon were
19 simply an employee, there are disclosure problems with
20 obtaining information on his employer. It didn't apply.
21 I simply could not obtain that information.
22 Q Did you have any other source aside from the
23 corporate returns to learn of Mr. Gordon's compensation
24 and income?
25 A Other than the income reporting documents, no.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
351
Gagliardi-redirect/White
1 Q But you did have those 433's; is that correct?
2 A Correct.
3 MR. WHITE: At this time I would like to offer a
4 document that the parties have stipulated the
5 admissibility of.
6 THE COURT: Very well.
7 MR. WHITE: Exhibits 409-A, and the parties agree
8 that it is a business record of M. Reffsin & Company,
9 accounting firm.
10 THE COURT: 409-A for Abel?
11 MR. WHITE: Yes, and I have a copy for the Court
12 which I will hand directly to your Honor.
13 THE COURT: Government's Exhibit 409-A for Abel
14 in evidence.
15 (Government's Exhibit 409-A received in
16 evidence.)
17 Q If you can take a look at 409-A, have you ever seen
18 that before?
19 A Give me a chance?
20 Q Yes, please review it.
21 (Handed to the witness.)
22 MR. SCHOER: For the record, I didn't stipula te
23 against anything. I don't know if it is offered against
24 my client, I assume he is not. And he is speaking only of
25 certain defendants.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
352
Gagliardi-redirect/White
1 MR. JENKS: He is speaking of Mr. Wallenstein and
2 Mr. Gordon, I assume.
3 THE COURT: Who is it being offered against,
4 which defendant?
5 MR. WHITE: Messrs. Gordon and Reffsin.
6 THE COURT: Only?
7 MR. WHITE: Correct.
8 THE COURT: All right.
9 Members of the jury, that is important to
10 distinguish that. When a document is offered against a
11 particular defendant for a particular count, you can only
12 consider it for that purpose. Sometimes it is difficult
13 to separate it out. But we will try to help you as much
14 as possible. But it is obvious with these tax records it
15 has no thing to do with the other defendants in the case.
16 You may proceed.
17 Q Mr. Gagliardi, have you ever seen that before?
18 A No.
19 MR. WHITE: May I read the first paragraph of it,
20 your Honor?
21 THE COURT: Yes.
22 MR. WHITE: It is addressed Bruce Gordon -- back
23 up.
24 The letterhead, M. Reffsin & Company C.P.A.s, 100
25 Jericho Quadrangle, room 339, Jericho, New York 11753,
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
353
Gagliardi-redirect/White
1 516 822-2002, dated April 8th, 1992. It is addressed to
2 Bruce Gordon, 10 Bluff Road, Glen Cove, New York 11502.
3 Dear Bruce, enclosed is your 1991 federal individual
4 income tax return, the original should be signed on the
5 bottom of page 2. No tax is payable with the filing of
6 this return. You will receive a refund of $1,239. Mail
7 your federal return on or before April 15th, 1992, to the
8 Internal Revenue Service, Holtsville, New York. It
9 continues and I will not read it.
10 Q Mr. Gagliardi, if you can turn to the seventh and
11 eighth pages of that document.
12 Now, even if you didn't see this particular
13 document, did you see documents like this in connection
14 with the offer in compromise?
15 A Yes, I did.
16 Q And the ones you saw were for other years?
17 A To the best of my recollection, yes.
18 Q And tell us what this document is.
19 A It's a computation on the agreement with the
20 Department of Justice, the required payment on the future
21 income collateral agreement.
22 Q That was to be paid when the taxpayer filed his
23 return each year?
24 A Yes.
25 Q And is that the agreement that includes the
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
3 54
Gagliardi-redirect/White
1 potentially -- potentially includes the corporation's
2 income as well?
3 A Correct.
4 Q Turn to page 2 of that agreement -- I am sorry, of
5 that document, and read where it says note A.
6 A Note A says: Taxpayer owns 75 percent of a
7 corporation named Who's Who Worldwide Registry, Inc. EIN
8 11-3029837. The taxable year -- the taxable income of the
9 corporation is $12,707 for the calendar year 1991. The
10 federal corporation income taxes are $2,206, providing an
11 additional net income of $2,501, less 12,501 exemption, of
12 which 75 percent of $1,876 is -- what is that word?
13 MR. WHITE: Allocable.
14 A Allocable to Bruce Gordon. The corporation was on
15 extension until September 15th, 1992. Therefore, I was
16 unable to obtain the final taxable income of the
17 corporation to file this statement until now.
18 Q If you can go back to the front page of that
19 document, and just page through it -- I am sorry, the
20 front page of the return there, and page through it, and
21 see if there is any indication that it was received by the
22 Internal Revenue Service?
23 A There is no indication on this copy.
24 Q What is it your understanding as to whether or not
25 there is a stamping of received on tax returns that are
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
355
Gagliardi-redirect/White
1 filed?
2 A It is my understanding that any tax returns that are
3 received is marked received and given an identifying
4 number.
5 MR. WHITE: Your Honor, I would offer 409, a
6 certified copy of the 1991 personal tax return of
7 Mr. Gordon.
8 THE COURT: The same tax return?
9 MR. WHITE: No, your Honor. It is the one that
10 was filed, your Honor.
11 MR. TRABULUS: No objection, your Honor.
12 THE COURT: Government's Exhibit 409 in evidence.
13 What year is that for?
14 MR. WHITE: 1991 personal return.
15 (Government's Exhibit 409 received in evidence.)
16 Q Mr. Gagliardi, if you can put 409, the return filed,
17 and 409-A, the other document that didn't have a received
18 stamp on it, side by side, and compare the first page.
19 A They appear to be the same.
20 Q Does 409, the filed copy have any received stamp on
21 it?
22 A It has document locator number, and appears to be a
23 stamp in the corner.
24 Q It has a document locator number on it?
25 A Yes, the indication that it was received by the
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
356
Gagliardi-redirect/White
1 information.
2 Q Now, if you can turn the document to page 2. Do
3 those appear to be the same?
4 A The second copy is signed by Mr. Gordon. That's the
5 only difference that appears to me.
6 Q Which copy was signed by Mr. Gordon, the one filed?
7 A The filed return.
8 Q Okay.
9 Turn to the next page.
10 Is that a copy of his W-2?
11 A Yes.
12 Q On both documents?
13 A Yes.
14 Q Turn to the next page and compare them.
15 Now, on 409-A, what is the next page?
16 A On 409-A, it is wages, scheduled, Bruce Gordon, and
17 it is the same on 409.
18 Q Continue to the next page?
19 A There is no next page on 409.
20 Q That's the text of 409; is that right?
21 A Yes.
22 Q What is on 409-A that is not on 409?
23 A The copy from Mr. Reffsin had the statement of annual
24 income on the collateral agreement.
25 Q So, the filed copy does not have the document that
HA RRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
357
Gagliardi-redirect/White
1 says that Mr. Gordon owns 75 percent of the corporation?
2 A Correct.
3 Q But the copy that Mr. Reffsin sent to Mr. Gordon to
4 file does?
5 A Correct.
6 MR. WHITE: Your Honor, to be sure, 409 was
7 received in evidence.
8 THE COURT: Both 409 and 409-A were received in
9 evidence.
10 MR. WHITE: Thank you.
11 THE COURT: According to my unofficial record.
12 That's correct, Mr. Trabulus?
13 MR. TRABULUS: Yes, your Honor. We stipulated to
14 409-A and did not object to 409.
15 THE COURT: Thank you.
16 I am keeping an eye out for the snow. And you
17 tell me how I can do that out here. Now I will give you a
18 clue, and the clue is how I can explain what
19 circumstantial evidence is.
20 For example, if you see somebody walking in with
21 an umbrella shaking off the snow, now, you can't see the
22 snow, right? But you can reasonably infer that it was
23 snowing outside. But I am going to keep a lookout.
24 MR. WHITE: Your Honor, we will also offer 416
25 and 417, which are certified copies of Who's Who Worldwide
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
358
Gagliardi-redirect/White
1 corporate returns.
2 THE COURT: For what number is that?
3 MR. WHITE: 416 is Worldwide corporate return for
4 1991.
5 417 is Who's Who Worldwide corporate return for
6 1992.
7 THE COURT: Does counsel have copies?
8 MR. WHITE: Yes.
9 THE COURT: Any objection?
10 MR. TRABULUS: Bear with me for a moment. I am
11 looking through my copy of 417. We discussed 416.
12 THE COURT: Surely.
13 Now, you say a very, very distinguished lawyer
14 walking in, an d he doesn't have an umbrella.
15 JUROR NO. 4: He does.
16 THE COURT: He does.
17 Mr. Scaring, I was telling the jury something
18 about circumstantial evidence.
19 MR. SCARING: It is not wet, your Honor,
20 however.
21 THE COURT: It is not wet? All right.
22 MR. TRABULUS: No objection.
23 THE COURT: Government's Exhibit 416 and 417 in
24 evidence.
25 (Government's Exhibit 416 received in evidence.)
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
359
Gagliardi-redirect/White
1 (Government's Exhibit 417 received in evidence.)
2 Q Mr. Gagliardi, let me show you
3 Government's Exhibit 416, if I can look over your
4 shoulder.
5 If you can look at page 2, the compensation of
6 the corporation's officers are listed there; is that
7 right?
8 A Yes.
9 Q Does that indicate what percentage of the
10 corporation's stock, common stock, is owned by Mr. Gordon?
11 A Yes, it does.
12 Q What does it say?
13 A 75 percent.
14 Q And this is the 1991 return?
15 A Yes.
16 Q And when was it filed?
17 A June 26th, 1991, it appears -- 1992? 1992.
18 Q And if you look at the 1992 return, page 2, schedule
19 E, again it lists compensation of officers?
20 A Yes, it does.
21 Q Does it give a figure for the percentage of the
22 common stock that Mr. Gordon owns?
23 A 100 percent.
24 Q No.
25 A I am sorry, 100 percent -- zero percent.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
360
Gagliardi-redirect/White
1 Q Let me ask the question again for clarification.
2 Does it indicate the percentage of the
3 corporation's common stock that Mr. Gordon owns?
4 A Yes, it does.
5 Q And what is it?
6 A Zero percent.
7 Q Does it indicate that anyone else owns common stock
8 in the company?
9 A Yes, it does.
10 Q Who?
11 A Richard Grossman.
12 Q How much does it indicate that Richard Grossman owns?
13 A Twenty percent.
14 THE COURT: Which return is that?
15 MR. WHITE: The '92 corporate return.
16 Q Mr. Gagliardi, would you look at Exhibit 423-H.
17 Do you see that, Mr. Gagliardi?
18 A Yes.
19 Q And 423-H is the bank statement that contains $15,000
20 worth of deposits to Mr. Gordon's account; is that right?
21 A That's right.
22 Q And those are in August of 1993?
23 A That's right.
24 Q Can you refresh our recollection as to what
25 Mr. Reffsin told you regarding the purpose of those
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
361
Gagliardi-redirect/White
1 transfers?
2 A He indicated that they were loans from a third party.
3 Q And are those the ones for the son's funeral
4 expenses?
5 A I believe so.
6 Q And who did he indicate the money was coming from?
7 A There were two notes. One was Joyce Grossman and the
8 other was Marilyn Middlemark. I don't have it clear in my
9 mind which was which.
10 Q Okay.
11 If you take a look at 425-A --
12 A Do me a favor.
13 (Counsel approaches the witness stand.)
14 Q You see it now?
15 A Yes.
16 Q And the 15,000 in July of 1993 was from who?
17 MR. TRABULUS: Objection, your Honor.
18 THE COURT: On what grounds?
19 MR. TRABULUS: I think he answered that. When he
20 says from who, he has already answered it. Is he asking
21 for independent knowledge?
22 MR. WHITE: I will rephrase it.
23 MR. TRABULUS: It is repetitive.
24 THE COURT: A lot of it has been repetitive, but
25 you have not objected.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
362
Gagliardi-redirect/White
1 MR. TRABULUS: I will object now.
2 THE COURT: Sustained.
3 MR. WHITE: Your Honor, I have offered
4 Government's Exhibit 764 and 765, where we have reached a
5 stipulation with Mr. Trabulus and Mr. Wallenstein, are
6 corporate records of Who's Who Worldwide Registry.
7 THE COURT: Any objection?
8 MR. TRABULUS: It is not quite the objection.
9 We -- not quite the stipulation. We will stipulate it to
10 being admitted as corporate records of National
11 Westminster Bank in the possession of Who's Who, and they
12 can come in.
13 THE COURT: Is that correct, Mr. Wallenstein?
14 MR. WALLENSTEIN: Yes, and I have no objection.
15 MR. JENKS: Judge, since I represent the
16 corporation, I didn't sti pulate to that. However, I
17 assume it is not being offered against the corporation?
18 MR. WHITE: Correct.
19 MR. JENKS: I have no objection.
20 THE COURT: Government's Exhibit 764 and 765, in
21 evidence.
22 (Government's Exhibit 764 received in evidence.)
23 (Government's Exhibit 765 received in evidence.)
24 Q Would you get out 423-H, the bank statements.
25 A Yes.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
363
Gagliardi-redirect/White
1 MR. WHITE: Your Honor, if I can reach from a
2 portion of 764 and 765. It says debit advice. Both of
3 them say debit advice to, there is a box at the bottom, to
4 Who's Who Worldwide Registry, Inc.
5 Under the description box, it says transferred to
6 7-021-76975-7, parens, authorization letter to follow.
7 That's on 765.
8 764 reads in the description box, transferred to
9 7-021-76975-7, parens, letter to follow, close parens.
10 Q Mr. Gagliardi, where it says transferred to, can you
11 compare that number to the account number of Mr. Gordon's
12 personal account on 423-H?
13 A They are identical.
14 Q And that debit advice was debiting the account of
15 who? What does it say in the "to" box at the bottom?
16 A To Who's Who Worldwide Registry, Inc.
17 MR. WHITE: Your Honor, no further questions.
18
19 RECROSS-EXAMINATION
20 BY MR. TRABULUS:
21 Q Mr. Gagliardi, you have not examined any bank
22 statements or records of Who's Who Worldwide Registry,
23 Inc., is that correct?
24 A No, sir.
25 Q And you have no way of knowing as to whether any
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
364
Gagliardi-recross/Trabulus
1 money came into their account and then went out to
2 Mr. Gordon's account, would you?
3 A No.
4 Q Now, you testified in respect to Exhibits 409 and
5 409-A, and I think you were asked a question by Mr. White
6 in which 409-A was described as the copy received by
7 Mr. Gordon; is that correct?
8 A Correct.
9 Q You don't know if that copy was received by
10 Mr. Gordon?
11 A I have no knowledge of it.
12 Q Is it your testimony that 409 and 409-A is identical
13 except for the fact that the pages are missing -- the
14 schedules are missing from 409?
15 A That's what it appears.
16 Q Would you take a look at the second page of 409-A --
17 excuse me, it would be the fourth page, but the second
18 page of the 1040, that being the one that the IRS
19 indicates was actually filed. Take your time.
20 Now, these pages are both the second page of a
21 form 1040; is that correct?
22 A Yes.
23 Q And both of these documents have on them a signature
24 where it says, prepare a signature -- preparer's
25 signature; is that correct?
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
365
Gagliardi-recross/Trabulus
1 A Yes.
2 Q Both those signatures appear to be in the same
3 handwriting, do they not?
4 A Yes.
5 Q And they are different signatures, are they not?
6 They are not copies of one another?
7 A It appears to me that the signature on 409-A is
8 darker and not dated.
9 Q Not only is it darker, but the lines are different,
10 correct? It is the same handwriting, but at a different
11 time that the person signed the document; does it appear
12 that way?
13 A They appear to be different.
14 MR. TRABULUS: Your Honor, I frankly don't
15 recall, but were copies of 409 and 409-A published to the
16 jury?
17 THE COURT: I don't believe so.
18 MR. TRABULUS: I don't believe so either.
19 I would request that copies be published to the
20 jury.
21 THE COURT: Go ahead.
22 MR. TRABULUS: Judge, I don't have multiple
23 copies, but I would ask that copies of the exhibit be
24 given to the jury and they can look at it.
25 THE COURT: Certainly. But we will continue as
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
366
Gagliardi-recross/Trabulus
1 they look. We will continue to work.
2 MR. TRABULUS: Certainly.
3 (Whereupon, the exhibit/exhibits were published
4 to the jury.)
5 Q This would indicate to you, would it not, that the
6 person who signed the name under the tax preparer actually
7 signed twice; is that correct?
8 A Correct.
9 Q You don't know if they were signed at the same time?
10 A I hav e no idea.
11 Q But all we know is that the copy which evidently was
12 submitted by Mr. Gordon was not the same -- did not bear
13 the same signature, although it appears the same -- to be
14 the same person, although it came from Mr. Reffsin's
15 company's file; is that correct?
16 A That's correct.
17 Q Now, you indicated earlier that there was no need to
18 check the bankruptcy file records, because the information
19 you had given to you in connection with the offer in
20 compromise was sufficient; is that correct?
21 A I found no reason to examine the bankruptcy records,
22 no.
23 Q But you did examine property tax -- excuse me,
24 property records in Nassau County, to see whether or not
25 Mr. Gordon opened any property; is that correct?
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
367
Gagliardi-recross/Trabulus
1 A Correct.
2 Q So, you did not regard the information given to you
3 as sufficient for that purpose; is that correct?
4 A That's correct.
5 Q And you searched other records as well; is that
6 correct?
7 A Correct.
8 Q And you had specific reason to believe, did you, that
9 he owned any property before checking the property
10 records; is that correct?
11 A I made only the routine searches that were required
12 to make.
13 Q But, you did have in the compensation agreement,
14 reason to believe that the income he was entitled to
15 receive would be based on the cash flow that the
16 corporation would have; is that correct?
17 A Yes, that's correct.
18 Q And you understood, did you not, that documents to be
19 contained within the bankruptcy filing might reflect upon
20 the cash flow of the corporation which had filed for
21 bankruptcy, did you not?
22 A They would contain such information.
23 Q Now, I think you were questioned by Mr. White about
24 Exhibit 404. And that is probably right in front of you
25 there. And that is an earlier collection information
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
368
Gagliardi-recross/Trabulus
1 statement.
2 A 404?
3 Q Yes. It is on the chart. I don't know if you looked
4 at the chart itself. I don't believe you were shown the
5 chart. Can you see it if it is over here?
6 A I believe so.
7 Q Now, this was not a collection information statement
8 which you had actually reviewed during the course of what
9 you did; is that correct?
10 A Correct.
11 Q You only saw that for the first time today or in the
12 last few days; is that right?
13 A I have seen this document upon reviewing the
14 information . That's fine.
15 Q Is it fair to say, Mr. Gagliardi, that insofar as you
16 say that you assumed that the charge accounts referred to
17 on the later collection information statements, related to
18 past charges, you certainly did not in making that
19 determination rely on this document, did you?
20 A No. I didn't have that document, no.
21 Q And the later documents talk about charge accounts;
22 is that right?
23 A Yes.
24 Q And there is no mention of the ex-wife on the later
25 documents, is there?
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
369
Gagliardi-recross/Trabulus
1 A Only for alimony payments.
2 Q But not in connection with the charge accounts?
3 A That's right.
4 Q Plural, right?
5 A Yes.
6 Q Is it this doesn't say charge accounts, but it says
7 shopper charge and ex-wife charges; is that c orrect?
8 A Correct.
9 Q Now, Mr. White in questioning you pointed out that
10 409 as filed did not contain a document in 409-A; is that
11 correct?
12 A Yes.
13 Q And that document referred to a 75 percent share
14 ownership on the part of Mr. Gordon; is that correct?
15 A Yes.
16 Q And 409 -- excuse me.
17 416 is the corporate tax return; is that correct,
18 for Who's Who Worldwide Registry, Inc.?
19 A Yes.
20 Q And that was signed by Mr. Gordon, was it not?
21 A Yes.
22 Q And that document did indicate 75 percent ownership,
23 did it not?
24 A Yes.
25 Q And that document was filed slightly more than two
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
370
Gagliardi-recross/Trabulus
1 months after the one that doesn't have that; is that
2 correct?
3 A This document is filed 6/22/9 2.
4 Q The other one was 4/13/92?
5 A I don't remember.
6 THE COURT: Mr. White, or Mr. Trabulus, do you
7 want to move those two exhibits to the other jurors?
8 MR. TRABULUS: Certainly, certainly.
9 Q I am going to hand you 409.
10 Can you tell us, please, when 409 was filed?
11 (Handed to the witness.)
12 A Let's see, it is dated 4/13/92.
13 Q Does it bear the stamp on it indicating it was filed?
14 A I don't see the stamp, but the document locator
15 number would indicate the date it was filed.
16 Q May 8th, 1992.
17 A The 130th day of the year, whatever it was.
18 Q When you testified earlier that whenever a return is
19 filed, it is stamped?
20 A That's my understanding. That's our practice.
21 Q And what happened here, since it wasn't stamped, this
22 would have been a deviation from that practice?
23 A I imagine so.
2 4 Q Now, I just want to see if I understand you
25 correctly.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
371
Gagliardi-recross/Trabulus
1 Returns are customarily stamped when filed; is
2 that your testimony?
3 A Yes.
4 Q And collection information isn't?
5 A No.
6 Q They are not?
7 A They are not.
8 Q And this particular return, apparently, was not
9 stamped?
10 A If it was stamped it was obliterated. There is some
11 stamp in the corner, that you can't really make out.
12 Q Let's turn now to 417, which Mr. White showed you.
13 That's the return for Who's Who Worldwide
14 Registry, Inc. for the following year. We have been
15 talking about the 1991 returns. Now we are switching to
16 1992; is that correct?
17 A Yes.
18 Q And that return was filed without Mr. Gordon's
19 signature on it ; is that correct?
20 A It appears so.
21 Q And it was then -- look through the document, and it
22 was then returned for this signature?
23 Withdrawn.
24 Isn't it correct that after that a form was sent
25 to Mr. Gordon to sign?
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
372
Gagliardi-recross/Trabulus
1 A It was the general practice, and I will tell you in a
2 moment.
3 Yes, that's the case.
4 Q That form is included in the exhibit?
5 A Yes.
6 Q Do you know when that form is sent, as to whether it
7 is the practice of the information to actually physically
8 return the return to the person so they can look at it
9 again?
10 A I don't know.
11 Q You don't know the answer?
12 A I don't know.
13 Q So, it is possible that the return was returned
14 without the return and then it was signe d and returned to
15 the IRS?
16 A An educated guess is they would just send a letter.
17 MR. TRABULUS: No further questions.
18 THE COURT: Anything else? Mr. Wallenstein?
19
20 RECROSS-EXAMINATION
21 BY MR. WALLENSTEIN:
22 Q Mr. Gagliardi, the statement attached to 409-A, the
23 statement indicating that Mr. Gordon has a 75 percent
24 ownership, that's not a statement that is required to be
25 filed with a 1040, is it?
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
373
Gagliardi-recross/Wallenstein
1 A No.
2 Q And is it your understanding, however, that this
3 document would be required to be filed, however, with the
4 Department of Justice in connection with the collateral
5 agreement?
6 A Yes.
7 Q Along with a copy of the 1040?
8 A Yes.
9 Q And the official filed version of Mr. Gordon's 1040
10 for that year would not need to contain that particular
11 statement in any form?
12 A No, it wouldn't.
13 MR. WALLENSTEIN: Thank you. I have no further
14 questions.
15 THE COURT: Anything else?
16 MR. WHITE: Yes, one brief area, your Honor.
17
18 FURTHER REDIRECT EXAMINATION
19 BY MR. WHITE:
20 Q Mr. Gagliardi, you said -- isn't it correct that
21 every return that is filed gets a document locator number?
22 A Yes.
23 Q And the issue of whether or not it gets a date -- a
24 return gets a date stamp, does whether or not a return is
25 timely filed play into that?
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
374
Gagliardi-redirect/White
1 A I can only speak to my practice. When we receive a
2 return we date stamp it. We realize that thousands
3 returns are filed with the center, it is po ssible a date
4 stamp did not get on to one.
5 MR. WHITE: Nothing else.
6 THE COURT: Anything else?
7 MR. TRABULUS: Nothing further, your Honor.
8 MR. WALLENSTEIN: Nothing further.
9 THE COURT: You may step down.
10 (Whereupon, at this time the witness left the
11 witness stand.)
12 THE COURT: Please call your next witness.
13 MS. SCOTT: Your Honor, the government calls
14 Edmond Garabedian.
15 THE COURT: Ms. Scott, have a seat. Please.
16 MS. SCOTT: Yes.
17 THE COURT: Raise your right hand.
18
19 E D M O N D G A R A B E D I A N ,
20 called as a witness, having been first
21 duly sworn, was examined and testified
22 as follows:
23
24 THE COURT: Please be seated.
25 State your full name and spell your name.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
375
1 THE WITNESS: Edmond Garabedian, E D M O N D,
2 G A R A B E D I A N.
3 THE COURT: You may proceed.
4
5 DIRECT EXAMINATION
6 BY MS. SCOTT:
7 Q Good afternoon.
8 A Good afternoon.
9 Q What did you do for a living?
10 A Employed by the American Express Company.
11 Q What is your duties there?
12 A The records custodian for American Express.
13 Q How long have you been the records custodian?
14 A The last six years.
15 Q What are your responsibilities as the record
16 custodian for American Express?
17 A I head the subpoena compliance department. I also
18 head and oversee the production of American Expresses
19 records. And I testify whenever it is necessary in
20 different venues.
21 MS. SCOTT: Your Honor, may I have a minute? We
22 are still seeking exhibits.
23 THE COURT: Surely.
24 (Whereupon, at this time th ere was a pause in the
25 proceedings.)
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
376
Garabedian-direct/Scott
1 Q I am showing Government's Exhibits 430 through 482.
2 Do you recognize those?
3 A Yes, ma'am, I do.
4 Q What are they?
5 A These are copies of the American Express monthly
6 statements for an American Express charge card in the name
7 of Elizabeth Sautter, S A U T T E R.
8 THE COURT: In the name of Elizabeth --
9 THE WITNESS: Sautter, S A U T T E R.
10 Q How do you recognize them?
11 A Through my daily work I reproduce these types of
12 documents based on the American Express records.
13 Q How is American Express notified when a customer
14 makes a purchase or a charge to their American Express
15 card?
16 A American Express normally is provided with electronic
17 information from the month of purchase by the merchant
18 processing the American Express card through an electronic
19 reader. Then the information regarding the purchase is
20 submitted to American Express and captured electronically.
21 Q And what happens to that information from there?
22 A American Express then pays the merchant pursuit to
23 the submission of a particular charge, and holds that
24 information until the next monthly statement is due. They
25 create a monthly statement for the card holder, and
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
377
Garabedian-direct/Scott
1 include that information as part of the purchase with
2 regard to that statement.
3 Q Are these statements kept in the course of regularly
4 conducted business activity of American Express?
5 A Yes.
6 Q Was it the regular business practice of American
7 Express to keep thes e records?
8 A Absolutely.
9 Q Had these records been under your supervision and
10 control?
11 A Yes.
12 MS. SCOTT: I offer Government's Exhibits 430
13 through 482 in evidence.
14 THE COURT: Any objection?
15 MR. TRABULUS: No.
16 THE COURT: Government's Exhibits 430 through 482
17 in evidence.
18 (Government's Exhibits 430 through 482 received
19 in evidence.)
20 Q Now, Mr. Garabedian, looking through those exhibits,
21 what do they say about the number of card holders on that
22 account?
23 THE COURT: Number of what?
24 MS. SCOTT: Card holders.
25 A This account had two card holders, the basic card
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
378
Garabedian-direct/Scott
1 holder is Elizabeth Sautter, and the supplemental card
2 holder was Bruce W. Gordon.
3 Q What is a supple mental card holder?
4 A A secondary individual who is given a card with
5 the -- under the same account. The supplemental card
6 holder's account only differs in the last four digits of
7 the account to actually note it as a supplemental under
8 that account number.
9 Q How do you know from looking at the statements that
10 the primary card holder is Elizabeth Sautter and the
11 secondary as Bruce Gordon?
12 A The primary card holder is the individual who would
13 receive the statements for the account and who is
14 responsible for the statements.
15 Elizabeth Sautter's name is on the top of each
16 statement, along with the address where the statements are
17 mailed. And in the particular Exhibit number 430, which
18 is a statement with a closing date of November 1990, there
19 is an indication of an annual membership fee for the
20 supplemental card member of Mr. Bruce Gordon.
21 Q How do the statements show which charges were made on
22 Elizabeth Sautter's card, and which charges were made on
23 Bruce Gordon's card?
24 A The statements are always created with Elizabeth
25 Sautter's charges being listed first. After all the
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
379
Garabedian-direct/Scott
1 charges for the basic card holder are listed, they are
2 subtotaled. And a total for card 100, which is the
3 designation for the basic card holder's account, is
4 listed. Subsequent to that all the supplemental card
5 member's charges are listed below it. They are subtotaled
6 and listed as total for card 101.
7 Q I am showing you Government's Exhibit 824-A,
8 Mr. Garabedian.
9 A Yes.
10 Q Do you recognize that document?
11 A Yes.
12 Q Did you have an opportunity to exami ne that document
13 before you came in to testify?
14 A I did.
15 Q Did you have an opportunity to compare it with the
16 information contained in those American Express statements
17 that you have in front of you?
18 A Yes.
19 Q And does this chart accurately represent the
20 information contains in the American Express statements?
21 A Absolutely.
22 MS. SCOTT: I offer Government's Exhibit 824-A.
23 MR. TRABULUS: Objection.
24 THE COURT: What ground?
25 MR. TRABULUS: If you look at the top it contains
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
380
Garabedian-direct/Scott
1 a designation inaccurate and inconsistent with the
2 testimony that was given, the very first line. It
3 designates the account as being something other than it
4 was.
5 THE COURT: It was an Elizabeth Sautter account?
6 MR. TRABULUS: That's correct.
7 THE COURT: This says Bruce Gordon?
8 MR. TRABULUS: Yes.
9 THE COURT: Other than that?
10 MR. TRABULUS: I have no objection other than
11 that. The top part is misleading.
12 THE COURT: You will remove that name and put the
13 name of the primary card holder, which is Elizabeth
14 Sautter, S A U T T E R.
15 Let's do that.
16 MS. SCOTT: I would like to ask an additional
17 question of the witness.
18 THE COURT: Sure.
19 Q Can you identify which cards you examined when you
20 compared this chart with the documents in front of you,
21 before you?
22 A The charges which were made by Bruce Gordon, and on
23 the supplemental card were the only charges that were
24 listed on this chart.
25 So, my comparison were of all charges made by the
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
3 81
Garabedian-direct/Scott
1 supplemental card member within the individual statements
2 against the chart.
3 Q And in your calculations did you include any of the
4 charges made on Elizabeth Sautter's card?
5 A No.
6 MS. SCOTT: I offer the exhibit on that basis.
7 THE COURT: We have to put a little caret between
8 Gordon and American, supplemental. Is that what it is
9 called?
10 THE WITNESS: Yes.
11 THE COURT: Supplementary or supplemental?
12 THE WITNESS: Supplemental.
13 MR. TRABULUS: Your Honor, what it should say is
14 charges made on the card issued to the name of Bruce
15 Gordon on the Liz Sautter card. That's what he testified
16 to.
17 THE COURT: This is a summary from the evidence;
18 is that correct?
19 THE WITNESS: Yes.
20 THE COURT: You have taken the document,
21 information from what is in evidence, of the Bruce Gordon
22 charges?
23 THE WITNESS: That's correct.
24 THE COURT: You have not taken the Elizabeth
25 Sautter's cards?
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
382
Garabedian-direct/Scott
1 THE WITNESS: That's correct.
2 THE COURT: We will put down Bruce Gordon
3 supplemental or supplementary --
4 MS. SCOTT: All right.
5 THE COURT: Do you have a magic marker?
6 MR. WHITE: I will get one.
7 THE COURT: You mean you have all these charts
8 and records and not a magic marker?
9 (Whereupon, at this time there was a pause in the
10 proceedings.)
11 MS. SCOTT: With the Court's permission I would
12 like to publish this chart to the jury.
13 THE COURT: I have not allowed it in evidence
14 yet, show it to counsel if he likes what you have there.
15 MR. TRABULUS: Fine.
16 THE COUR T: All right, Government's Exhibit 824-A
17 in evidence.
18 (Government's Exhibit 824-A received in
19 evidence.)
20 MS. SCOTT: With the Court's permission I would
21 like to offer this chart.
22 THE COURT: Sure.
23 (Whereupon, the exhibit/exhibits were published
24 to the jury.)
25 THE COURT: Can everybody see the charts? If you
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
383
Garabedian-direct/Scott
1 can't see it, let me know.
2 We can put it in the front so you can see it.
3 I will tell you what to do, move the easel right
4 in front of the jury. Don't worry about me. Just move it
5 so it faces the jury. If I want to see it, I will take a
6 walk over.
7 Is that better?
8 A JUROR: Yes.
9 THE COURT: Now we can see it. And I will take a
10 look myself.
11 You may proceed.
12 Q Now, Mr. Garabedian, if you wouldn't mind stepping
13 down next to the exhibit.
14 Could you please tell the jury the total amount
15 that was charged to Bruce Gordon's supplemental American
16 Express card for the year 1991.
17 A For the year of 1991, the total amount charged on
18 Bruce Gordon's supplemental account was $30,267.11.
19 Q What about the year 1992?
20 A That total was $46,051.84.
21 Q And for 1993?
22 A That was $116,503.61 in total.
23 Q And for 1994?
24 A $183,032.67.
25 Q 1995?
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
384
Garabedian-direct/Scott
1 A The 1995 total was $34,320.07.
2 Q Please tell the jury the total amount charged to
3 Bruce Gordon's supplemental American Express card for the
4 entire period, 1991 through 1995.
5 A All the way -- the total starting with November of
6 1990 through March of 1995 is a grand total of
7 $411,853.29.
8 Q Thank you, Mr. Garabedian. You can take the seat
9 again.
10 I will ask you to look at one of the statements
11 in front of you, Government's Exhibit 449.
12 THE COURT: Is this for identification or is it
13 in evidence?
14 MS. SCOTT: It is in evidence.
15 A Yes.
16 Q Could you give the date on that document?
17 A Exhibit number 449 is a copy of the monthly statement
18 with a closing date of June 19th, 1992.
19 Q Looking at item 16, can you tell the jury what that
20 says.
21 A Item 16 is a charge at Chanel.
22 THE COURT: C H A N E L?
23 THE WITNESS: That's correct.
24 THE COURT: The famous perfume, Chanel number 9?
25 THE WITNESS: Yes, Chanel Boutique, a store in
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
385
Garabedian-dir ect/Scott
1 Palm Beach, Florida. It is a charge for $5,183.40.
2 Q What is the date of the charge?
3 A May 23rd, 1992.
4 Q And, by the way, which card is that charged made to?
5 A It is made to the supplemental card of Bruce Gordon
6 Dan.
7 Q Now, item 24, is that also to the supplemental card?
8 A Yes.
9 Q What does that read?
10 A It is a charge at Ann Klein in Manhasset, New York in
11 the amount of $2,071.27.
12 Q And what is the date on that charge?
13 A The charge is dated May 31st, 1992.
14 Q I am not sure if you read the date on the Chanel
15 charge, I will ask you to repeat that.
16 A I did, it was May 23rd, 1992.
17 Q And turning now to Government's Exhibit 453 in
18 evidence.
19 A Yes.
20 Q Item number 17 which charge is that charged to?
21 A That is the first charge charged to the supplemental
22 c ard of Bruce Gordon for this particular month. And this
23 is a charge at polo Ralph Lauren, East Hampton, New York.
24 And it is a charge for $1,003.72, dated September 20th,
25 1992.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
386
Garabedian-direct/Scott
1 Q Look at Government's Exhibit 454 in evidence.
2 A Yes.
3 Q Item 21, what card was that charged to?
4 A It was charged to the card of Bruce Gordon, the
5 supplemental account, and it is a charge at Ann Klein at
6 Manhasset, New York. It is a charge in the amount of
7 $1,111.04. And it is dated November 1st, 1992.
8 Q Now, looking at Government's Exhibit 469 in evidence?
9 A 469.
10 Q Item 14, can you tell us which card that item was
11 charged to?
12 A That was the first charge billed to the supplemental
13 card of Mr. Gordon, and it is a charge at the Royal Palm
14 Gallery in Palm Beach, Florida. The charge is dated
15 January 27th, of 1994. And it is in the amount of $11,400
16 even.
17 Q And finally, Government's Exhibit 472 in evidence.
18 A 472.
19 Q I ask you to look at items 14 and 19 and tell us
20 which card that is charged to and what they are.
21 A Both those charges were made to the supplemental
22 card.
23 Item number 14 is a charge at the Hoya Crystal
24 Gallery in New York. It is dated April 27th, 1994, and it
25 is in the amount of $2,695.96. And item number 19 is a
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
387
Garabedian-direct/Scott
1 charge, a telephone order charge from Orrefors,
2 O R R E F O R S, in New York, and it is dated May 2nd,
3 1994, and it is in the amount of $9,423.16.
4 Q I am showing you Government's Exhibit 404A and 404-B
5 in evidence, a nd ask you to take a look at item number 63
6 on this document.
7 Is that a date?
8 A That is a -- item number 63 is a for a date, yes.
9 Q What is the date given there?
10 A September 16th, 1991.
11 Q And just above that in item number 58, do you see a
12 number given in that box?
13 A Yes.
14 Q And --
15 A It appears to be 175.
16 MR. TRABULUS: Objection, your Honor. It is
17 repetitive of testimony elicited from another witness yes,
18 sir, from the same document.
19 THE COURT: 404-A and B?
20 MR. TRABULUS: A is the blowup of 404.
21 THE COURT: Yes.
22 MS. SCOTT: Your Honor, I am moving on.
23 THE COURT: Very well.
24 Q Now, Mr. Garabedian, I would just ask you to take a
25 look at Government's Exhibit 441 in evidence.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
388
Garabedian-direct/Scot t
1 A Yes.
2 Q And I am showing you Government's Exhibit 441-A.
3 Is that a true and accurate enlargement of the
4 exhibit you have before you, 441?
5 A Yes.
6 MR. WHITE: I offer Government's Exhibit 441-A.
7 THE COURT: Any objection?
8 MR. TRABULUS: It is just an enlargement of 441,
9 no. No knob.
10 THE COURT: Government's Exhibit 441-A in
11 evidence.
12 (Government's Exhibit 441-A received in
13 evidence.)
14 MS. SCOTT: Now I ask the Court's permission to
15 publish it for the jury?
16 THE COURT: Surely.
17 (Whereupon, the exhibit/exhibits were published
18 to the jury.)
19 Q Now, Mr. Garabedian, I would ask you to step down and
20 stand next to the exhibit, please.
21 Now, directing your attention to items number 28,
22 29, 30, 31.
23 Can you tell the jury what you see there.
24 A Item n umber 28 is a charge at Mansouri,
25 M A N S O U R I, men's wear in Greenvale, New York. A
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
389
Garabedian-direct/Scott
1 charge dated September 21st, 1991, in the amount of
2 $2,000.
3 Item number 29 is a charge at Thos Miller,
4 T H O S, Miller Town in Woodbury, New York. And that's a
5 charge dated September 21st, 1991, for $254.97.
6 Item number 31 is another charge at the same
7 merchant, Thos Miller in Woodbury, New York, on the same
8 date of September 21st, 1991, $238.70.
9 Q I believe you skipped item 30.
10 A Correct, I apologize.
11 Item 30 is also a charge at Thos Miller, Town and
12 Country in Woodbury, New York, again on September 21st,
13 1991, for a charge in the amount of $500 even.
14 Q And the dates given for all those charges are
15 September 21st, 1991; is th at correct?
16 A Yes.
17 Q What is the approximate time period between the dates
18 on this document and the dates on those charges?
19 A Five days.
20 Q By this document I mean 404-B.
21 A Yes. Five days.
22 Q Now, Mr. Garabedian, I am showing you more documents
23 in evidence, 405-A and 405-B. This is 405-A, and this is
24 405-B.
25 MR. TRABULUS: Objection, your Honor, the same
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
390
Garabedian-direct/Scott
1 thing, the contents of these documents were the subject of
2 other witnesses yesterday. It is repetitive.
3 MS. SCOTT: Your Honor, it is being offered for
4 comparison purposes with new evidence offered at this
5 time.
6 THE COURT: Overruled.
7 Q Mr. Garabedian, looking at item New Jersey 58, on
8 405-B, can you read that date?
9 A July 8th, 1993.
10 Q And just above that in item number 51, can you read a
11 number that is given there.
12 A 70.
13 Q Now, looking again at the summary chart, can you read
14 the amount of the charges charged to the supplemental card
15 in July of 1993?
16 A The July 1993 amount totals $8,110.50.
17 Q Did you have an opportunity to examine the amounts
18 given in that chart in the month of 1993 for the months
19 preceding July?
20 A Yes.
21 Q Did you have an opportunity to take the average of
22 those charges?
23 A Yes, I did.
24 Q And what was that average amount?
25 A It is approximately $10,000 over the prior six
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
391
Garabedian-direct/Scott
1 months.
2 Q Finally I am showing you Government's Exhibit 406-A
3 and 406-B in evidence.
4 A Yes.
5 Q A nd ask you to read item 68 on 406-B to the jury.
6 A Item number 68?
7 Q I believe that's the date.
8 A It is actually 56.
9 Q I am sorry, 56.
10 A 56 is date of December 29th, 1993.
11 Q And just above that in box 51, and the two boxes
12 below it, can you read to the jury the amounts given
13 there?
14 A 200 and 1,000.
15 Q Finally, Mr. Garabedian, I am turning your attention
16 to Government's Exhibit 467 in evidence.
17 A 467.
18 Q I am showing you 467-A.
19 Now, is this a true and accurate enlargement of
20 Government's Exhibit 467?
21 A Yes.
22 MS. SCOTT: I offer 467-A.
23 MR. TRABULUS: No objection.
24 THE COURT: 467-A, Government's Exhibit in
25 evidence.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
392
Garabedian-direct/Scott
1 (Government's Exhibit 467-A received in
2 evidence.)
3 MS. SCOTT: I request to publish it to the jury.
4 THE COURT: Yes.
5 (Whereupon, the exhibit/exhibits were published
6 to the jury.)
7 Q Looking at the document before you,
8 Government's Exhibit 467-, can you take a look at item
9 25.
10 A Yes.
11 Q What card is that item charged to?
12 A The supplement card, Mr. Gordon.
13 Q What is it?
14 A It is a charge at Wallach and Sons in Manhasset, New
15 York. It is dated November 20th, 1993. It is a charge in
16 the amount of $4,588.66.
17 Q Item number 27. Can you tell us what that is?
18 A It is a charge at Daum, D A U M, Boutique in New
19 York, dated December 4th, 1993. And it is a charge for
20 $2,004.05.
21 Q And item number 28.
22 A Item number 28 is a charge at the Sharper Image in
23 New York, dated December 5th, 1993, in the amount of
24 $ 5,576.64.
25 Q Finally, item number 30.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
393
Garabedian-direct/Scott
1 A Item number 30 is a charge at Barney's New York on
2 December 4th, 1993, in the amount of $1,388.77.
3 Q Now, I will ask you again to compare the dates on
4 these documents, 406-B, which you said had a date of
5 December 29th, 1993?
6 A Yes.
7 Q And approximately how far away in time is that from
8 the charges on these other documents, 467-A?
9 A Approximately three weeks.
10 Q Mr. Garabedian, looking at Government's Exhibit 467,
11 can you tell the jury what the total amounts of charges
12 were to Bruce Gordon's supplicate card between November
13 and December 1993?
14 A $14,051.17.
15 Q Now, I am going to ask you to look at
16 Government's Exhibit 471; and I am showing you
17 Government's Exhibit 471-A. Is that a true and accurate
18 enlargement of 471?
19 A Yes.
20 MS. SCOTT: I offer 471-A.
21 MR. TRABULUS: No objection.
22 THE COURT: Government's Exhibit 471-A, for Abel
23 in evidence.
24 MS. SCOTT: I am publishing that for the jury?
25 THE COURT: Yes.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
394
Garabedian-direct/Scott
1 (Whereupon, the exhibit/exhibits were published
2 to the jury.).
3 Q Please tell us what you see there for item 20.
4 A Item number 20 is a charge at Bergdorf Goodman in New
5 York, dated April 2nd, 1994. It is in the amount of $780.
6 Q Item 21?
7 A Another charge at Bergdorf Goodman on the same date
8 of April 2nd, 1994, in the amount of $146.14.
9 Q What is the dates given for those purchases?
10 A April 2nd, 1994.
11 Q Are those charges made to the sup plemental cards of
12 Bruce Gordon?
13 A Yes.
14 Q I am asking you to look at Government's Exhibit 474.
15 A Yes.
16 Q And I will show you 474-A.
17 Is this a true and accurate enlargement of
18 Government's Exhibit 474?
19 A Yes, it is.
20 Q I am offering Government's Exhibit 474-A.
21 MR. TRABULUS: No objection.
22 THE COURT: Government's Exhibit 474-A in
23 evidence.
24 (Government's Exhibit 474-A received in
25 evidence.)
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
395
Garabedian-direct/Scott
1 Q Now, as quickly as possible, I would just ask you to
2 look at items 25 and 26 on that exhibit.
3 A Yes.
4 Q And tell us briefly what they are.
5 A Item number 25 is a charge at a restaurant Laurant,
6 L A U R E N T, in Paris, France, in the amount of
7 $339.24. And item number 26 is a charge at Bunta,
8 B U N T A, Molino, M O L I N O, a charge from Italy, in
9 the amount of $2,505.62.
10 Q And item number 30, can you tell the jury what that
11 is.
12 A Item number 30 is a charge at L. Marciano,
13 M A R C I A N O, from Paris, France. It is in the amount
14 of $3,626, U.S. dollars.
15 Q Items 31 and 32, can you tell us what those are?
16 A Item 31 is a charge at an establishment by the name
17 of, I believe it is Jyph, J Y P H, in Paris, France. It
18 is in the amount of $730.75.
19 Item 32 is a charge at Galerie Sordello,
20 G A L E R I E, S O R D E L L O. It is a charge from
21 Paris, France. And that charge is in the amount of
22 $21,149.10.
23 Q Now, items 33 through 36, can you tell us what those
24 are.
25 A 33 is a charge at Sulka, S U L K A, in Paris,
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORT ER
396
Garabedian-direct/Scott
1 France. And in the amount of $2,070.37.
2 Item 34 is an airline ticket for Air France in
3 the amount of $5,830.35.
4 Item 35 is another airline ticket with Air France
5 for the same amount of $5,830.35, as the previous charge.
6 I am at 35 --
7 Q 36.
8 A 36. Item number 36 is a charge at the Ritz in Paris
9 in the amount of $3,721.49.
10 Q Now, can you tell from looking at the statement when
11 those charges were made.
12 A The closing statement -- date is July 21, 1994.
13 Looking at the individual records of charges attached to
14 this statement, there is -- there are dates on the
15 individual charge slips, and, for example, item number,
16 item number 30, for example, is the charge from L.
17 Marciano in Paris, which has a date of July 5th, 1994.
18 Q Is it fair to say that these charges were made in the
19 summer of 1994?
20 A They were made between the closing date of the prior
21 month, which was June 20th, and the closing date of this
22 statement, which was July 21st.
23 Q Thank you.
24 Now I am asking you to look at
25 Government's Exhibit 427 in evidence.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
397
Garabedian-direct/Scott
1 A Yes.
2 Q I will ask you to read aloud the third paragraph in
3 that exhibit.
4 A The third paragraph begins with: He is going to have
5 to borrow the money. He has offered, and the offer in
6 compromise submitted --
7 MR. TRABULUS: Objection, your Honor.
8 This is again repetitive.
9 THE COURT: Overruled.
10 A Where shall he borrow this money? Perhaps he should
11 cease eating.
12 Q Finally, what is the date on that letter?
13 A September 29t h, 1994.
14 THE COURT: How much more do you have with this
15 witness?
16 MS. SCOTT: Two or three more questions about one
17 other exhibit.
18 THE COURT: Go ahead.
19 Q Finally, Mr. Garabedian, I will ask you to take a
20 look at Government's Exhibit 475.
21 A Yes.
22 Q And I am showing you Government's Exhibit 475-A.
23 Is 475-A a true and accurate copy of
24 Government's Exhibit 475?
25 A Yes.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
398
Garabedian-direct/Scott
1 MS. SCOTT: I offer Government's Exhibit 475-A.
2 MR. TRABULUS: No objection.
3 THE COURT: Government's Exhibit 475-A in
4 evidence.
5 (Government's Exhibit 475-A received in
6 evidence.)
7 Q Now, I would ask you to take a look at item 7 and 8
8 and 12 on that exhibit, and tell the jury what those are.
9 A Item se ven is a chart from Positano, P O S I T A N O,
10 car service, in Italy. It is in the amount of $329.97.
11 Item eight is a charge from Les Sirenuse,
12 S I R E N U S E, from Italy, in the amount of $4,405.10.
13 Item 12 is a charge from NRSC, in Washington,
14 D.C., in the amount of $2,000.
15 Q Now, going back to Government's Exhibit 824-A and
16 read to the jury the monthly charges for 1994?
17 A Could you repeat the question?
18 Q I will back up for one minute back to 475-A.
19 Item 12, you said was a charge to NRSC?
20 A Correct.
21 Q Did you have an opportunity to look at your records
22 back at your office regarding that entry?
23 A Yes.
24 Q And what did you learn is the full name of that
25 vendor, NRSC?
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
399
Garabedian-direct/Scott
1 A The vendor's full name is the National Republican
2 Senatorial Committee.
3 Q What does it say underneath that charge?
4 A It says contribution.
5 Q Contribution/donations?
6 A Donations, yes.
7 Q Going back to Government's Exhibit 824-A, if you read
8 off the monthly charges in 1994.
9 A Starting with January, the total for 1994 in January
10 was $981.08.
11 February total was $17,649.48.
12 The March total was $14,297.21.
13 The April total was $4,456.50.
14 The May total was $17,672.49.
15 The June was $3,012.91.
16 July's total was $47,392.51.
17 August was $9,614.10.
18 September was $27,215.83.
19 October was $12,270.83.
20 November was $18,042.43.
21 December was $10,427.30.
22 Q What was the year total?
23 A The year total was $183,032.67.
24 Q Now, Mr. Garabedian, I am showing you
25 Government's Exhibit 825 thro ugh 834.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
400
Garabedian-direct/Scott
1 Do you recognize these exhibits?
2 (Handed to the witness.)
3 THE COURT: I asked you if you only had a few
4 more questions, you have more?
5 MR. WHITE: I now have three more questions
6 relating to the exhibits I just gave him. It will be
7 about two more minutes.
8 THE COURT: Okay.
9 (Handed to the witness.)
10 A I recognize these exhibits.
11 Q Can you tell us what they are?
12 A Copies of the payment checks received by American
13 Express in payment of the American Express account.
14 Q Now, how were those copies made?
15 A These copies were made pursuant to my request for
16 reproduction of the information that American Express
17 maintains electronically regarding these checks. They
18 were then, as they say digitize d and faxed over to my
19 office.
20 Q Are these checks kept in the regularly conducted
21 business of American Express?
22 A Yes.
23 Q Was it the regular business practice of American
24 Express to make these records?
25 A Yes.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
401
Garabedian-direct/Scott
1 Q Looking at 826, 828, 830, the even numbered ones --
2 MS. SCOTT: I am sorry, I offer the exhibits in
3 evidence.
4 THE COURT: What are the numbers again?
5 MS. SCOTT: 825 through 834.
6 THE COURT: Any objection?
7 MR. JENKS: Your Honor, presumably those checks,
8 although they are Who's Who Worldwide checks, are being
9 offered against Bruce Gordon and not against the
10 corporation?
11 MS. SCOTT: That's correct.
12 MR. JENKS: No objection.
13 MR. TRABULUS: Your Honor, there is no knob.
14 THE COURT: Very well, Government's Exhibit 825
15 through 834 in evidence.
16 (Government's Exhibits 825 through 834 received
17 in evidence.)
18 Q Pulling out the even numbered exhibits, 826, 828,
19 830, 832 and 834 --
20 A Yes.
21 Q What is the name on those checks indicating the
22 person who paid for that part of the American Express
23 bill?
24 A Going through these checks, they were submitted
25 either by Elizabeth Sautter, Who's Who --
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
402
Garabedian-direct/Scott
1 Q I am just talking about the even numbered ones.
2 A The even numbered? All right, let me just go through
3 them again.
4 826, 828, 830, 830, 834, are copies of the checks
5 submitted to American Express for payment by -- on the
6 checks from Elizabeth Sautter.
7 Q Setting those checks aside, the even numbered checks,
8 I ask to you look at the odd numbered checks, 825, 827,
9 829, 831, and 833.
10 A Right.
11 Q And I ask you to tell the jury what those checks
12 indicate about who paid -- who was paying the money on
13 those checks to American Express?
14 A These checks were issued by Who's Who Worldwide
15 Registry, Inc., Sterling Who's Who, Inc. and I believe
16 there was one other corporate entity that submitted one
17 check that was in these files. I would have to go through
18 it individually to locate it.
19 MS. SCOTT: Your Honor, I would ask permission at
20 this time to publish the odd exhibits to the jury and the
21 even exhibits.
22 THE COURT: When we get back from our recess.
23 Have you concluded your direct examination?
24 MS. SCOTT: I have.
25 THE COURT: When we get back you can publish
HARR Y RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
403
Garabedian-direct/Scott
1 that.
2 MS. SCOTT: I have no further questions from
3 Mr. Garabedian.
4 THE COURT: Did you find the other one?
5 THE WITNESS: I believe it is this one, your
6 Honor.
7 It appears to be Interglobal Execnet, Inc.
8 E X E C N E T, Inc.
9 THE COURT: Very well.
10 Members of the jury, we will take a ten-minute
11 recess.
12 Please do not discuss the case and keep an open
13 mind.
14 Madam deputy, you will please recess the jury.
15
16 (Whereupon, a recess is taken.)
17
18 (Whereupon, the jury at this time entered the
19 courtroom.)
20 THE COURT: Please be seated, members of the
21 jury.
22 You wanted to publish something to the jury?
23 MS. SCOTT: Yes, your Honor. I did.
24 THE COURT: What are you publishi ng?
25 MS. SCOTT: The checks, 825 through 834.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
404
Garabedian-direct/Scott
1 You start with number one. We go in seniority
2 here.
3 MS. SCOTT: Thank you for reminding me.
4 THE COURT: Like the judiciary. Everything is in
5 seniority. We eat in order, we walk around in order.
6 Everything is in seniority.
7 We have a new courthouse being built in Central
8 Islip. Our chambers and courtrooms are being allocated,
9 by seniority, naturally.
10 (Whereupon, the exhibit/exhibits were published
11 to the jury.)
12 THE COURT: All right, cross-examination.
13 MR. TRABULUS: Thank you, your Honor.
14
15 CROSS-EXAMINATION
16 BY MR. TRABULUS:
17 Q Good afternoon.
18 A Good after, sir.
19 Q I am Mr. Gordon's lawyer, and I have relatively few
20 que stions for you.
21 Mr. Garabedian, I want to understand the account
22 arrangements here. Mr. Gordon himself did not have an
23 account with American Express, did he?
24 A No.
25 Q The account was with Elizabeth Sautter; is that
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
405
Garabedian-cross/Trabulus
1 correct?
2 A Yes.
3 Q And the billing statements were sent to Elizabeth
4 Sautter; is that correct?
5 A Yes.
6 Q And he basically had permission to charge things
7 under her account; is that correct?
8 A He had an account under her account number.
9 Q Was there actually any agreement, account agreement
10 between Mr. Gordon and American Express, anything like
11 that?
12 A There is a supplemental application which needed to
13 be submitted by the basic member and submit -- signed by
14 the supple mental card holder.
15 Q Was he himself responsible for the charges?
16 A Under the terms and conditions of American Express,
17 yes.
18 Q And Mr. Garabedian, you have no way of knowing from
19 your records whether or not certain of the things that
20 were charged were used for Who's Who Worldwide or whether
21 used for him personally?
22 A I would have no way of knowing.
23 Q And certainly it appears that the clothing would be
24 for personal use?
25 A It would seem to be.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
406
Garabedian-cross/Trabulus
1 Q You have no way of knowing as to whether any of the
2 travel expenses would be used for business travel?
3 A No.
4 Q You have no any of knowing whether or not as to
5 whether artwork or framing or crystal was bought, as to
6 whether it was used to furnish corporate f acilities?
7 A I have no way to know.
8 Q Similar with regard to the restaurant charges, you
9 have no way of knowing as to whether it would be business
10 lunches or dinners; is that correct?
11 A Right.
12 Q It would not be unusual for a corporate executive to
13 have a credit card account which might be reimbursed by
14 the corporation; is that an unusual arrangement?
15 A It is not an unusual arrangement. But it is normally
16 a company account.
17 Q And would the corporate -- withdrawn.
18 MR. TRABULUS: No further questions.
19 THE COURT: You may proceed.
20
21 REDIRECT EXAMINATION
22 BY MS. SCOTT:
23 Q Mr. Garabedian, did Bruce Gordon have an account in
24 his name?
25 A There was a plastic embossed with the name Bruce
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
407
Garabedian-redirect/Scott
1 Gordon and the supplemental number assigned to him, yes.
2 MS. SCOTT: Thank you, I have no further
3 questions.
4 THE COURT: Anything else?
5 MR. TRABULUS: Nothing, your Honor.
6 THE COURT: You may step down. Mr. Garabedian.
7 Call your next witness.
8 (Whereupon, at this time the witness left the
9 witness stand.)
10 MS. SCOTT: The government calls Peter
11 Hirshcleifer.
12 THE COURT: Would you stand up, and raise your
13 right hand, sir.
14
15 P A U L H I R S H C L E I F E R ,
16 called as a witness, having been first
17 duly sworn, was examined and testified
18 as follows:
19
20 THE COURT: Please be seated. State your full
21 name and spell your last name.
22 THE WITNESS: First name is Paul, Hirshcleifer,
23 H I R S C L E I F E R.
24
25 DIRECT EXAMINATION
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
408
Hirschleifer-direct/Scott
1 BY MS. SCOTT:
2 Q Good afternoon, Mr. Hirshcleifer.
3 A Good afternoon.
4 Q What do you do for a living?
5 A Retailer, I own the Hirshcleifer stores in Manhasset.
6 Q What is the name of your stores?
7 A The names of the stores are --
8 THE COURT: I didn't hear a thing you said.
9 First of all relax.
10 Now, pull the microphone. Pretend this is the
11 day before Christmas and you just sold out everything in
12 your store.
13 THE WITNESS: Thank you, your Honor.
14 THE COURT: All right.
15 THE WITNESS: The name of the store is
16 Hirshcleifer, in which we have the Giorgio Armani.
17 THE COURT: A R M A N I?
18 THE WITNESS: Yes.
19 THE COURT: How do you spell Giorgio?
20 THE WITNESS: G I O R G I O.
21 Q And what is your title?
22 A I am the president of the company.
23 Q And as the president of the company, are you aware of
24 the manner in which the company keeps records of sales?
25 A Yes, I am.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
409
Hirschleifer-direct/Scott
1 Q I am showing you Government's Exhibit 504, 505,
2 505-A, 506, 507, 508, 509, 510, 511, 511-A, 512, 513 and
3 514.
4 I ask you if you recognize those documents.
5 (Handed to the witness.)
6 A Yes, I do.
7 Q What are they?
8 A They are receipts. The first one is a receipt from
9 Giorgio Armani.
10 The next one, two ---I believe the next seven or
11 eight are receipts from Giorgio Armani. And there is a
12 receipt -- these were all receipts from Giorgio Armani.
13 Q Are they receipts from the company which you are the
14 president of?
15 A Yes, they are.
16 Q How were these receipts created?
17 A The client came in, purchased merchandise. Upon the
18 purchase of the merchandise, the sales associates wrote up
19 the sales slip.
20 Q And what information was entered on the sales slip?
21 A We have the manufacturer code, the style number, the
22 item number, is it the retail price.
23 Q And does it also indicate the method of payment?
24 A Yes, it does.
25 Q Now, do these receipts record charges for items
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
410
Hirschleifer-direct/Scott
1 purchased from your stores, Giorgio Armani Boutique?
2 A Yes, it does.
3 Q And were they created at or near the time the
4 purchases were made?
5 A At the time.
6 Q Were they created by the Giorgio Armani employees
7 servicing the customer at the time they made the
8 purchases?
9 A Yes.
10 Q Were they created by people who had knowledge of the
11 transactions?
12 A Yes, they were.
13 Q Were these receipts kept in the regular conducted
14 business of Giorgio Armani?
15 A Yes, they are.
16 Q Was it the regular practice of business --
17 THE COURT: You have to slow down a bit. You are
18 picking up speed as you go along. Pretty soon you are
19 getting to flank speed. I will describe that soon when
20 there is a lull in the action here. It has to do with the
21 motion picture called Around the World in 80 Days. That's
22 what flank speed is. I will give you that later.
23 Q Was it the regular business practice of Giorgio
24 Armani to make these records and keep them?
25 A Yes.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
411
Hirschleifer-direct/Scott
1 MS. SCOTT: I offer Government's E xhibit 504
2 through 514, including 505-A, 511-A, and 514-A.
3 THE COURT: Any objection?
4 MR. TRABULUS: Your Honor, I don't think so.
5 Would you bear with me a moment?
6 THE COURT: Of course.
7 MR. TRABULUS: My bound set is a little out of
8 order here.
9 THE COURT: Take your time.
10 MR. TRABULUS: I don't know if I have all of them
11 in sequence here the way they were given to me.
12 Based on his testimony, no, I have no objection.
13 THE COURT: Government's Exhibits 504 through 514
14 in evidence.
15 (Government's Exhibits 504 through 514 received
16 in evidence.)
17 Q Mr. Hirshcleifer, I would ask you to go through those
18 exhibits and tell the jury what they show.
19 A 504 shows purchases from the men's Giorgio Armani
20 boutique of various items.
21 This shows for example, six ties. The other four
22 items are -- i t does not specifically say what the item
23 is, but we can read the six ties on 504.
24 THE COURT: You want the amounts of each one?
25 MS. SCOTT: I would like to know the total.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
412
Hirschleifer-direct/Scott
1 A The total on 504 with the sales tax was $4,188.10.
2 Q What was the date of that purchase?
3 A November 28th, 1992.
4 The next one I have is 505, the purchase of a
5 men's suit -- the total purchase before the sales tax was
6 $2,075.
7 THE COURT: What is the date on it?
8 THE WITNESS: I am looking.
9 The date of the sale is February 19th, 1994.
10 The next one is 506. The date of the purchase is
11 April 10th, 1993.
12 The amount of the purchase, including the sales
13 tax is $6,944.
14 Q What types of items were purchased?
15 A On this sales slip the re are two suits, one jacket --
16 I am sorry, three suits and one jacket.
17 Next is number 507. The date of the purchase is
18 April 10th, 1990 -- it looks like 1993. The amount is
19 $998.20. And it appears to be 11 or 12 ties.
20 508, April 17th, 1993, the amount of the purchase
21 is --
22 Q Mr. Hirshcleifer, if you could give us the amount.
23 A Certainly. Including the sales tax, $2,793.28. And
24 it is one man's suit and three bathing suits.
25 The next is 509, the date is November 6th, 1993,
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
413
Hirschleifer-direct/Scott
1 and the amount of the sale is $504.63 and it is for one
2 man's sweater.
3 The next purchase is October 6th, no year. But
4 it must be '93, because it is the next invoice number.
5 It is various merchandise that --
6 THE COURT: What is the exhibit num ber on that?
7 THE WITNESS: 510.
8 Various merchandise consisting of four ties and
9 three shirts, the total amount is $1,459.33.
10 Exhibit 511, dated September 13th, 1994, four
11 ties in the amount of $352.63.
12 512, August 20th, 1994, the amount of the sale is
13 $6,938.58. It is one raincoat and two men suits.
14 513, dated September 14th, 1994, $2,517.20. It
15 is for one Navy suit. And it appears to be a white
16 shirt.
17 Invoice -- I am sorry, Exhibit 514, dated
18 September 24th, 1995, the amount of the sale is $292.95.
19 And it looks to be a men's sweater.
20 Q Thank you, Mr. Hirshcleifer.
21 I have no further questions for you.
22 THE COURT: Cross-examination.
23 MR. TRABULUS: Thank you, Mr. Hirshcleifer. I
24 have no further öööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööö öööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööööö MS. SCOTT: The government calls Lynette
5 Shultis.
6 THE COURT: Raise your right hand.
7
8 L Y N E T T E S H U L T I S ,
9 called as a witness, having been first
10 duly sworn, was examined and testified
11 as follows:
12
13 THE COURT: Please be seated.
14 State your full name and spell your name.
15 THE WITNESS: S H U L T I S, first name is
16 Lynette, L Y N E T T E.
17
18 DIRECT EXAMINATION
19 BY MS. SCOTT:
20 Q Good afternoon, Ms. Shultis.
21 What do you do for a living?
22 A Credit markets and client services operations manager
23 at Bergdorf Goodman.
24 Q How long have you had that job?
25 A With Bergdorf for seven years and with the present
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
415
Shultis-direct/Scott
1 position about a year and a half.
2 THE COURT: You have to talk a little slower so
3 we can all hear what you have to say.
4 Q Directing your attention to April of 1994, what was
5 your position at that time?
6 A In April of 1994 I was credit operations manager.
7 Q And what were your responsibilities as credit
8 operations manager?
9 A Bill adjustments department, accounts receivable
10 reconciliation.
11 Q Now, I am showing you Government's Exhibits 483 and
12 484.
13 (Handed to the witness.)
14 Q You recognize the documents?
15 A Yes.
16 Q What are those?
17 A Sales receipts from Bergdorf Goodman.
18 Q How do you recognize them?
19 A They are old receipts. We just changed our registers
20 recently. But this is the original receipts we used in
21 the store for any purchase made.
22 Q How are these receipts created?
23 A This type of receipt was a piece of paper that was
24 actually slid into the register. And as the information
25 was typed in by the sales associate with the merchandise
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
416
Shultis-direct/Scott
1 that was being purchased, it printed out.
2 Q What would happen to those records after they were
3 made?
4 A After records were made a copy went to the customer.
5 Another copy goes into the drawer. At night they are
6 collected and put in a bag and brought to the sales audit
7 department, where th ey go through to make sure everything
8 was correct on the receipts and then they are stored.
9 Q Do these receipts show charges for items purchased at
10 Bergdorf Goodman?
11 A Yes.
12 Q And were they created at or near the time the
13 purchase was made?
14 A Correct.
15 Q Were they created by the person serving the customer
16 who made the purchases?
17 A Yes.
18 Q Were they created by people with knowledge of the
19 transaction?
20 A Yes.
21 Q Are these receipts kept in the course of regularly
22 conducted business activity at Bergdorf Goodman?
23 A Yes, they are.
24 Q Was it the regular business practice of Bergdorf
25 Goodman to make these records?
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
417
Shultis-direct/Scott
1 A Yes.
2 MS. SCOTT: I offer 483 and 484 in evidence.
3 THE COURT: Any objection?
4 MR. TRABULUS: No.
5 THE COURT: Government's Exhibits 483 and 484 in
6 evidence.
7 (Government's Exhibit 483 received in evidence.)
8 (Government's Exhibit 484 received in evidence.)
9 Q Taking a look at the two exhibits, can you tell us
10 what they show about the transactions that they represent?
11 A It would show the department and the class of the
12 merchandise. It gives a brief description of the
13 merchandise. It tells the individual SKU so we can go
14 back and find out specifically what the merchandise is.
15 THE COURT: The individual what? SKU did you
16 say?
17 THE WITNESS: SKU. It is a number associated
18 with everything. It tells -- gives us information as to
19 who the vendor is, what season it is from, and actually
20 what the merchandise is from.
21 THE COURT: How do you spell this?
22 THE WITNES S: S K U.
23 THE COURT: I never heard of it before, but it is
24 all right.
25 THE WITNESS: You are not in retail.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
418
Shultis-direct/Scott
1 THE COURT: All right.
2 Q Can you tell us what those records show?
3 A This would show that -- it shows a number of
4 different purchases. It also tells the number of items of
5 each item purchased and the dollar amounts for those
6 items.
7 Q When were these items purchased? If you look at
8 Government's Exhibit 483 first.
9 A It is a subtotal, a two-page document, so it is April
10 2nd, 1994, 484 has the date on the bottom.
11 Q You say those exhibits represent a series of
12 transactions that occurred on one day?
13 A Actually, I am looking at this, and it looks like
14 these are -- there are two different sales receipts. The
15 first one, 483 is a subtotal, so there are other pages
16 that go along with that. And the one for 484 is a
17 separate document.
18 Q I am showing you another document also part of
19 Government's Exhibit 483.
20 Do you recognize that?
21 A Yes.
22 This is the entire document. Unfortunately the
23 receipt does not come out as one fold, or it didn't come
24 out as one fold -- one full receipt. It just fit whatever
25 could fit on one page, and you have to insert another page
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
419
Shultis-direct/Scott
1 to get the rest of the items printed on there and continue
2 until there is a total. So this is a multi-page receipt.
3 Q Once again, is that a document that was created and
4 kept in the regular course of business at Bergdorf
5 Goodman?
6 A Yes, it is.
7 MS. SC OTT: Your Honor, I offer that additional
8 piece.
9 THE COURT: You will annex that to 483.
10 Any objection?
11 MR. TRABULUS: I have no objection, your Honor.
12 I just don't know if I have it.
13 THE COURT: Why don't you show it to
14 Mr. Trabulus.
15 (Whereupon, at this time there was a pause in the
16 proceedings.)
17 MR. TRABULUS: No objection.
18 THE COURT: We will attach it or annex it to 483,
19 and it becomes part of one exhibit, 483.
20 Q Now, the date you said again was April --
21 A April 2nd, 1994.
22 Q And what items were purchased on that day?
23 A This lists -- there were four of one type of brief,
24 four of another type of brief, four of another type of
25 brief, six of another type of brief.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
420
Shultis-direct/Scott
1 THE COURT: Brief , B R --
2 THE WITNESS: B R I E F.
3 THE COURT: What is a brief?
4 THE WITNESS: Underwear.
5 THE COURT: Okay.
6 A One pair of socks. The second page is a
7 continuation, it shows one pair of ankle hose, one pair of
8 socks, another pair of hose, another pair of socks. On
9 the next page there are four different pairs of socks.
10 And on the last page there is one more pair of socks, and
11 then it totals.
12 Q Are you aware of the types of items these are from
13 looking at these records?
14 A Other than the brief description, I couldn't tell you
15 specifically what they were unless I was able to look up
16 the S K U number, which would tell you what the vendor
17 was, and the definite description would tell color and
18 size.
19 Q Looking at 483, can you tell us the total amount
20 spent on that day for these items you described?
21 A $780.48, total of sale.
22 Q Looking at Government's Exhibit 484, can you tell the
23 jury what that shows, what the transaction there was for?
24 A It shows one item purchased, a long sleeve polo
25 shirt, a total of $146.14.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
421
Shultis-direct/Scott
1 Q What is the date of this transaction?
2 A April 2nd, 1994 also.
3 Q Can you tell us anything else about the brand name of
4 those items?
5 A No, not from this, I would have to get the S K U
6 information.
7 MS. SCOTT: Thank you.
8 I have no further questions.
9 MR. TRABULUS: Thank you for coming. I have no
10 further questions.
11 THE COURT: Very well.
12 (Whereupon, at this time the witness left the
13 witness stand.)
14 THE COURT: Please call your next witness.
15 MR. WHITE: Your Honor, the gov ernment calls
16 Robert King.
17 THE COURT: Raise your right hand.
18
19 R O B E R T K I N G ,
20 called as a witness, having been first
21 duly sworn, was examined and testified
22 as follows:
23
24 THE COURT: Please be seated.
25 State your full name and spell you are last
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
422
1 name.
2 THE WITNESS: Robert King, K I N G.
3 THE COURT: You may proceed.
4 MR. WHITE: Thank you, your Honor.
5
6 DIRECT EXAMINATION
7 BY MR. WHITE:
8 Q Mr. King, can you tell us how you are employed.
9 A Yes. I am the director of operations for Fendi
10 Stores.
11 THE COURT: For what?
12 THE WITNESS: Fendi, F E N D I. Fendi Stores.
13 Q Can you tell us what kind of business Fendi Stores
14 is?
15 A It is a retail store.
16 Q What sort of merchandise does it sell?
17 A Collection of handbags, accessories, clothing, shoes.
18 Q What brand of merchandise does it sell?
19 A Only Fendi. Fendi is an Italian designer.
20 Q Now, are you familiar with Fendi's record keeping
21 procedures?
22 A Yes, I am.
23 Q Can you tell us, when a customer makes a purchase at
24 Fendi, is there a receipt prepared?
25 A Yes.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
423
King-direct/White
1 Q Tell us how that works.
2 A It is handwritten at first. It is a preprinted
3 form. It is then processed through a register system
4 where the register imprints sales information on it. A
5 copy of it is given to the customer, and we keep a copy.
6 Q And if the customer pays for it with a credit card,
7 is there any receipt retained by Fendi?
8 A Yes. If a client is paying by credit card, the
9 actual credit card payment is processed separately and
10 generates a second receipt, a separate receipt for each
11 sale.
12 Q Does the store then maintain a copy of those
13 receipts?
14 A Yes.
15 Q Let me show you Government's Exhibits 521, 521-A,
16 521-B, 522 and 522-A.
17 (Handed to the witness.)
18 Q Now, Mr. King, do you recognize those exhibits?
19 A I do.
20 Q Would you tell us what they are, please.
21 A Exhibit 521 is a Fendi Store, Inc. sales slip, where
22 you see the customer's name and address written on the top
23 portion by the salesperson, and the information on the
24 sale printed on there by the register system.
25 Q And 521-A and B, what are they?
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
424
King-direct/White
1 A 521-A is the second receipt generated when the credit
2 card is used for payment. And 521-B is the back side of
3 521, which just shows the credit card imprint on the sales
4 slip, on the Fendi Store sales slip.
5 Q Is it 522?
6 A 522 is the same, a Fendi Store sales slip. And 522-A
7 shows the credit card payment.
8 Q Now, is the -- is it the regular practice of Fendi
9 Stores to make and keep such records?
10 A Yes, it is.
11 Q Do you make and keep such records in the regular
12 course of your business?
13 A Yes, we do.
14 MR. WHITE: The government would offer
15 Government's Exhibit 521, 521-A, 521-B, 522 and 522-A.
16 MR. TRABULUS: No objection.
17 THE COURT: 521 through 522-A in evidence.
18 (Government's Exhibits 521 through 522-A received
19 in evidence.)
20 Q Mr. King, if you take a look at 521, would you tell
21 us the name of the customer?
2 2 A Bruce W. Gordon.
23 Q And would you tell us what the item purchased was?
24 A It was a wool coat purchased for $1,351, plus $111.38
25 sales tax for a total of $1,461.38.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
425
King-direct/White
1 Q The date of the purchase?
2 A November 26th, 1994.
3 Q And can you tell us from the receipt as to whether
4 the coat was on sale?
5 A Yes. The original price was 2,250, 40 percent off
6 which brought it to 1,350.
7 Q Now, are there numbers on the receipt, or anything
8 else on the receipt from which you can decipher additional
9 information from the merchandise?
10 MR. TRABULUS: Objection, your Honor. It is
11 really irrelevant, this level of detail.
12 THE COURT: Sustained.
13 Q Mr. King, do you know whether the coat is a men's or
14 woman's coat?
15 A It is a wo man's coat.
16 Q And how was this -- how did the customer pay for this
17 purchase?
18 A American Express.
19 Q Take a look at 522. Can you tell us what the date of
20 that purchase was?
21 A The same date, November 26th, 1994.
22 Q And the customer?
23 A Bruce W. Gordon.
24 Q And what was purchased?
25 A A tweed coat with Fisher trim, a fur trim coat.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
426
King-direct/White
1 Q Men's or women's coat?
2 A Woman's.
3 Q How much did it cost?
4 A It also was on sale, the original price was $7,500.
5 And the sale price is $5,000.
6 MR. WHITE: No further questions.
7 MR. TRABULUS: I have no questions, your Honor.
8 Thank you.
9 THE COURT: You may step down. Thank you.
10 (Whereupon, at this time the witness left the
11 witness stand.)
12 THE COURT: Please call your next witness.
13 MR. WHITE: The government calls Joann Dempsey,
14 your Honor.
15 THE COURT: Raise your right hand.
16
17 J O A N N D E M P S E Y ,
18 called as a witness, having been first
19 duly sworn, was examined and testified
20 as follows:
21
22 THE CLERK: Please be seated.
23 State your full name and spell your name.
24 THE WITNESS: Joann Dempsey, D E M P S E Y.
25 J O A N N.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
427
Dempsey-direct/White
1
2 DIRECT EXAMINATION
3 BY MR. WHITE:
4 Q Ms. Dempsey, how are you employed?
5 A I am the manager of the general office in the New
6 York store of Saks Fifth Avenue.
7 Q And how long have you had that position?
8 A I have had the position approximately two years,
9 although I have been with the company for 15.
10 Q Are you familiar with Saks' record keeping
11 procedures?
12 A Yes, sir.
13 Q And when a customer makes a purchase at Saks, is a
14 store receipt prepared?
15 A That's correct, sir.
16 Q And is that done at the time of the purchase?
17 A At the time of the purchase a transaction is run
18 through the register. It is our legal means of recording
19 the sale. A copy is handed to the customer, and the rest
20 is processed through our systems.
21 Q Can you briefly describe what that processing is.
22 A Normally the customer is charged at the time that the
23 transaction is made. There are instances where a deposit
24 is taken for custom made clothing, but the credit card at
25 the point where it is presented is swiped through the
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
428
Dempsey-direct/White
1 register, or a cash transaction happens. It is processed
2 through our sales audit system. The copies are given to
3 the third party credit cards if they are indeed utilized.
4 And the sale is posted to the customer as charge account.
5 Q Does Saks maintain a copy of that receipt?
6 A Yes. Legally we keep it on site for 13 months. The
7 credit card companies have access to a deeper history.
8 Q Is it the regular practice of Saks to make and keep
9 such records?
10 A Yes.
11 Q And do you make it and keep them in the course of
12 your regular business?
13 A Everyday.
14 Q Let me show you Government's Exhibits 517.
15 (Handed to the witness.)
16 Q I am showing you 517 through 520, and 520-A.
17 (Handed to the witness.).
18 Q Are those Saks store receipts made in the manner in
19 which you just described?
20 A Yes.
21 MR. W HITE: The government would offer 517
22 through 520 and 520-A.
23 THE COURT: Any objection?
24 MR. TRABULUS: Your Honor, I have not been given
25 520-A, I doubt that I would object to it, but I would like
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
429
Dempsey-direct/White
1 to see it first.
2 THE COURT: Surely.
3 (Counsel confer.)
4 MR. TRABULUS: No objection.
5 THE COURT: Government's Exhibit 517 through
6 520-A in evidence.
7 (Government's Exhibit 517 through 520-A received
8 in evidence.)
9 Q Ms. Dempsey, if you take a look at 517, can you tell
10 us the date of the purchase there?
11 A I am sorry, but I don't have 517 in front of me.
12 Q It should be the backside of one of those exhibits.
13 A Yes, it is.
14 The date is August 21st, 1994 of the
15 transaction. It happens to represent a sal e for Hugo Boss
16 cashmere overcoat.
17 THE COURT: How do you spell that?
18 THE WITNESS: B O S S, Hugo, the first name of
19 the designer.
20 It happens to be a Navy double breasted cashmere
21 overcoat for $1,295.
22 Q Can you tell from the receipt how it was paid for?
23 A On an American Express card.
24 Q Can you tell from the receipt the customer's name?
25 A It is Bruce Gordon.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
430
Dempsey-direct/White
1 Q If you can look at 518.
2 A Uh-huh.
3 Q What is the date of that purchase?
4 A August 21st, 1994.
5 Q What was purchased?
6 A It happens to be a brown Raglan sleeve.
7 THE COURT: R A G L A N D?
8 THE WITNESS: R A G L A N.
9 THE COURT: L A N?
10 THE WITNESS: Yes.
11 Q How much did the jackets cost on sale for?
12 A $4 90.95.
13 Q Take a look at 519.
14 Could you tell us the date of that purchase?
15 A This was actually a deposit that we mandate on
16 custom-made clothing, processed on September 24th, 1994.
17 Normally we do request a 50 percent down payment for
18 custom clothing.
19 Q And what is the amount of the down payment on this
20 date?
21 A Before sales tax $6,080.
22 Q Now, if you can look at Exhibit 520, and 520-A, those
23 are four pages that comprise one receipt; is that correct?
24 A That's correct.
25 Q Could you tell us the date of that receipt?
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
431
Dempsey-direct/White
1 A It was charged to the customer at the point where the
2 goods were available for delivery on November 12th, 1994.
3 Q Can you tell us the items purchased there.
4 A Certainly. Six custom-made suits by a designer named
5 Alan Flusser, F L U S S E R.
6 Q How much were the Alan Flusser suits?
7 A They seemed to vary anywhere from $2,295 to $1,750.
8 Q What else was purchased besides the suits?
9 A A variety of neck wear and pocket squares, pocket
10 squares being anywhere from 20 to $55, neck wear between
11 115 or 105 dollars.
12 Q The grand total?
13 A $14,355.84.
14 Q Now, could you tell us, is there a name and address
15 listed for the customer on the receipt?
16 A Certainly, Bruce Gordon.
17 Q Can you tell us what the address is?
18 A 250 East 54th Street in Manhattan.
19 MR. WHITE: No further questions, your Honor.
20
21 CROSS-EXAMINATION
22 BY MR. TRABULUS:
23 Q Could you just tell me the date of that receipt?
24 A November 12th, 1994.
25 MR. TRABULUS: Thank you.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFF ICIAL COURT REPORTER
432
Dempsey-cross/Trabulus
1 No further questions.
2 THE COURT: You may step down, Ms. Dempsey.
3 Please call your next witness.
4 (Whereupon, at this time the witness left the
5 witness stand.)
6 MS. SCOTT: The government calls Aidong,
7 A I D O N G, last name He. H E.
8 THE COURT: Raise your right hand.
9
10 A I D O N G H E ,
11 called as a witness, having been first
12 duly sworn, was examined and testified
13 as follows:
14
15 THE COURT: Please be seated.
16 State your name and spell your name, please.
17 THE WITNESS: Aidong, A I D O N G, He, H E.
18
19 DIRECT EXAMINATION
20 BY MS. SCOTT:
21 Q Good afternoon, Ms. He.
22 A Hi.
23 Q Tell me where you work?
24 A Tourneau, Inc.
25 Q What do you do for them?
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, C P, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
433
He-direct/Scott
1 A Work in the accounting department.
2 Q What is your position there?
3 A Accounting staff.
4 Q What are your responsibilities on the accounting
5 staff?
6 A I do basic accounting functions, like bank
7 reconciliations, credit card reconciliations and other
8 things.
9 Q Are you aware of the manner in which sales records
10 are kept at Tourneau?
11 A Yes.
12 Q Ms. He, I am showing you Government's Exhibit 523 and
13 524.
14 Do you recognize those?
15 (Handed to the witness.)
16 A Yes.
17 Q And what are those?
18 A These are sales receipts.
19 Q For -- what are those receipts for?
20 A These are proof of purchase. When a customer comes
21 in the store and they want to purchase merchandise, the
22 salespeople right up tickets like this.
23 Q And what do they do with those tickets, once they
24 have written them up?
25 A They have to be signed by the customer. Then these
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
434
He-direct/Scott
1 things will be sent, say the store, after one day, the
2 store will send a whole day's ticket like this to our home
3 office to get posted to the system, computer system. And
4 then it will be stored day by day, month by month, store
5 by store.
6 Q And are these records kept in the course of regularly
7 conducted business of Tourneau?
8 A Yes.
9 Q And is it the regular business practice of Tourneau
10 to make these records and keep them?
11 A Yes.
12 MS. SCOTT: I offer Government's Exhibits 523 and
13 524.
14 THE COURT: Any objection?
15 MR. TRABULUS: No.
16 THE COURT: Government's Exhibits 523 and 524 in
17 evidence.
18 (Government's Exhibit 523 received in evidence.)
19 (Government's Exhibit 524 received in evidence.)
20 Q Ms. He, when you take a look at those two documents,
21 can you tell us what they show about the transactions that
22 they represent?
23 A Number one is the customer's name and address and the
24 item he bought. And --
25 Q What is the name given?
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
435
He-direct/Scott
1 A It looks like Bruce Gordon, or something like that.
2 Q And what is the item there on 523?
3 A I am sorry?
4 Q What is the item there on 523.
5 A It is a strap. It is a Concord strap.
6 THE COURT: Concord, C O N C O R D?
7 THE WITNESS: Yes.
8 THE COURT: Strap?
9 THE WITNESS: Yes, 523, yes, strap.
10 Q What kind of strap is that?
11 THE COURT: Is that for a watch?
12 THE WITNESS: Yes, lady's.
13 THE COURT: Lady's watch?
14 THE WITNESS: Yes, lady's Concord watch.
15 Q What is the amount?
16 A $671.25.
17 Q What is the date that that item was purchased?
18 A March 18th, '95.
19 Q How was it paid for?
20 A By American Express card.
21 Q Now, looking at the other document,
22 Government's Exhibit 524, can you tell us the name of the
23 customer on that document?
24 A Same customer, Bruce Gordon.
25 Q What is the name of that document?
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
436
He-direct/Scott
1 A March 18th, '95, same day.
2 Q What is the item that was purchased?
3 A Auders Piaget, A U D E R, or something like that,
4 P I A G E T.
5 THE COURT: Is that a watch?
6 THE WITNESS: It is a watch.
7 Q Can you tell us the amount of money that was paid for
8 that item?
9 A The net amount is 1,500 -- I am sorry, $15,250.
10 That's the net amount. After trade in, there was a trade
11 in. The total amount should be $14,018.38.
12 Q Can you tell us how that item was paid for?
13 A By American Express card.
14 MS. SCOTT: I have no other questions. Thank
15 you, Ms. He.
16 MR. TRABULUS: I have no questions, thank you.
17 THE COURT: You may step down, Ms. He.
18 (Whereupon, at this time the witness left the
19 witness stand.)
20 THE COURT: Please call your next witness.
21 MR. WHITE: Your Honor, the government calls Fran
22 Gilberto.
23 THE COURT: Raise your right hand.
24
25
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
437
1 F R A N C I N E G I L B E R T O ,
2 called as a witness, having been first
3 duly sworn, was examined and testified
4 as follows:
5
6 THE COURT: Please be seated.
7 State your full name and spell your last name.
8 THE WITNESS: Francine Gilberto, G I L B E R T O.
9 THE COURT: You may proceed.
10 MR. WHITE: Thank you, your Honor.
11
12 DIRECT EXAMINATION
13 BY MR. WHITE:
14 Q Ms. Gilberto, can you tell us how you are employed?
15 A I am the credit manager for Tiffany & Company.
16 Q How long have you had that position?
17 A About 13 years.
18 Q Tell us what kind of merchandise Tiffany sells?
19 A Jewelry, crystal, china --
20 THE COURT: Would you pull the microphone closer
21 to you, Ms. Gilberto. And speak up.
22 THE WITNESS: Yes.
23 Q Can you tell us what sort of merchandise Tiffany's
24 sells?
25 A Jewelry, diamonds, silver, gold, flatware, china,
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL CO URT REPORTER
438
Gilberto-direct/White
1 crystal.
2 Q Are you familiar with Tiffany's record-keeping
3 procedures?
4 A Yes.
5 Q And when a customer makes a purchase at a Tiffany
6 store is there a receipt prepared?
7 A Yes.
8 Q Tell us how that happen?
9 A A salesman on a sales terminal when the customer
10 comes in the store, they are given a receipt. We request
11 a signature on the receipt, a portion is maintained for
12 the company and given to the customer.
13 Q How is the information entered on that receipt?
14 A All the merchandise is SKU'd. And the SKU is entered
15 on the point of sale terminal, along with a dollar amounts
16 and a brief description of the merchandise, total and tax
17 is on the receipt.
18 Q Tell us what you mean by a SKU?
19 A SKU is a identification number given for all the
20 merchan dise for back end systems to identify the piece,
21 description associated with it, the appropriate dollar
22 amount associated with that piece.
23 Q It is a numerical code identifying a particular piece
24 of merchandise?
25 A Correct.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
439
Gilberto-direct/White
1 Q Okay.
2 If you could please take a look at
3 Government's Exhibits 515 and 516.
4 (Handed to the witness.)
5 Q Do you recognize those?
6 A Yes.
7 Q Can you tell us what they are?
8 A These are Tiffany sales audit receipts. This is the
9 portion that is maintained for the company records.
10 Q And were those receipts prepared in the manner you
11 described before?
12 A Yes.
13 Q Is it the regular practice of Tiffany's to make and
14 keep such records?
15 A Yes.
16 Q Do you do that in the course of your regular
17 business?
18 A Yes.
19 MR. WHITE: Your Honor, the government offers
20 Exhibits 515 and 516.
21 THE COURT: Any objection?
22 MR. TRABULUS: No objection.
23 THE COURT: Government's Exhibits 515 and 516 in
24 evidence.
25 (Government's Exhibit 515 received in evidence.)
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
440
Gilberto-direct/White
1 (Government's Exhibit 516 received in evidence.)
2 Q Now, if you would take a look, please at Exhibit 515;
3 can you tell us first of all what the name of the customer
4 is?
5 A Bruce W. Gordon.
6 Q And is there a date -- what is the date of the
7 transaction?
8 A 12/26/94.
9 Q Would you tell us the items purchased were?
10 A Fashion earrings, and five Tiffany Classics.
11 Q Do you recall what type of merchandis e Tiffany
12 Classics are?
13 A This particular one I have looked into it as
14 earrings.
15 Q And the other item that was purchased was what kind
16 of merchandise?
17 A Fashion earrings also.
18 Q And can you tell us how much each of those costs?
19 A Fashion earrings were $1,025, Tiffany Classics was
20 $700.
21 Q Now, if you can take a look at Exhibit 516; can you
22 tell us the customer on that?
23 A Bruce W. Gordon.
24 Q And the date of that purchase?
25 A 12/26/94.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
441
Gilberto-direct/White
1 Q And what were the items purchased?
2 A This is Picasso silver.
3 Q And do you know what sort of merchandise that is?
4 A Earrings.
5 Q And how much did those earrings cost?
6 A $375.
7 Q And how were those earrings paid for?
8 A American Express card.
9 Q And does the receipt reflect the card member name?
10 A Yes.
11 Q What does it say?
12 A Bruce W. Gordon.
13 Q Going back to 515, does it reflect how the
14 merchandise was paid for?
15 A American Express.
16 Q Again, who was the credit card account holder?
17 A Bruce W. Gordon.
18 MR. WHITE: No further questions, your Honor.
19 MR. TRABULUS: Thank you for coming.
20 No questions.
21 (Whereupon, at this time the witness left the
22 witness stand.)
23 THE COURT: Please call your next witness.
24 MR. WHITE: The government calls Ben Youdim,
25 Y O U D I M.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
442
1 THE COURT: Step up, raise your right hand.
2
3 B E H R O U Z Y O U D I M ,
4 called as a witness, having been first
5 duly sworn, was examin ed and testified
6 as follows:
7
8 THE COURT: Please be seated. State your full
9 name and spell your last name.
10 THE WITNESS: Yes. My full name is Behrouz
11 Youdim.
12 THE COURT: Spell both names.
13 THE WITNESS: B E H R O U Z, last name is
14 Y O U D I M.
15 THE COURT: N as in Negative?
16 THE WITNESS: M like Mary.
17 THE COURT: All right.
18 THE COURT: You may proceed.
19
20 DIRECT EXAMINATION
21 BY MR. WHITE:
22 Q Mr. Youdim, can you tell us what you do for a living?
23 A I own a store in Great Neck, sir.
24 Q And can you tell us the name of the store?
25 A Perucci Clothing.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
443
Youdim-direct/White
1 THE COURT: How do you spell that?
2 THE WITNESS: P E R U C C I.
3 THE COURT: Perucci Clothing?
4 THE W ITNESS: Yes, sir.
5 THE COURT: That's the name of your store?
6 THE WITNESS: That's the store that used to
7 belong to me and a partner, which is no longer in
8 existence.
9 THE COURT: The store is no longer in existence?
10 THE WITNESS: The store was closed last
11 September.
12 Q When did you first open Perucci Clothing?
13 A In September of 1980.
14 Q Can you tell us what type of business Perucci
15 clothing was?
16 A Men's Italian clothing.
17 Q Now, are you familiar with the record keeping
18 procedures employed at Perucci Clothing?
19 A Yes, I am.
20 Q And when a customer made a purchase at Perucci
21 Clothing, was a receipt prepared?
22 A Yes.
23 Q Can you tell us how that worked?
24 A The receipt is a combination of total purchases, and
25 also it shows the way the payment was paid.
HARRY RAPAPORT , CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
444
Youdim-direct/White
1 Q And who would record the information on that receipt?
2 A Whoever was waiting on a customer.
3 Q The employee?
4 A The employee or the owner, yes.
5 Q And what sort of information would be recorded?
6 A Usually first name, last name, telephone number.
7 Q And what information regarding the merchandise
8 purchased would be recorded?
9 A It would be recorded as to how it was paid.
10 Q Would the particular type of merchandise that was
11 being purchased be included on the receipt?
12 A Yes.
13 Q And after the receipt was prepared, what would
14 Perucci do with the copy of it?
15 A The copy would stay in the book.
16 Q In what book?
17 A The sales book.
18 Q Would you maintain that book with the receipts?
19 A Yes, we try to keep a good record, yes.
2 0 Q And if you can take a look at Exhibits 495, 496, 497,
21 498, 499, and 500 and 501.
22 If you can take a look at each one of those,
23 please.
24 (Handed to the witness.)
25 A Yes, sir.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
445
Youdim-direct/White
1 Q Could you tell us what those are.
2 A This is not my handwriting. It is my ex-partner's
3 handwriting. And this just says a coat --
4 THE COURT: No, what are they? Are they letters,
5 deeds to property? What are they?
6 THE WITNESS: This is a sales receipt, sir.
7 Q From Perucci Clothing?
8 A Yes.
9 Q And if you look at the last document there, 501, do
10 you see that?
11 MR. WHITE: Your Honor, if it is all right with
12 you, I will stay here?
13 THE COURT: Sure.
14 Q Tell us what 501 is?
15 A A receipt for American Express.
16 Q For a purchase at Perucci Clothing?
17 A Correct.
18 Q Was it Perucci's regular practice to keep those types
19 of records like 495 through 501?
20 A Yes.
21 Q Did you do that as part of your regular business?
22 A Yes, I did.
23 MR. WHITE: Your Honor, the government will offer
24 495 through 501.
25 THE COURT: Is it 495 or 496?
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
446
Youdim-direct/White
1 MR. WHITE: Let me check, I am sorry.
2 MR. WHITE: 495, 96, 97, 98, 99, 500 and 501.
3 THE COURT: Any objection?
4 MR. TRABULUS: No.
5 THE COURT: Government's Exhibits 495 through 501
6 in evidence.
7 (Government's Exhibits 495 through 501 received
8 in evidence.)
9 Q Mr. Youdim, if you can take the top one, 495, could
10 you tell us the date of that purchase?
11 A November 30th, of 1 990.
12 Q And can you tell us who the customer was.
13 A Again, this is not my handwriting, but it says, and
14 looks like Bruce Gordon.
15 Q And does the receipt indicate the items purchased?
16 A Yes, it does.
17 Q Can you tell us what they are?
18 A A black coat. It looks like a camel coat.
19 Q And could you tell us the cost of each of those
20 coats?
21 A The first one is 895. The second one is 850.
22 THE COURT: Do you want to pull the microphone
23 closer, Mr. Youdim.
24 Now, if you can take a look at 496, can you tell
25 us the date of that purchase.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
447
Youdim-direct/White
1 THE WITNESS: November 30th, of 1990.
2 Q And the customer?
3 A Again, not my handwriting, but it says Bruce Gordon.
4 Q And does it indicate the items purchased?
5 A Slack s, shirts, total.
6 Q What is the total cost?
7 A 705, plus tax, 761.
8 Q Okay.
9 Take a look at 497, the date of that purchase.
10 A 12/11 of 1990.
11 Q And the customer?
12 A Bruce Gordon.
13 Q And what are the items purchased?
14 A Suit.
15 Q Can you tell us how much the suit cost?
16 A 845.
17 Q What else?
18 A Blazer and another blazer.
19 Q How much did the two blazers cost?
20 A 695 and 675.
21 Q And what is the total, the grand total?
22 A 2392.
23 Q Take a look at 498. What is the date of that
24 purchase?
25 A 10/8 of 1990.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
448
Youdim-direct/White
1 Q And the customer?
2 A Again, not my handwriting, but it says Bruce Gordon.
3 Q And the items purchased?
4 A Jackets, jacket, jacket, pants, ties.
5 Q And what time to time grand total for the purchases?
6 A 6535.
7 Q That's 6,535?
8 A Correct.
9 Q Take a look at 499. What is the date of that
10 purchase?
11 A November 17th, of 1990.
12 Q Does it indicate the customer?
13 A Not readable.
14 Q Okay.
15 Is there any indication underneath the customer
16 line for address, that indicates who the customer might
17 be?
18 A There is a note saying who is who.
19 Q Who is who?
20 A Uh-huh.
21 Q Can you tell us what the items purchased were?
22 A It looks like jackets.
23 Q Give us the grand total.
24 A 1452.
25 Q Mr. Youdim, let me show you
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
449
Youdim-direct/White
1 Government's Exhibit 499-A.
2 Would you take a look at that.
3 Would you tell us what that is?
4 A Certified check.
5 Q And if you look on the back, do you recognize
6 anything on the back?
7 A Yes, for deposit only, Perucci Clothing.
8 Q Do you recognize that as a check you received at
9 Perucci Clothing?
10 A It has our stamp on the back.
11 MR. WHITE: Your Honor, the government would
12 offer 499-A.
13 THE COURT: Any objection?
14 MR. TRABULUS: No.
15 THE COURT: Government's Exhibit 499-A in
16 evidence.
17 (Government's Exhibit 499-A received in
18 evidence.)
19 Q Could you read 499-A, and tell us what the date of a
20 the check is?
21 A 11/29 of 1990.
22 Q Could you tell us the amount?
23 A $1,458.
24 Q And who is the -- could you read the name upon whose
25 account is -- the check is written?
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
450
Youdim-direct/White
1 A It says Who's Who Worldwide.
2 Q Read the whole thing?
3 A Who's Who Worldwide Registry, Inc.
4 Q Now, if you can look at Exhibit 500, and tell us what
5 that is -- what is the date of that transaction?
6 A 4/24 of '91.
7 Q And the customer?
8 A It looks like Bruce Gordon.
9 Q And what was purchased?
10 A Jackets and ties.
11 Q And what was the grand total?
12 A 1815.
13 Q $1,815?
14 A Correct.
15 Q Finally, Exhibit 501. That's two American Express
16 charge slips; is that correct?
17 A Yes.
18 Q Tell us the date that corresponds to the top one?
19 A Issued on 12/18 of '91. The next one is 12/23 of
20 '91.
21 Q Can you tell us the amounts for each of those slips.
22 A $3,466.57. The second one is also the same,
23 $3,466.57.
24 MR. WHITE: Your Honor, I have no further
25 questions.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
451
Youdim-direct/White
1
2 CROSS-EXAMINATION
3 BY MR. TRABULUS:
4 Q Hello.
5 Very quickly, the last two that you read, do you
6 know if they were the same purchase, both for the same
7 amount?
8 A It couldn't be for the same purchase, no.
9 MR. TRABULUS: No further questions.
10 THE COURT: You may step down.
11 Please call your next witness.
12 (Whereupon, at this time the witness left the
13 witness stand.)
14 MS. SCOTT: Your Honor, unfortunately our next
15 and last witness has not appeared.
16 THE COURT: Has not appeared?
17 You have no other witnesses here?
18 MR. WHITE: We do not.
19 THE COURT: How distressing. Everybody else in
20 the room is happy except for me.
21 MR. WHITE: That's what we were afraid of, your
22 Hono r.
23 THE COURT: It is not good that I am unhappy.
24 It looks like, since I want to see everybody,
25 that we will be forced to take a half a day today.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
452
1 We are going to recess until Tuesday, because as
2 I told you, I have other matters on tomorrow. The weekend
3 will come then, and then we have a holiday on Monday. So
4 we will recess until Tuesday, which is, I believe, the
5 20th of January, 1998. Time goes by, at 9:30.
6 In the meantime, please do not discuss the case
7 either among yourselves or anyone else. Keep an open
8 mind. Come to no conclusions about anything.
9 Don't read any articles about this if there
10 should be. I have not seen any, but don't read any.
11 Because if you do I may have to call you in one by one and
12 question you about whether you read the articl e. And if
13 you did, whether it would affect you in this case. We
14 don't want to have to go through that whole procedure.
15 If you see anything like this, just pass over
16 it.
17 When you come back, the courtroom will be
18 considerably smaller, because we are going to close that
19 wall. We are going to do it probably for tomorrow. And
20 it will be more cozy that way, you see. We don't need all
21 of that space there.
22 I want to wish everybody a happy holiday on
23 Monday. Enjoy the holiday. We will all meet on Tuesday
24 the 18th.
25 A JUROR: The 20th.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
453
1 THE COURT: The 20th, why do I slip all the
2 time?
3 Do you want to pick up this exhibit, Mr. White,
4 please. These are yours.
5 You can put them right under your chair, and
6 leave the m there.
7 See you on Tuesday the 20th.
8 (Whereupon, at this time the jury leaves the
9 courtroom.)
10 THE COURT: Mr. White, while you put on a good
11 number of witnesses, we had 22 minutes to spare. We want
12 to get through with this case. You may not want to, but I
13 do.
14 MR. WHITE: I certainly do, your Honor.
15 THE COURT: Always consistent with a fair trial
16 and opportunity to be heard. But we have to move this
17 case along. And you have to have witnesses, extra
18 witnesses, more than you think are necessary, because
19 these things happen. We want to utilize all the time. We
20 have 18 people coming out of their life to come here, and
21 we want to get through with the case.
22 Now, also, we want to be punctual.
23 Now, there is a song I'm Old Fashioned. I don't
24 want to sing it for you. Some of you may not know the
25 song, because you are too young. But I want to start on
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
454
1 time. I will not tolerate any lateness. And if it
2 continues, even for a short while, I am going to impose
3 fines. I don't want to do that. But we want to start on
4 time.
5 We have 30, 35 people waiting. You are not
6 keeping one person waiting, you are keeping a whole bunch
7 of people. So I want to be on time.
8 Also, we come back from lunch, I want to be here
9 on time. It shouldn't take you an hour to eat lunch.
10 MR. SCHOER: Judge, can I speak to that? You may
11 not be finished. But I believe part of the problem we are
12 having on the breaks, and lunchtime, there are only seven
13 phones in this courthouse that are working, pay phones,
14 and there are ten of us, plus 18 jurors, and during the
15 break -- we have busy p ractices, your Honor knows that.
16 We have calls we have to make, and just to get back to our
17 offices to get messages.
18 In the ten minutes -- this morning I couldn't go
19 and get a phone during the ten minute break because it was
20 being used. In the afternoon I got two minutes on the
21 phone before I have to be back in here.
22 What we would like to ask collectively if your
23 Honor would ask the marshals to permit us to bring cell
24 phones into the courthouse to be able to use those. It
25 might facilitate us being on time.
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
455
1 THE COURT: I will ask them.
2 MR. SCHOER: Thank you.
3 THE COURT: But whether the phones are busy or
4 not busy; whether you have a busy practice, and I hope all
5 of you do, or not, I want to start on time.
6 Now, do we have to take up any thing,
7 Mr. Trabulus?
8 MR. TRABULUS: I would just ask the government to
9 identify the witnesses they will be calling on Tuesday.
10 MR. WHITE: I think we will have a couple of more
11 document custodians like these, and then Mr. Gordon's
12 sister, Joyce Grossman, and her husband, Dr. Richard
13 Grossman.
14 THE COURT: That's all?
15 MR. WHITE: They may take a while.
16 THE COURT: Suppose they don't take a while? Who
17 else do you have? I want to move the case along, the time
18 you estimated is too long. I don't think it will take too
19 long.
20 MR. WHITE: Judge, I have an outline of the order
21 of witnesses, I will speak to Mr. Trabulus and
22 Mr. Wallenstein, it only relates to them. I don't want to
23 take the Court's time in looking it up.
24 THE COURT: As I told you before, these people
25 will never testify in a case again durin g their entire
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
456
1 life. The reasonable life expectancy is about 85 today,
2 isn't it? This is an infinitesimal time in their life.
3 Have them here, if they have to come back, I will direct
4 them to come back if you don't want to.
5 MR. WHITE: I agree, your Honor, we had these
6 seven or eight people waiting here most of the day as
7 well.
8 THE COURT: I made no complaints, because we
9 moved very rapidly. But have enough witnesses, I don't
10 want to lose any time.
11 MR. WHITE: I will do my best.
12 MS. SCOTT: It was my witness, your Honor. He
13 was supposed to be here and didn't show. Your comments
14 should be directed at me.
15 THE COURT: Comments are not directed at
16 anybody. I want to make sure we do a good job and move
17 along, always consistent with a fair and full opportunity
18 to try your case.
19 We don't have to meet earlier than 9:30? Nobody
20 has problems?
21 See you at 9:30.
22 Have a nice weekend and holiday.
23 (Case on trial adjourned until 9:30 o'clock,
24 Monday, January 20th, 1998.)
25
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
457
1 I-N-D-E-X
2
W-I-T-N-E-S-S-E-S
3
PAGE LINE
4 F R A N K G A G L I A R D I.................. 246 1
DIRECT EXAMINATION (cont'd)....................... 246 11
5 CROSS-EXAMINATION................................. 295 23
VOIR DIRE EXAMINATION............................. 311 16
6 CROSS-EXAMINATION (cont'd)........................ 314 2
VOIR DIRE EXAMINATION............................. 318 1
7 CROSS-EXAMINATION (cont'd)........................ 321 10
CROSS-EXAMINATION................................. 331 7
8 REDIRECT EXAMINATION....... ....................... 340 9
REDIRECT EXAMINATION (cont'd)..................... 347 7
9 RECROSS-EXAMINATION............................... 363 19
RECROSS-EXAMINATION............................... 372 20
10 FURTHER REDIRECT EXAMINATION...................... 373 18
11 E D M O N D G A R A B E D I A N............... 374 19
DIRECT EXAMINATION................................ 375 5
12 CROSS-EXAMINATION................................. 404 15
REDIRECT EXAMINATION.............................. 406 21
13
P A U L H I R S H C L E I F E R............. 407 15
14 DIRECT EXAMINATION................................ 407 25
DIRECT EXAMINATION................................ 414 18
15
R O B E R T K I N G.......................... 421 19
16 DIRECT EXAMINATION................................ 422 6
17 J O A N N D E M P S E Y....................... 426 17
DIRECT EXAMINATION................................ 427 2
18 CROSS-EXAMINATION................... .............. 431 21
19 A I D O N G H E............................. 432 10
DIRECT EXAMINATION................................ 432 19
20
F R A N C I N E G I L B E R T O............... 437 1
21 DIRECT EXAMINATION................................ 437 12
22 B E H R O U Z Y O U D I M................... 442 3
DIRECT EXAMINATION................................ 442 20
23 CROSS-EXAMINATION................................. 451 2
24
25
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
458
1 E-X-H-I-B-I-T-S
2 Government's Exhibit 421 received in evidence..... 259 20
Government's Exhibit 421-A received in evidence... 260 4
3 Government's Exhibit 423 received in evidence..... 263 23
Government's Exhibits 423-A through 423-L
4 received in evidence.............................. 264 5
Government's Exhibit 424 received in evidence..... 269 4
5 Government's Exhibit 424-A received in ev idence... 269 13
Government's Exhibit 425 received in evidence..... 271 2
6 Government's Exhibits 425-A through 425-D
received in evidence.............................. 271 24
7 Government's Exhibit 499-1-A received in
evidence.......................................... 274 17
8 Government's Exhibit 426 received in evidence..... 279 16
Government's Exhibit 426-A received in evidence... 279 25
9 Government's Exhibit 428 received in evidence..... 288 20
Government's Exhibit 429 received in evidence..... 294 8
10 Government's Exhibit 409-A received in evidence... 351 15
Government's Exhibit 409 received in evidence..... 355 15
11 Government's Exhibit 416 received in evidence..... 358 25
Government's Exhibit 417 received in evidence..... 359 1
12 Government's Exhibit 764 received in evidence..... 362 22
Government's Exhibit 765 received in evidence..... 362 23
13 Government's Exhibits 430 through 482 received
in evidence........................... ............ 377 18
14 Government's Exhibit 824-A received in evidence... 382 18
Government's Exhibit 441-A received in evidence... 388 12
15 Government's Exhibit 467-A received in evidence... 392 1
Government's Exhibit 474-A received in evidence... 394 24
16 Government's Exhibit 475-A received in evidence... 398 5
Government's Exhibits 825 through 834 received
17 in evidence....................................... 401 16
Government's Exhibits 504 through 514 received
18 in evidence....................................... 411 15
Government's Exhibit 483 received in evidence..... 417 7
19 Government's Exhibit 484 received in evidence..... 417 8
Government's Exhibits 521 through 522-A received
20 in evidence....................................... 424 18
Government's Exhibit 517 through 520-A received
21 in evidence....................................... 429 7
Government's Exhibit 523 received in evidence..... 434 18
22 Government's Exhibit 524 re ceived in evidence..... 434 19
Government's Exhibit 515 received in evidence..... 439 25
23 Government's Exhibit 516 received in evidence..... 440 1
Government's Exhibits 495 through 501 received
24 in evidence....................................... 446 7
Government's Exhibit 499-A received in evidence... 449 17
25
HARRY RAPAPORT, CSR, CP, CM OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
|
|
| The List Transcript USA's Best Managing Directors Dirty Jury? Politics |
| The List Transcript USA's Best Managing Directors Dirty Jury? Politics |
This site is concerned with the Who's Who Worldwide Registry tragedy, and the double scandal of government and judical corruption in one of the dirtiest trials of the twentieth century and the concomitant news media blackout regarding this incredible story.
Sixteen weeks of oft-explosive testimony, yet not a word in any of 1200 news archives. This alone supports the claim that this was a genuinely dirty trial; in fact, one of the dirtiest federal trials of the 20th century.
Show your support for justice, for exoneration of the innocent, and perhaps most importantly, government accountability, by urgently contacting your Senator, the White House, and the U.S. Department of Justice.